A Sad Day for Goodison's FA Cup Farewell

posted by Danny ONeill
21 Comments

1906, 1933, 1966, 1984, 1995. 

 Read that last year closely. Next year will be 30 years since we last won a trophy. 

 I don't need to tell this audience or the most hardened Evertonian that. We are fast approaching 40 years since our last league title triumph. I shouldn't mention Europe, but I just have. Our one and only continental triumph now also approaching 30 years, although circumstances dictated that one of the best teams in our club's history was denied the opportunity to capitalise and build on that success. 

 Let's face it, since the heady days of the 80s, apart from that brief spike under Joe Royle, the running of our once proud club has been in steady, decline. To the cynics, it was almost planned. Failure to invest. Failed stadium projects to either redevelop or move from our still current home that should have been planned and delivered starting 30 years ago. 

 It hurts. It hurts a lot. But we keep going and selling out every fixture, home and away, weeks in advance, often within hours of tickets going on sale. We have over 30,000 on the season ticket waiting list. Anyway, back to yesterday. 

 A pit stop at the Harlech Castle and quick chat with Bill and Mark, who had left his 5* cuisine (!!!!) to meet up before being joined by Neil. My son and brother were outside sorting their tickets out on the Apple wallet and then we headed to take our places in the growing queues. I once again, just made the siren. Fortunately my seat was the first on the row, immediately to the right of an entrance / exit, so I didn't disrupt anyone. 

 A lot has been said about the match and the players, with most being in broad agreement of what they witnessed. At half-time, a feeling of "a bad day at the office". The team hadn't shown up or competed. Gone was the intensity. The pressing witnessed for the majority of the past few weeks went AWOL. Once again, the ball was like a hot potato. Despite seeing Beto score a brace last week by playing him though, we reverted to using him as a target man, with his back to goal most of the time. He doesn't hold it up and isn't a target man. 

 We seemed to settle okay for about first 15 minutes, but with little end product. Ndiaye, went close, but rather than go for goal, I did think that he could perhaps have pulled it back for Beto and another runner at the back post. Gradually, it descended into a scrappy Everton performance, littered with basic mistakes. Bournemouth simply contained us and absorbed what little we did throw at them, and started to take over the game, hitting us with two sucker punches. Our defence was increasingly struggling with the pace of Bournemouth's 21 & 24. 

 From where I was sat, Tarkowski was too high up the pitch for their first goal, and the sequence of events unfolded right in front of me. As the first ball went to their winger, the forward drifted into the space vacated by our Captain. Jebbison was in and, in his desperation to make amends, the experienced skipper made what can only be described as a stupid tackle; penalty. There was a shout for offside and I think VAR would have looked at it, although it would have been marginal. No complaints about the penalty decision though. The scorer (24) thundered towards the ball and put it away. Pickford chose correctly and was there, but there was simply too much pace and power on the strike. 

 The second came from a ridiculous attempt of a cross-field switch pass from, yes, the man of the moment Tarkowski. Instead of the intended target, the ball kindly fell to a grateful Bournemouth player. Next thing we know, the ball is in our 6-yard box and what ensued can only be described as a sketch straight from the Benny Hill school of football defending. The ball fell to Jebbison after a deflected shot, which he put towards goal. I may not get universal agreement, but I thought the keeper was unfortunate. He saved from point blank range, only for the ball to go straight back to the striker, who "kneed" it into the net with, I think, 3 Everton defenders around him, who could do nothing.  

 As the half came to an end and the players made their way down the tunnel, you could hear the restlessness and displeasure of the natives, some booing. 

 The teams came back out and thoughts turned to how would we react in the second half after the debacle of the first? As the saying goes, it was a game of two halves. Everton took the game to Bournemouth and although the visitors still posed a threat, the blues were now increasingly testing their resolve to hold onto their lead. We came very close, hitting the post three times. But not close enough and as the clock ran down, but a much improved performance and effort, which was given some appreciation from the Goodison support. 

 

Some teams can make a comeback from 2 – 0 down. We can't right now. This current team needs to get its noses in front as we simply lack the attacking options or goal threat to recover, particularly against better teams. And forget the name, history or size of club, Bournemouth are a better team than Everton. The table and recent results do not lie. 

 

The players: 

 

Pickford. Despite the penalty and second goal, it didn't feel like he had a lot to do. A decent diving punched save in the 2nd half. There was a moment when he seemed to flap at a stray ball that seemed to be bearing down on the cross bar. Could he have left it? Caught it? It was down the other end, so I'm not sure. He pushed it over the bar for a corner. Maybe flashbacks from that infamous Anfield moment? 

 O'Brien. Not his best game, but in his defence, he isn't a right back, was dealing with their best player who had place to burn and his captain inside him didn't offer much support or protection, frequently playing him into trouble. 

 Tarkowski. Now, he wasn't playing well earlier in the season, but that is the worst I've seen him play. He couldn't do anything right. The message I received about him at half-time simply read "he's stinking the place out". 

 Branthwaite. Probably our best defender, although there wasn't much competition and most of their threat was coming down our right. How he didn't score had me lost for words. Instead, it came off the woodwork and fell to a grateful keeper. 

 Young. Didn't do a lot wrong. Steady if somewhat unspectacular.

Gueye. Not at his best, but neither was the team. Not at his worse. I thought some of the comments I read were harsh and miss the important, unglamorous work he does. He remains an important player for us. 

 

Garner. He did okay, but showed us what he can do when he came on at Brighton and last week against Leicester. He wasn't there yesterday, but again, neither was the team. 

 Doucoure. No 10 second goal this week. Just Doucoure. 

 Ndiaye. Tricky, persistent. One of the few who stood out once we showed up. 

 Lindstrom. Back to earlier in the season Lindstrom. Void of confidence and ideas, but he still has a part to play in the remainder of this season. 

 Beto. I'm going to defend him here. He'll never be prolific and probably won't be here next season. But having shown what he can be capable of if the ball is played through to him. Maybe Bournemouth's resolute organisation prevented that, but we reverted to using him as a target man with his back to goal, rendering him ineffective. 

 Alcaraz (Sub) I think we're going to like him. That free kick, that he won and took, was sublime. The keeper was rooted like an oak tree as it rattled the post. Another that I was convinced was going to make the net bulge. Apparently he can be a hothead, which isn't a bad thing. My brother has declared him a dead cert for a red card in the Derby!! 

 Harrison (Sub). Best I've seen him play in a long time. I'm still screaming for him to be played on the left, but he done well when he came on and hit the post with, what was a good cross that bypassed everyone, keeper included. I was ready to celebrate that one too!! 

 Keane (Sub). Even though in another part of the ground, I could hear my son groan as he came on and the crowd chanted his name! Took up the Mick Lyons / Steve Watson role as improvised striker. Not on long enough to make too much of an impact. 

 One of my less eventful trips, but there were still moments. 

 Even by my standards, that was an early start. Up at 5am to get the dog out in the rain and dark. We had to take her to the son's girlfriend's, who were looking after her whilst we went to the match. We departed for London to navigate the engineering works between Stafford and Crewe. Having been advised to change at Stafford, we noticed there was a Glasgow train; first stop Crewe. Bonus. A quick change onto a train that only stopped at Runcorn, South Parkway, Mossley Hill and into Lime Street.  

 We were there an hour earlier than planned at 12:30, so went to catch some of the Leyton Orient v Manchester City match whilst waiting for my brother, who said he would be at the station by 1pm. By 1:40pm no sign despite repeated attempts to find him, we were on the brink of heading to the ground. We eventually found him and jumped a taxi to County road. 

 

After the match, we'd agreed to meet at the Oak. The atmosphere walking (not marching Mark) down Goodison Road and Spellow Lane and in the Oak, was interesting. No despair, quite relaxed and even slightly good humoured in places. 

 We decided to try and flag a black cab down. It usually comes in at less than £10, which I always leave the driver with. We managed to stop one who said he would take us to Lime Street. I'm not even sure if he was a taxi, and as we went to get in, he stopped and asked how many of us there were. When we said 3, he informed us it would be £30. The cheeky (expletive) was trying to charge us £10 each. The other two walked off to find another one. I remained at the driver's window, exchanging a few expletive laden opinions of his business model before being told by the two youngsters to leave it and got called over like a bad dog!! 

 

One last random thought that I forgot to mention last week and noticed again on the highlights late last night when we got back. With that hat, Peter Reid looks like a character from the Untouchables. Not a bad comparison considering that great side he was an integral part of. 

 So, no FA Cup for Goodison in her last season. We'll have to wait for it to be paraded around Bramley Moore, when we finally add a 6th to our tally. I'm actually looking forward to the new stadium. We need to move on. Respect our past, but look to the future. The new stadium is central to that. The new owners, who I assume are keeping their powder dry until our top flight status is confirmed, may come out with their vision for the club and back this up with funding in the summer to put the playing squad into a much better position to compete and develop.  

 For now, our focus is simple; stay in the top flight of English football. This current team has one job, one objective. No excuses, it starts Wednesday. If some are not feeling up for it, let me know. Then onto Palace next weekend to meet with John. Mark will be there too. I've promised that I will find Selhurst Park this time as last time out, I walked in circles before finally giving in and asking the police where the ground was. I was only a mile out heading in the wrong direction!! 

 I for one, did not get carried away with recent results. They were important wins and gave us breathing space, but the job isn't done yet. That was a wakeup call and we must avoid complacency.  

 It's difficult to pick a man-of-the match from that, so I'll go for best of the rest of the second half. A promising cameo from Charly, but I think, once again, I'll go for Ndiaye. I think a 3 of Ndiaye, Garner and Charly is as good as we can muster for now, with the options we have. 

10 February, 2025 at 10:16 am


Comments

Derek Knox 1 
10/02/2025 at 10:41:23

Wow Danny, a good article there mate. I was as disappointed as most, after seemingly put our demons to rest, confidence restored, I fancied a hard fought win. I know I keep going on about him, but Doucoure is a wasted shirt and contributes nothing to attack. He is supposed to be an attacking midfielder. What one goal every 20 months or so ?

Hopefully a reality check for most of our players, but let's win our last Derby at Goodison as that F A Cup run has been extinguished, No Doucoure from now on !

Andy Duff 2 
10/02/2025 at 11:47:10

Great article. Is there a way to change the Thread it is in Transfers section not Match report

Mark Murphy 3 
10/02/2025 at 14:28:05

That 5* cuisine turned out to be thick sliced sarnies mate. Its no longer a tapas bar!
My last ever cup game at Goodison was ruined by the ceiling of the lower Glwadys. I'm very much looking forward to BMD now.
Hoping for at least one more home game before the doors close but only if I can get a good seat.
I may have a "cunning plan" for the Soton game but it depends on a Saints fan's kindness. At least if needed I know the words to their song...another song about marching but far better than that dirge about candles and black out curtains...
see you in South Croydon, if you can find it..
UTFT

Danny ONeill 4 
10/02/2025 at 14:41:38

I can't see it Andy. There were only 3 options and the Match Review drop down is where Lyndon put his and transferred a few over from TW.

Maybe I've missed something or there are just a few to be expected teething problems as with any transition.

Mark, stay in touch. Well, we've no choice really, as, subject to my navigational skills, we're meeting on Saturday with John Raftery!!

Ja Bet 5 
10/02/2025 at 16:04:02

Always enjoy Danny, please keep reporting.
I can not get to games anymore so on reading your reports, I feel like I am walking alongside you. I am positive about wednesday game.
Come on you blues.

Lynn Maher 6 
10/02/2025 at 16:41:56

Always look forward to your reports Danny. This was exceptionally good. Keep them coming please.
Although we didn't win, for the first time in ages, we didn't feel as down, as in previous months, when leaving the ground.
I am convinced there is a glimmer of hope.
Wednesday should be interesting!

Ted Roberts 7 
10/02/2025 at 17:01:31

Danny,once again a great account of your trials and tribulations of the day.I witnessed it all from a back row seat in the main stand,where I actually stood up for the whole game, and saw everything,( except a Blues score obviously)thanks to an unobstructed view.The first half left me deflated,as it did to the majority of the attendance,but the second half effort had me leaving the Old Lady with a slightly more optimistic outlook for forthcoming games.For whatever reason,Saturday was not to be our day,but Wednesday’s match is not filling me with dread,and I think we can notch up a few more positive results before we move out for good.Hopefully I will get the chance of one more visit to Goodison,after all,my first visit in 1970 was a 5-2 victory over Chelsea,so I would love it to end on a victory also.Take care and much respect for your travels and match day accounts.COYB

Jonathan Harding 8 
10/02/2025 at 17:09:18

Thanks Danny. I go to far fewer games than you but was stood in the middle of the Lower Gwladys on Saturday.

Bournemouth just sat back and asked “what have you got?”. The answer for 45 minutes was nothing. It took me a while to work out why. We were playing them with 10 men. Doucoure did nothing to help out Beto and nor did he drop deep to bolster midfield. He was simply absent.

And when you add in Ashley Young conserving his energy and doing no more than just holding his defensive position it was effectively nine-and-a-half men.

Now Jordan Pickford is a great keeper and a good lad but won’t make a future manager. Surely with his experience he could have surmised the short stuff was not working. He needed to take some responsibility and clear it long. He didn’t and Tarks suffered along with nearly 40,000 Evertonians inside Goodison.

Keep the reports coming Danny. All the best!

And PS Mark Murphy – if you have a Lower Gwladys ticket make sure it’s from row Z forward. They’d have to pay me to take anything from AA upwards such is the atrocious view.

Danny ONeill 9 
10/02/2025 at 18:28:13

Thanks all,

I did forget to mention the group of Bournemouth supporters in the same carriage for the return journey.

One of them was the father of their promising young Dutch defender Dean Huijsen. I looked him up. Born in the Netherlands and represented them at U-16 through U-19 level. As his family moved to Spain when he was very young, he acquired Spanish citizenship and now represents Spain U-21s. Still only 19.

He came through at Juventus, followed by a loan spell at AS Roma before signing for Bournemouth.

His dad played for Jong Ajax, their academy / U-21s and AZ Alkmaar I believe.

Paul Ferry 10 
10/02/2025 at 18:48:32

Sort of player that we ought to be tracking Danny (9). Thanks for your as ever enjoyable report. I think you said somewhere that you had also sent it to Toffeeweb's new thingies. If so, I see it has not been posted yet. "Yet" being the operative word but it would be some sort of reassurance to see it there.

My own feeling now, is that Lyndon's forum with its greater range and easy format will soon take over as others see how poster-friendly it is.

Thanks LL!

Danny ONeill 11 
10/02/2025 at 18:51:59

Paul, it went up on Evertonia straight away without being vetted.

It hasn't yet appeared on TW.

Paul Ferry 12 
10/02/2025 at 19:47:54

Let that be a litmus paper test then Danny. If your match report is not posted that will tell us an awful lot.

That FA cup draw! Feck. It could well have been our Wembley year.

Paul Ferry 13 
10/02/2025 at 19:49:19

Ah Danny, it's 2025! It will be thirty years this year since we last won something. Our longest ever drought, needless to say.

Peter Moore 14 
10/02/2025 at 21:55:06

Enjoyed reading that Danny, despite the result being a crap way to end the history of FA Cup matches at GP.
Everything metaphorically crossed for defeating the shite on Wednesday, under the lights.
COYB.

Andy Crooks 15 
10/02/2025 at 00:00:04

Great report, Danny, hope to catch up with you at the United game

Larry O'Hara 16 
11/02/2025 at 01:22:15

Danny (11) that is worrying: if Toffeeweb doesnt host articles like yours they have signed their cyber death warrant…

Mike Gaynes 17 
11/02/2025 at 01:25:53

Danny, superb work as usual. You always make me feel like I'm at the game with you!

Incidentally, right after you mentioned Dean Huijsen, ESPN posted an article saying that Real Madrid and Manchester United will be fighting over him come summer, and other articles say Bayern and Chelsea will be in for him as well. Mr. Huijsen's lad is about to be very, very wealthy.

Paul Ferry 18 
11/02/2025 at 03:49:12

Agree Larry (16). And this is surely the result of their appalling lack of communication and information and appalling lack of knowledge of what TWEB is and its culture.

Duncan McDine 19 
11/02/2025 at 15:40:33

Nice one Danny.

On the subject of Toffeeweb and it's new owners, I am remaining open minded and willing to give them a fair chance.

My first impressions are that it's now dogshit.

Duncan McDine 20 
11/02/2025 at 15:46:06

To add some context: 504 Gateway Time-out
nginx

That should say enough

Antony Abrahams 21 
11/02/2025 at 21:29:30

I’m not one for snitching Danny, but any cab driver who is at it like that mate, just take the number off either the inside or the plate on the back of the cab.

I went to Milton Keynes and was fuming because you had to change trains if you were going to or coming from London, via Liverpool, but all the Manchester trains got a straight run Danny.

This is why you must have thought the disruption was between Stafford and Crewe, when the problem was between Northampton and Rugby, according to what was said over the tannoy of the Manchester to London train, that I had to pick up.

The diversion took me past Villa Pk, so maybe your partners team will win the cup this year mate💙 and she will see that Everton can take it off them next year🤞

Tomorrow is another day and now it’s getting closer….please Everton, make it a night to remember for all the right reasons


Add your response

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.