There was a lot to question about Sean Dyche as he toiled through his final few months at Everton but the more time goes on, the bigger mystery that surrounds his treatment of Jake O’Brien becomes. The Republic of Ireland international arrived last summer as the Blues’ most expensive acquisition of the transfer window at £17m but didn’t start a Premier League game until David Moyes arrived more than six months later.

In between, the young centre-back made a couple of solid appearances in the Carabao Cup that had fans wondering why he hadn’t been given more opportunities sooner, particularly when Jarrad Branthwaite was battling injury early in the season.

Now, of course, O’Brien is thriving as a makeshift right-back and two and a half weeks after coming up with an equaliser at Brentford, he struck again, this time in stoppage time against West Ham as Everton clawed back a point having failed to maintain their first-half intensity in a disappointingly flat second period. Just as importantly, he was one of the better performers on the day, suggesting that he has a very bright future at the Club, no matter where in the back line he is eventually deployed.

Moyes is, no doubt, using the final few weeks of the campaign to continue his fact-finding mission as he plans for his first full season back in charge and there will have been plenty of food for thought based on this performance. Beto, unfortunately, has lapsed back into the awkward, clumsy fit at centre-forward, Jack Harrison struggled back on the right flank and was rightly substituted, and Abdoulaye Doucouré provided plenty of energy but not much else.

It meant that for all of Everton’s energy and intensity in the first 45 minutes — both of which were markedly absent after the interval until Tomáš Souček’s 67th-minute goal and Moyes’s changes spurred them back into action — there wasn’t much in the way of end product.

With Doucouré selected again in the “number 10” role, Charly Alcaraz deployed wide on the left and Harrison swapping flanks, the Toffees started in what has become familiar fashion since Moyes returned — strong in the press and controlling the direction of the game and neat footwork by Harrison after he had been found by Alcaraz ended with a blocked shot as the first salvo of the contest after eight minutes.

The Hammers didn’t have an attack of note until the 12 minutes had elapsed but they almost went ahead from their first corner when Branthwaite directed a header towards his own goal and forced a reaction save from Jordan Pickford. On the whole, though, it was the hosts carrying the threat and a flurry of crosses in a six-minute spell midway through the half seemed to signal the manager’s key strategy in trying to force home the opening goal.

Harrison cut inside and swung a ball to the back post but Alcaraz’s header was saved; then after a mistake by the visitors was pounced upon, the on-loan winger chipped a ball in for Doucouré but he couldn’t get enough on his header to trouble Alphonse Areola.

Two chances then fell to Beto from either flank, O’Brien whipping a cross that the Portuguese powered over and Vitalii Mykolenko picking him out but the resulting header dropped onto the stanchion behind the goal. And, finally, O’Brien beautifully worked space for another delivery but, again, Doucouré couldn’t get enough purchase on the ball.

Always a threat for Graham Potter’s man, Jarod Bowen had a rare chance at one end with a half-volley that Pickford palmed over before O’Brien lined up a laser effort that Areola beat away but as the clock ticked to 45 minutes, Everton were awarded a penalty when Beto went down in the box under the attentions of Konstantinos Mavropanos.

Referee, Darren Bond, had had a shocker to that point and it turned out that his decision to penalise the Greek defender was another poor decision because, after the VAR had directed him to the pitch-side monitor, he was able to see that the striker had kicked the turf while trying to swivel onto a shot rather than being fouled.

Despite the disappointment of having had a penalty decision reversed in successive home games, there was enough in the first 45 minutes to suggest that the Blues might have enough to eventually go on and win the game if they just kept at it — at least until the likes of Armando Broja and Jesper Lindstrøm came on to offer a different dimension.

Frustratingly, it was West Ham who emerged from the break with the greater purpose while Everton seemed to have lost theirs and the longer the second half wore on, the more it felt as though the game from the home team’s perspective was waiting on those substitutions.

Increasingly, Potter’s men showed more composure and quality on the ball and when Emerson was played in behind by Soucek and he centred for Bowen, Pickford was relieved when the attempted overhead kick by then Hammers’ “false nine” hit his own hand rather than testing the goalkeeper.

Just past the hour mark, Bowen’s drive from a tight angle was parried to safety but after Everton were unable to repel a sustained attack and when Bowen powered his way past O’Brien and slipped the ball to Souček, the Czech worked space for a well-placed snapshot that he swept past the unsighted Pickford and into the far corner.

Moyes, who had been waiting for a couple of minutes for the ball the go dead so he could introduce Lindstrøm for Doucouré, duly made that change before the restart but, for the first few minutes at least it was still the visiting side in the driver’s seat.

Pickford spilled another low shot from Bowen after James Tarkowski had cheaply given the ball away in his own half and then saved Souček’s back-post header to ensure that it remained only 1-0.

Everton re-discovered some of their mojo, though, and Harrison was unlucky that his well-struck volley cannoned off Emerson and behind with a quarter of an hour to go. And when a triple-change that saw Beto, Harrison and the sub-par James Garner replaced by Broja, Youssef Chermiti and Tim Iroegbunam, the pendulum swung the Blues’ way.

Still, it didn’t look as though it was going to be their day. Chermiti had an 84th-minute shot blocked but the resulting corner came to nothing and it was until the game had moved into injury time that the equaliser finally arrived.

Mykolenko’s cross was blocked behind, the corner was cleared but when it was recycled by the Toffees, Chermiti had a cracking effort beaten away by Areola. Still Everton kept it and when Alcaraz crossed towards the back post, Idrissa Gueye’s volleyed it back across goal where O’Brien was perfectly placed to nod home emphatically from close range.

Even better almost followed with one of the last kicks of the game. Once more, the impressive Chermiti was involved as he jumped with his marker for a bouncing ball on the edge of the West Ham area and Alcaraz seized on the loose ball behind the defence. Agonisingly, with just the keeper in front of him, the Argentine screwed his effort just wide of the target and the three points went begging.

As dramatic as that would have been as a finalé, a draw was probably a fair result. Coming into this weekend, no team in the Premier League had drawn more games than Everton and they have now extended their tally to 13 for the season. Today, they were curiously flat in the second half but at least found a way back into the game in time to salvage a point.

Moyes may still be able to lay claim to Everton’s longest unbeaten run for eight years but his team have now tied four of their last five fixtures keeping them hovering in the middle of the bottom half rather than pressing for a place in the top half of the Premier League.

Thankfully, survival is all but guaranteed but in terms of entertainment for supporters, particularly in these final matches at Goodison Park, it’s a little frustrating, with thoughts turning to those impactful players yet to return from injury in the hope that they can spark the side back to winning ways.



Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Frank Sheppard
16/03/2025    08:33:17

A satisfactory result in that a draw was all we deserved, and the impressive unbeaten run continues.
I thought the Manager of the Month curse had struck until the excellent equaliser.
DM probably learned a lot today, in terms of several players perhaps “reverting to type” but others making good impact from the bench.

2  Peter Mills
16/03/2025    08:48:38

Pure speculation on my part:- Seamus Coleman had a chat with Sean Dyche.

“There’s a cracking player in Ireland, great prospect, you’ve got to get him while you can”.

Dyche:- “I don’t need a 6ft 6in centre back, and we haven’t got £17m”.

Thelwell signs him. Dyche takes the hump, doesn’t play him, prefers to make a point by playing Ashley Young.

There was a slight end of season feel to Goodison yesterday. Due to the generosity of one of the guys who sits behind me, I managed to get a ticket for a pal who was making his last, poignant visit. Without greater excitement than we had yesterday, that wistful air may be around the place for the next few home games.

3  Donal O’Mahony
16/03/2025    12:09:29

Moyesiah has now taken 17 points from 10 games, matching Dyche haul from prior 19…..amazingly, even if we had lost all Moyes fixtures (bar Ipswich), we’d still be above the relegation zone..albeit sweating !!

4  Dale Self
16/03/2025    13:52:18

Peter, there is reason to believe a rift existed between Thelwell and Dyche over squad deployment. I think Jerome floated that over at the other site and I was doubtful at the time.

And do the fans have PTSD? And yes, you know what SD stands for.

People claiming we looked leggy are right. That was why the last guy played such a negative style typically and then occasionally took the reins off. While the players found some energy for a more positive approach under Moyes, squad size and cumulative minutes played take a toll. Given that, Moyes has drilled the players well on positioning, spacing and timing of support runs. He's getting all that can be expected given the constraints.

Chermiti and Broja look like they have the intent and skill to create up front. With Beto, service is required and it needs to be on a plate. The other two look like they just need the ball at their feet. Alcaraz and Ndiaye will benefit much more with either of them up front, although Chermiti might work into the box from the wings.

Moyes may have solved the midfield possession problem that the other guy could not. Garner and Gueye are running in tandem well, which leaves space for Alcaraz to exploit. We consistently created number advantages on the wings. Seldom found a cutting pass to the byline but Myko found time for delivery and O'Brien made some ambitious moves on the right.

Given where we have been, this was a continuation of sound progress. I'm in. UTOFM!

5  Kieran Fitzgerald
16/03/2025    15:12:53

More game time for Tim coming back from injury, game time at last for Chermiti following injury. I would be happy just to see all the players get game time between now and the end of the season. Competitive games that will give players time to gel and show Moyes what he has.

As for O'Brien, a centre half who scores goals. Always to have.

6  John Raftery
16/03/2025    17:37:36

Although there is no threat of relegation I am slightly nervous about what lies ahead. Our next five fixtures are against the current top five clubs. We must hope the superior quality, but far from invincibility, of the opposition brings out more of the battling characteristics of our players than we have seen in the last two matches.

Otherwise I fear the narrative will rapidly change from ‘x games unbeaten’ to ‘y games without a win’. That in turn will bring pressure on the manager with little regard to the lack of depth and quality in the existing squad. Going into the summer with people questioning the manager’s credentials is not where we want to be.

To an extent that has already started with some, albeit a small minority at present, critical of the perceived delay in making substitutions, selection decisions, use of the long ball and so on. One or two victories next month will go a long way to stemming the current trickle of criticism.

7  Paul Conway
16/03/2025    22:17:56

Did anyone notice Chermiti has Beefed up a little ?..or, is it the Beard.

You always start with your best Team, so, the next game should be the team we finished with.

O’Brien was immense today and he now practically owns that Couloir down the right hand side.

8  Jack Plant
17/03/2025    08:20:08

Would be nice to have turned one of this run of draws into a win, but can't really complain. This remains a flawed team and squad. Moyes has somehow managed to get some rhythm from them but realistically this is a lower mid table squad. The quality across the league has increased so much I worry for any team coming up from the championship that isn't prepared to spend big.

At least we had a full bench this week, hopefully it will be even stronger come the visit to mordor!

9  Jack Plant
17/03/2025    08:41:24

Peter, you could be right but my view on Dyche is he was less stroppy and more unimaginative. He had two right sided CBs who he trusted, I don't think it would have ever occurred to him to play O'Brien at RB.

10  John Raftery
17/03/2025    09:16:22

Jack (9) Dyche did actually select O’Brien at right back for the cup tie versus Peterborough. He was of course dismissed later in the afternoon before the match was played.

11  Jack Plant
17/03/2025    11:04:03

Yeah good point John!

12  Steve Hogan
17/03/2025    17:50:48

We should not be too disappointed in the fall off in results and performance of late. Everyone who has watched Everton over the course of the season, knows very well the limitations of the squad, as does Moyes.

In truth,now we are safe, whilst not enjoying the prospect of a defeat, we have to accept the next five games are against teams who are much better resourced, than we have ever been for the last five years or more, and I still expect the Blues to pull a rabbit or two out the hat and win one or two of those games.

As to the future, even at this early stage of his tenure, Moyes knows who he must keep, and who he must give the boot to, after 20+ years of managing in the Premiership, he will absolutely be aware, that we need an injection of quality in midfield and upfront, players who can inject real pace to the team.

Everyone knows that it's 'fine margins' which win games, and we simply need a striker/s, that will convert those half chances, and turn one point into three.

I'm genuinely excited to see what kind of new additions, the new recruitment team will bring in, with up to 12 players out of contract, it's imperative they get it right, given I don't expect a massive transfer budget.

And finally, I'm amazed at someone with Dyche's experience in football, a fair amount of time spent in the Premiership, he failed to see the potential of O'Brien. This guy is a fast learner and is improving game by game. He reminds me so much of a raw, early days Tim Cahill, with a great shot and an eye for goal.

If Dyche had of remained in charge next season, the odds are we would have lost him to another club.

Onwards and upwards.

13  Darren Hind
21/03/2025    07:59:18

I have mentioned this before Lyndon.

I believe you will attract a lot more comments if you recreated the "recent comments" section on your front page.

14  Jerome Shields
22/03/2025    03:55:22

Typical after a warm weather break performance.Relegation avoided relax.


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.