With four games left before the end of 2025 and the opening of the winter transfer window, Everton’s recent form might be creating something of a dilemma for the club’s owners.

On the 19th of this month, The Friedkin Group will mark one year since their takeover from Farhad Moshiri was ratified by the Premier League and they have already overseen plenty of change. Sean Dyche was dismissed and replaced by David Moyes in January, the Houston-based firm signed off on £120m worth of transfers over the summer (with a further £20m committed to Freiburg for Merlin Röhl at the end of the season), an almost completely revamped recruitment team was assembled and completed in September, while, in May, the Blues left their ancestral home at Goodison Park and kicked off a new era at Hill Dickinson Stadium this past August.

If the timing of Dyche’s departure ended up being moved forward a few months by events on the pitch, results since late October have hinted that Moyes and his players could be ahead of the projected timeline in terms of qualification for Europe.

Given the scale of the squad rebuilding task that faced incoming Chief Executive and the transfer committee at the end of last season when half the first-team squad from last term left, 2025/26 was earmarked as a campaign of consolidation.

A solid mid-table finish — somewhere between 11th and 14th — while some of the younger signings bedded was seen as an attainable goal and eminently satisfactory progress following four years of struggle to remain a Premier League outfit. Perhaps a decent cup run could add interest along the way (although the early exit from the Carabao Cup at the hands of Wolves put paid to any dreams of finally winning that competition) but, on the whole, it’s fair to say that even with Jack Grealish secured on loan, expectations were modest.

Thanks to four wins in five matches and an intriguingly competitive Premier League landscape, Everton find themselves in seventh place with three weeks left of the year, just two points off fourth place. Since Moyes took over for his second spell as manager, no team has won more away games than the Toffees and the team are 12 points better off than their tally from the corresponding 2024/25 fixtures.

That they have done it without anything approaching a reliable centre-forward and no recognised right-back is all the more remarkable. To date, Beto has notched one league goal and £27.5m summer acquisition Thierno Barry only got off the mark this past weekend in the comprehensive 3-0 win over Nottingham Forest.

It raises the unavoidable question of just how good could Moyes’s side be and how far could they conceivably go if a consistent goalscorer and perhaps just one more natural full-back be added to the squad during January?

Of course, the biggest concern, as ever, is finances and the well-worn cliché that the mid-season transfer window has, historically, been a difficult one that rarely provides value for money. The most sought-after players are tied down to contracts and few clubs are willing to part with their better assets halfway through their campaign.

The biggest spenders, like Newcastle in recent years, can usually push the boat out to land their main targets (Anthony Gordon being a prime example when the Magpies ponied up £45m to land him in late January 2023) but for Everton, who spent the bulk of their transfer kitty for the season over the summer, the circumstances and the price would have to be just right to tempt them into the market.

Moyes is said to be keen to strengthen his squad and, by most accounts, there is headroom there for the club to add to the team next month — but probably not the kinds of funds needed to acquire a top-class centre-forward, for example, who could more or less guarantee more than two goals from 15 games. Ivan Toney has been mooted as a potential target but acquiring him outright from Al-Ahli would be extremely expensive and a questionable enterprise given that he turns 30 in March. Toney makes more sense under those terms but there would be competition for his services. 

More likely, the club might seek a younger and cheaper but less developed forward to supplement the options at Moyes’s disposal or attack the loan market where there may be deals to be had given that certain out-of-favour players will be looking for game time in a World Cup year.

Then there are players who are soon to be out of contract like Dusan Vlahovic at Juventus, although there will be a queue of more “attractive” clubs eager to speak to him — Tottenham and Manchester United are currently rumoured to be tracking him closely — and he just suffered a serious thigh injury that probably takes him off the table anyway.

The question is, though: if potential candidates that the club have scouted extensively potentially becomes available for a higher price than would be the case in the summer, do Everton “twist” and make a concerted push for Europe (knowing also that that would bolster the FA Cup campaign as well)? How close to the PSR wind would the hierarchy be prepared to sail by gambling on the team’s current form not only continuing but potentially improving further?

No one should be getting carried away but the next four games, and those that like beyond in January when the likes of Idrissa Gueye and Iliman Ndiaye in particular are away at the Africa Cup of Nations, could be important when it comes to how tempted they might be.

As quickly as Everton have ascended to the fringes of the Champions League chase, a run of poor results like the recent drubbing by Newcastle could dump them back into the bottom half again.

Indeed, defeat to Chelsea and Arsenal, slip-ups against Burnley and Nottingham Forest after Christmas and a general struggle without the AFCoN stars could temper ambitions for the season again and keep the club on a conservative footing of consolidation and measured progress under Moyes’s stewardship.

But a surprise win at Stamford Bridge, perhaps a gritty draw against title-chasing Arsenal and maximum points from Burnley and Nottingham Forest and, all of a sudden, the road opens up to a genuine charge for Europe this season. Then the Friedkins and the transfer committee could have some decisions to make!