If the Premier League in 2025 was a Netflix series, I wouldn’t have made it through the first episode. The thing is though, this is my 30th season as a match-going fan and old habits die hard. Switching off is easier said than done.

Whether watching live in the stadium or tuning into programmes like Match of the Day, I’ve seen thousands of games and not a day goes by where I don’t consume the sport.

Now though, after 30 years of fandom, I’m suffering an existential football crisis, obsessed with a league I don’t particularly care for. The Premier League is simply unwatchable. Yet there I am, on the terraces every week or viewing another game at home, bored out of my mind but still devouring this pursuit that ceased being a hobby a while ago. It sounds so ridiculous and it is.

The matchday buzz is being swiftly crushed with a sense of monotony but still I stick with it, poking an old First Division carcass and longing for a game that has ceased to exist.

It’s undeniable that the top level of football in England has eaten itself and there are so many factors that have eroded the essence of the game.

Now, first things first. The fact I’m an Evertonian doesn’t help my cause as the Blues strangle the potential of yet another campaign with a dysfunctional centre-back-at-right-back set-up while also electing to pick a second string side in a competition that can secure a route to Europe. But the tedium I feel watching the Premier League goes far beyond the Toffees.

No club has played more seasons in the top-flight and so my football education has been to watch the Premier League every week as Everton remain an ever-present. A season ticket holder for a quarter of a century, Alan Shearer made his Newcastle debut in my first-ever game back in August 1996 and I saw a 16-year-old Wayne Rooney announce himself to the world. I’ve been sat just yards from the action when Thierry Henry and Cristiano Ronaldo have taken to the field and witnessed the teams of Sir Alex Ferguson, Jose Mourinho and Arsene Wenger on an annual basis.

During that time, there have always been huge gripes with refereeing decisions and plenty of poor games bereft of quality or excitement. But the Premier League now? This is something on a whole other level. It’s soul destroying.

VAR is excruciating to sit through. Sat inside the stadium, you see the action in real-time but can then only look on as a referee stands with a finger to his ear. While millions of people hundreds and thousands of miles away are kept in the loop with action replays and explanations of what is being looked at during a game you are physically attending, you are kept in the dark. Seconds turn to minutes and still everybody is standing around waiting and ultimately losing the will to live, no longer arsed if their team has conceded a penalty or not.

Then, there is the lack of consistency in decisions. It is infuriating. I remember in December 2023, Dejan Kulusevski pulled Amadou Onana’s Everton shirt in the box down at Tottenham. It stretched so far it ended up in South London. No penalty. Nothing. Only days later, Dejan Kulusevski – yes him again – pulled the shirt of Danny Welbeck. Penalty to Brighton. It’s a prime example of the absurdity which goes on and on. Maddening. Absolutely maddening.

This mind-boggling ineptness has occurred every week for seasons and continues to blight the game. It’s hard to be enthused for a match when the competition is no longer decided by kicking a ball into a net but instead comes down to the lottery of random refereeing calls.

Would I have felt this way had Everton not lost to Arsenal this weekend but actually beaten the league leaders? Definitely. The lows don’t feel as low and the highs don’t feel as high at the moment. It's like the edges of my passion have been shaved off. A litany of stoppages, time-wasting and players halting the game by choosing to go down will do that and make for a more arduous experience. Referees deciding not to follow the rules and book those who crowd them after a decision also make you think, ‘What’s the point?’

Then, there are the kick-off times. Everton played Arsenal at 8pm on the Saturday before Christmas. Thousands won’t have minded one bit. A great chance to have a festive catch up with mates followed by the game. Great stuff. For thousands of others though, a nightmare.

So many times during a season, these rearranged matches force supporters to do logistical gymnastics in their head at a time they should be having a good time and letting their hair down. So often, for example, the last train leaves before the final whistle has sounded for an evening game. With only weeks notice, supporters must assess their options which ultimately comes down to forking out on hotels or alternative travel.

The bottom line is, match-going football fans are paying more to be inconvenienced. Of course, it’s a personal choice and people don’t have to go to the game but the point is, they are being forced too. Why should millions have their hobby negatively impacted to line the pockets of others?

Football has always been described as the ‘working man’s game’ and it’s for that reason the Saturday 3pm kick-off should be sacred. It was a regular match time for decades because it suited the masses. People, after a long week at work, had time to meet with friends, go to the match and get home again in the space of five or six hours.

The sport is of huge cultural importance, the fabric of so many cities and towns up and down the country. It’s a key part of society and community but that’s being lost. Now, kicking off at 3pm on a Saturday is a Premier League novelty and people are missing out due to the many changes to the calendar. Some kids, for example, can’t attend games with school the next day while other members of the fanbase aren’t able to commit to long stays or awkward travel arrangements due to mobility issues. Football should be for everybody and not just television viewers. With good reason, match-goers feel disregarded and forgotten.

Within the next five years I can see Champions League fixtures being scheduled for the weekend meaning even more Premier League matches moving to midweek. The game is changing but to the betterment of the fans? Not a chance. And don’t get me started on the FA Cup kick-off times. A competition killed by a thousand cuts.

The Premier League hype machine is another tedium to contend with. Any Manchester United or Liverpool broadcast may as well come direct from the official club channel as punditry has been saturated by former players associated with those two teams. Then there is the ‘Big Six’ bias as 14 proud and storied clubs now feel nothing but bit-part characters, extras in the Premier League story.

Watch the Football League in comparison and it’s a breath of fresh air. A reporter and co-commentator will talk about the action taking place in the match. That’s it. They simply describe what is happening with no leaning or hyper focus on a particular star name or manager. It’s just football.

Away from the television noise, the play on the pitch has become tiresome and robotic. I love a stat and when you get into the numbers and analytics there is so much to be gleaned from these figures to give you an edge in a match. However, following these details to such an extreme doesn’t make for a spectacle.

The moment I see defenders part to either side of the six yard box for the goalkeeper to play it short, my enthusiasm shrinks that little bit more. I get the reasons and know the benefits of such a set-up but it’s also galling to see so many games spoiled by defenders losing the ball in the area and a centre forward gleefully tapping home the easiest of goals. It would be quicker to throw the ball into the net. Anytime I see such an occurrence, the encounter becomes void in my mind. Urgh.

For so long people have insisted the game isn’t played on paper yet modern football is seemingly being dictated by spreadsheets. It was Thomas Frank who coached his Brentford players not to shoot from distance, instead focusing more on prioritising high-quality chances. It makes perfect sense to follow the percentages; how many times have you bemoaned an effort that’s hit Row Z?

However, when heading out of a stadium, you want to excitedly relive your number ten’s 30-yard winner that flew into the top corner, not dissect the benefits of five perfectly-crafted passes a yard from the goalline. Football is a results business but first and foremost, it’s entertainment and the pendulum has swung too far one way. Tactical battles see teams cancel each other out and football has turned into chess.

The spontaneity which get fans on their feet and out of their seats is ebbing away. Players don’t even get to the byline anymore. Instead, such is the eagerness to merely keep the ball, inverted wingers pass it safe to full-backs who are no longer allowed to overlap and instead go inside. The switch of play to the other wing is slow and laborious.

Then there are the athletes who can run at full pelt for 90 minutes but can’t trap a football. The technical element has been lost and true footballers who can produce moments of magic are being stifled or instead replaced by workhorses.

The malaise being felt is a real shame as it comes at a time fan culture and initiatives are thriving, with a number of supporter bases putting in their own time and effort to create incredible tifos and flag displays to show their love for their club and give the players extra backing.

I turn 35 this month and so some may put my Premier League irks down to age and nostalgia but I don’t think that’s the case. When I watch live games in the Football League, I’m engrossed and can feel the animation on my face as I react to a great cross for a centre forward to head; safe in the knowledge VAR can’t rob me of the moment.

Watching the Premier League, I’m loud and proud in my backing of Everton, joining in with chants but soon enough, I can feel my shoulders drooping, only gesturing with quiet indignation that the referee is wandering over to the screen again and will no doubt change his decision. There is a real lack of spark because of the negatives that are diminishing the Premier League.

Despite my complaints here, I’m in no doubt every era of the game has had its downsides. I’m sure the final ten minutes of plenty of games in the 1980s were ruined by goalkeepers being allowed to pick the ball up from a back pass. It must have stifled so many matches. However, today’s drawbacks feel unnecessary but so damaging, and for generations to come too.

The match is losing its appeal and yet, the Premier League has never been so universally loved and continues to soar in popularity around the globe. Every campaign, billions of people tune in to watch the self-proclaimed Best League in the World. However, for the ‘legacy’ fans who played a key role in making the English top-flight this giant competition, this feels a very different game.

Sure, clubs will proudly boast of sell out attendances but look a little deeper and you’ll see the empty seats where loyal supporters have now stuck their seat on a resale platform only for it to go unsold. The failures of VAR together with an increase in late and midweek kick-off times isn’t sustainable.

In the world of work, a ‘quiet quitting’ phenomenon has taken hold and I see football fans following suit. Slowly, supporters may decide they will now follow a take-it-or-leave approach when it comes to the fixture list as opposed to strictly planning events, social gatherings and family time around when the match is on. Loyalty goes both ways and the Premier League isn’t sticking to its side of the bargain.

This is football and, like in life, things change. However, things don’t always change for the better and so while I can never halt the Premier League evolving in the way it is, it doesn’t mean I can’t have a good, cathartic moan about its ugly transformation.

I may be in the minority in feeling like this but know others will relate.

As my disinterest grows, will I still be there next week and tune into the Premier League highlights later on? Yeah. Who am I kidding? Of course I will. I might even actually enjoy one of the matches.

Will that be the case in a year’s time though? I’m not as certain. An unthinkable statement from someone who is football daft and deeply immersed in the game but something’s got to give because there is a growing sense among match-going fans everywhere that the ‘entertainment’ on offer is no longer worth this level of expense, inconvenience or tedium.