An outsider might view what has gone on at Everton since Saturday morning and muse that, “you couldn’t make it up”. The painful truth is that you don’t have to. Despite all the change that’s occurred over the past couple of years, change that was supposed to usher Everton away from the chaos of the Farhad Moshiri era, this football club continues to be one of the laughing stocks of the Premier League.

Once again, Sky’s unavoidable blowhard Kopite, Jamie Carragher, was on television screens this week explaining how Everton are the worst-run club in England’s top flight, and, depressingly, when it comes to the footballing side of the operation at least, you can’t argue with him. Because over much of the summer 2026 transfer window, and certainly in its final shambolic hours, the custodians of this famous, once-proud institution — or, at least, those they have hired to do their bidding from the Royal Liver Building and Finch Farm — have cast that notion in stone.

What should have been the climactic end to a two-year squad-building plan began, instead, with a galling mis-step over the potential sale of home-grown star, Harrison Armstrong and a somewhat embarrassing (but nonetheless welcome) climb-down by the owners, The Friedkin Group (TFG), that kept the teenager at Everton and ended with the ignominy of United States international Folarin Balogun leaving Finch Farm last night without having signed the contract that would have sealed a deadline-day move from Monaco.

The striker’s decision came after the transfer had been revived following questions Everton had over his medical tests, but a deal sheet was submitted to the Premier League in anticipation of the deal being completed before the 1am cut-off.

It means that when added to the Blues’ failure to land left-back cover for Vitalii Mykolenko, the sale of Beto to Fiorentina and Iliman Ndiaye’s £65m switch to Manchester City, Everton have just two senior full-backs on their books, just one developing but raw striker and have lost their best outfield player.

David Moyes, who has made no bones of the fact that he wanted more bodies through the door before the window closed, has seen his already small squad reduced from 22 outfield players to just 18 while TFG have seen their standing with — and faith among — supporters utterly and, perhaps, irretrievably undermined.


”What a Mess”

Everton have had farcical transfer windows in the past but surely none can rival what played out this summer; a slow-motion calamity that reached its climax in the early hours of this morning when news broke that Balogun had walked just an hour after it looked as though his switch from the French Riviera to Merseyside was all but complete.

The club’s hierarchy had allowed Beto’s move to go ahead without assurances that his replacement would sign and, now, assuming there isn’t a viable option with a pulse on the free-agent market, Moyes must now muddle through until January, at least, with just Thierno Barry as a recognised centre-forward.

Meanwhile, 21 months after TFG’s takeover from Moshiri and despite a full year of their much-vaunted new recruitment and trading setup in place, Everton went into the final hours of the window without a single specialist right-back after Nathan Patterson was sold to Torino for a nominal fee.

Ainsley Maitland-Niles, the 29-year-old midfielder-turned-right-back was acquired from Lyon just before the deadline but there is no back-up for either full-back position without the manager forcing more square pegs into round holes.

Such rank negligence is baffling from an ever-present Premier League club and one owned by a multi-billion dollar company that appears, in all other respects, to be competently and efficiently run. And, from a financial perspective, the Friedkins will feel very good about things — Everton raked in around £100m in transfer fees this summer with an outlay of £65m, plus the wages committed to Jack Grealish’s return on loan from Manchester City.

But Everton’s ability to compete this season, particularly for Europe, looks to have been hobbled. Any prospect of it is now hugely dependent on almost fanciful amounts of luck on the injury front, both in defence and where Barry is concerned, together with the relatively young forward delivering goals on a consistent basis.

How much the Blues’ attacking threat is blunted by the loss of Ndiaye will be determined by the extent to which Brennan Johnson can rediscover the form of his Tottenham and Nottingham Forest days, Tyrique George rapidly continuing his maturation on the wings, and Jack Grealish not only remaining fit himself but repeating the impact he had last season.

Frustratingly, things started out well enough. Everton’s “transfer committee” and head of trading, Nick Hammond especially, garnered praise for their patient and ultimately successful pursuits of George and Hayden Hackney, both secured on favourable terms from Chelsea and Middlesbrough respectively and in good time for both to enjoy a full pre-season. Christian Nørgaard, meanwhile, may eventually prove to be a shrewd acquisition for £7m from Arsenal once he regains his fitness.

However, the longer the window wore on and as deadline day in particular unfolded, it felt that, in all instances, money, the balancing of the books and Squad Cost Ratio considerations were prioritised over what ultimately happens on the pitch. Banking the £15m for Beto and ensuring he didn’t leave for free next summer, for example, was deemed more important than ensuring a replacement was found first.

Even if that wasn’t the case, the fact that the recruitment team left so much important business to the very last day invited the disaster that befell them yesterday.

It reduced their bargaining power regarding Ndiaye, the one player the ownership knew could command a hefty fee but arguably went to City for £10m to £15m less than his current market value. It forced them to go cap in hand to a player in Kenny Tete who used Everton to get a better contract at Fulham a year ago and who then proved to be unattainable again, prompting a move for a 29-year-old Maitland-Niles whose form in France has been on the wane for a while.

And when the Balogun deal was in jeopardy, it left them panic-calling Old Trafford and Villa Park to see if either Joshua Zirkzee or Tammy Abraham were interested in an 11th-hour switch to Merseyside. They weren’t. Humiliatingly, it prompted one prominent Tottenham Hotspur commentator on X to tweet: “For an established Premier League club to end up in this position is unfathomable. What a mess.”

This is, as so many fans — and even other outside observers — have said a “heads must roll” moment. Because it’s almost inconceivable that the current recruitment structure can remain in place or indeed that CEO Angus Kinnear can survive what has been a disastrous week for the leadership.

The chief executive was at pains in his recent interviews with fan media, and BBC Radio Merseyside to assure fans that a high-quality right back would be signed, that Everton would finish the transfer window stronger than they entered it, and that European qualification was the aim for this season. Again, that last claim seems fanciful now while he will, no doubt, wear the other two like tar and feathers for as long as he remains in his post.

As the architect and a chief component of the recruitment setup that he installed to replace the Director of Football model, it’s difficult to see how Kinnear survives this disastrous transfer window. At the very least, the structure surely needs to be ripped up and either re-thought or rebuilt with different personnel.


A False Friedkin Dawn

Dan Friedkin’s ownership of AS Roma has, until recently, been notable for his near absence as a public figure at the Italian club. He famously avoided attending matches, at Stadio Olympic or anywhere else, but made an exception for the Europa Conference League Final in Tirana in 2022 and was photographed with the trophy after the Giallorossi beat Feyenoord.

While it’s unfathomable to most that the owner of a company that has sunk hundreds of millions of dollars into one of the biggest and most famous clubs in the history of English football hasn’t seen fit to spend any time immersing himself in the culture of the asset he has purchased or even set foot in its magnificent new stadium on a match day, the Friedkins have maintained their distance since taking over at Everton as well. Neither Dan nor his son Ryan have attended a competitive game at Bramley-Moore Dock.

Perhaps that is also to maintain for the regulators at UEFA the perception of an at-arm’s-length separation between Everton and Roma., essentially to head off any conflict of interest should both clubs end up in the same European competition at any point in the near future — although, with the Italian club in the Champions League on the one hand and the recruitment and player trading setup his firm has put in place on Merseyside bungling it’s way through a panicked and slipshod transfer window on the other, that doesn’t feel like an imminent concern!

Whatever their reasoning, the Friedkins’ disconnect is what has led to decisions like the alarmingly short-sighted and misguided one made last week to try and sell Harrison Armstrong.

From a purely business perspective, selling a largely unproven 19 year-old for £35m to £40m, with a potentially large selling clause included, makes sense. But, as much as billionaire owners, particularly those from the United States (where club and team loyalty is a much rarer commodity than in England and players move far more freely and frequently between teams) would love it not to be the case, English football has an enormous emotional component.

Nowhere might that be more true than at Everton, where a local-born player has been in the senior squad in every season since the formation of the Football League in 1888 and the power of the fans has been demonstrated time and time again over the past few years. As has been expressed many times on forums, social media, and websites like this, it is not hyperbole to suggest that it was Evertonians who kept the Toffees in the Premier League just as much as the likes of Jordan Pickford, Richarlison, Abdoulaye Doucouré and those other players who made outsized contributions in those successful battles to stave off relegation.

TFG felt the full force of that fan power in the outcry that greeted news of Armstrong’s imminent sale and, thankfully, it forced a rethink that likely headed off the first demonstrations of supporter discontent. Yet, had it not been for a report from David Ornstein of The Athletic coming out before the Premier League match at Bournemouth last Saturday, the depth of supporter anger at the prospect of losing Everton’s brightest Academy prospect for many years might never have reached TFG’s notice and the 19-year-old starlet would surely now be a Forest player.

In the wake of the Armstrong debacle, some fans opined that the reaction from supporters might draw Dan Friedkin out from his self-imposed exile from Hill Dickinson Stadium. Now it’s hard to see how either he or his son could show their face at the stadium they have done so well to market since they assumed control of Everton in December 2024 without drawing a hail of derision. The same could easily be said for Kinnear.

The question then becomes, how do TFG make amends? Because as the Armstrong episode showed, without the fans on their side, they’re going to find it very difficult to succeed on the football front. It is the support and patronage of Evertonians that they will rely on to fill the stadium, buy the concessions, take up the hospitality offerings and roar the team they're now neglecting on to some semblance of success.

Then they could take a "budgets be damned" approach to bringing in the reinforcements we need at fullback and centre-forward in January, to either support what looks, from this vantage point, an unlikely push for Europe or ensure that the club stays in the Premier League.

Truthfully, they may not ever be able to mend the bridges; at the very least it’s going to be difficult and whether they even care to is another question altogether. They could start by issuing immediate partial refunds to every season ticket holder paying increased prices, well above the rate of inflation, to watch what is now an inferior, reduced product on the pitch this season.

They could offer sincere assurances that they, as a company, are invested in making Everton successful, that things can and will change, and that they didn’t, as it increasingly feels, merely buy a stadium with the inconvenience of a football team attached to it.

If they can’t muster the grace to break their silence and communicate not only their remorse for the failures to date, but also their ambitions for the future, they may as well sell up at the first opportunity and walk away. The alternative is years of rancour and discontent, the like of which weary Blues thought had been consigned to bitter history.

Read More