FAN VIEW
Thoughts on a Home Ground: Part Two
As Manchester United look to replace their own ageing stadium, what if Bramley-Moore Dock had been another false dawn and Everton had been forced to limp along at Goodison Park?
In the second part of the article. I wanted to look at other issues that can affect a stadium, and fans' relationship with what is their home ground. When I was reseaching the first part of the article, I had gone down my usual rabbit hole and, yet again, a variety of thoughts, ideas and issues had surfaced. Many of those could easily have affected Evertonians in our recent history. While none are a disaster in terms of lives lost, each one could have been traumatic in their own right.
My starting point is Old Trafford. It's a stadium that, much like Goodison Park, has seen more than it's fair share of history, success and club folklore in the making. It is also an old stadium, one that has gone without investment, without essential maintenance, for a number of years. By way of example, rain water is reportedly pouring into the stands through their covers. While there are plans for a new stadium — and I think there has been some engagement with fans around this — it must feel like empty spin from what are truly awful owners.
You have an uncaring, heavy-handed minority owner in Jim Ratcliffe, whose approach to running the club is to implement cost-cutting measures at every turn. You then have the majority share owners, the Glazers, who just see Manchester United as a cash cow, having reportedly taken £2bn out of the club during their time there. With owners like these, do United fans really believe that they will finance the cost of a new ground in a way that suits the overall health of the club, or the wishes of the fans?
All of the above is happening against a backdrop of an incredibly sharp decline in fortunes on the pitch. United have become also-rans with a speed no fan thought possible ten years ago. At least during our very lean years, Evertonians had a crumb of comfort in an ageing but fully functioning Goodison. Something alive, something wonderful, something that was glorious in and of itself. It was something that we could draw solace from. United fans, by comparison, are watching their club fall apart before their eyes in a home ground that seems to be rubbing salt in their wounds.
There is a part of me that can empathise with Man United fans. Goodison was on borrowed time for a number of years. It wasn't just that it was an ageing stadium, fabulous as it was. For the club to grow, to progress, to keep pace with the direction football, and the Premier League was going in, we long needed a newer and bigger model. As with United now, we had had our own version of spin and nonsense from poor quality owners when it came to a new home. Over a short period of time, we had the Kings Dock fiasco, with the non-existent 'ringfenced money', the ground share with Liverpool, which we didn't have the price of, and the Kirkby bowl, with nobody knowing who exactly was going to pay for it.
For varying reasons, each of the three stadium plans may well have caused, distress, upheaval, dissatisfaction and dismay for Evertonians. I'm not going to go into huge detail here. as each plan is worth an article in it's own right, I will however reference KEOIC a little later.
We eventually did get it rght with Bramley-Moore Dock. As I said in Part One, the move from Goodison was seemless. It was relatively painless and hassle free. However, what if BMD had been another false dawn, another missed opportunity? Can you imagine the impact on the club, and any hope of a new stadium if, say, we had lost one of the recent relegation battles?
Would we now be limping along in the Championship, sweating on a ground that was edging closer to being refused the necessary permits to operate? Would we being going cap in hand to our neighbours, looking to become tenants, hoping that they, the council and regional police force would agree to it?
A ground share with even less apeal than the first one proposed. Would we be looking back at Destination Kirkby with a different pair of glasses on? Would we have spent ten years, as Wimbledon did, renting space in another club's home ground, never feeling any ties or fondness for the place? Would we eventually have moved miles away to another ground, well away from our geographical and spiritual heartland?
If I am being particularily fatalistic, could the lack of a home ground have eventually become ruinous for the club? Financially, and in terms of our very existence, it may well have done. Would it have led to a series of points deductions and demotions for financial mismanagement? Would we have had a series of disinterested and sub-par owners, with little or no interest or competency in running a club properly? Owners who would have assisted in running the club into the ground.
Would we have eventually ended up in the position Sheffield Wedneaday found themselve last season, in administration, under threat of winding up petitions, and scrambling for new owners? Only maybe with the humiliation of no home ground.
Perhaps we have have had to endure what Bury had to in 2019. Despite the joy of promotion to League One that year, the club was expelled from the Football League altogether for long standing financial difficulties.
Both examples are, I know, drawing things out to a worst case scenario. But a death spiral can be sudden in its arrival, and when it does, it can be quick in it's acceleration. It can also be something that a club can lose control over quite quickly. Could anyone have predicted the mess Manchester United — yes, that United — finds itself in now, from where it stood only very recently?
However, as with the first part of this article, I would like to finish the second part on a positive note. AFC Wimbledon fans created a new club, with a close version of their original name. They also developed their own home ground, only 250 miles from where their original one stood. They didn't just stop being Wimbledon fans.
Bury fans, following their expulsion, created a new club, starting near the bottom of the footballing pyramid. They eventually returned to their original home ground in 2023, having purchased it from the administrators. They didn't stop being Bury fans.
I would like to think that if any of the scenarios above had happened to us, or that we had lost our own home ground, that some version of KEIOC would have surfaced, would have been established. That Evertonians would not have given up on the club either. That we wouldn't have given up on what it meant to have our own home ground, our own stadium to to celebrate on team, our club in. You would hope that this would be our legacy to Goodison.
Reader Responses
Selected thoughts from readers05/11/2026 22:45:51
Interesting articles, Kieran, but I think there is just the one factual error within it: "AFC Wimbledon fans created a new club, with a close version of their original name. They also developed their own home ground, only 250 miles from where their original one stood." Respectfully... having been down it, I know Plough Lane is a long old road- but one hadn't realised it was considerably longer than the M6 motorway!...
06/11/2026 05:28:24
Well spotted James, yep, should have read 250m. Would hope I don't make the same mistake about BMD at any stage!
06/11/2026 10:01:54
I think most Evertonians would remain Evertonians, even if "Everton" became a phoenix club playing in the local park.
Btw, was Goodison Park really "a ground that was edging closer to being refused the necessary permits to operate"? I do remember that line was spun as part of the Desperation Kirkby hype and yet it's remained in use decades later, miraculously.
06/11/2026 10:16:59
Dennis, I was to a certain extent assuming. As an older ground I wasn't sure how much life she had left in her. In ways it was a hypothetical what if type of article.
06/11/2026 10:31:15
I do wonder what will become of Goodison Park under new owners. Will they have the same commitment to Women's soccer?
13/11/2026 18:24:24
Kieran I have deep dived into the three stadium plans and unearthed a different story than the public perception.I currently am fighting Liverpool City Council.to release more information under FOI..
The Council's response:
:'disclosure would prejudice its commercial position in current/future property transactions and the commercial interests of the company involved. It carried out a public interest test and concluded withholding is in the public interest.'
I now have got them where I want them after months.Liverpool Council have done well out of Everton
13/11/2026 22:16:16
I think it's a great pity that the new stadium could not have been named Bramley Moore with its historical link.
There were never any derisive comments about the name Goodison Park, but sadly money dictated and now we are stuck for the forseeable future with Hill Dickinson and all the sniggering jibes.
13/11/2026 23:23:03
dennis I seem to remember uncle bill wiping back the tears in a interview on tv and blubbing 'we won't get a safety certificate next season' at the time of the kirkby scam.
and jerome your post intrigues me. as we have all suspected LCC have always been most obliging to lfc (anfield rd.closed and streets left derelict so the new main stand could grab the land)
i remember gladys street junior school kept goodison in its footprint or thats what we were told by EFC & LCC
14/11/2026 09:30:18
LCC, are a complete joke. How the Liverpool City Mayor, can say that we werent sure that the stadium was going to be finished, in defence of the appalling situation at Sandhills, still keep his job?
Its all about money though because if there had been enough of it then they would have found the space to relocate Glawdys St school, imo Philip, and the despicably, cynical Kenwright, would have never had to use those crocodile tears.
How short sighted were the people who decided to do away with the dockers umbrella, or was it because they just never had the money to stay on top of the maintenance? No wonder those very rich owners of Manchester City, have been so valuable because you cant do nothing without money, until the people in high places, end up being bought by the people with the collateral……. Im just thankful we ended up on the banks of the Royal Blue Mersey, because if the worlds greatest Evertonian, had his way, it would have been Donkey Derby.
14/11/2026 10:29:47
Fortunately we do have BMD and the Hill Dickinson. It is a magnificent development and a brilliant stadium designed (unlike some) specifically for football. Part of the very necessary modernisation of what had sadly become a tragically old-fashioned club.
As a club overall we are still a work in progress in lots of areas - but the stadium really is the business.
14/11/2026 13:30:25
You're quite right, Philip. The recollection had me reaching for a couple of tissues!
14/11/2026 15:42:44
Peter @7, agree it would have been nice to mark the history of the docks with the name of the stadium. Unfortunately, naming rights mean cash. Cash rhat perhaps helps to cover the running costs for home games.
Robert @10, an apt description of the club. Part of us moving forward meant a modern stadium. Goodison in part had us living in the past.
14/11/2026 20:19:38
dennis yeah I think it was circa 2007 when bungalow bill came out with that whopper and 18 years later it was still being fully functionable ! nobody ever queried BK on this as far as I know. antony of course the gladys st.school could have been re-located it must be nearly 150 years old ! but as I said we never seem to get the same preferential treatment as the RS...they bring in the tourists i'm not old enough to remember the dockers umbrella my dad went on it, but he was'nt a docker !
yeah I shouted at the radio when I heard steve roth.make that remark on the tony snell prog.pn radio merseyside
for dodgy dealings read the gaurdian article - anfield the victims,the anger and liverpools shameful truth by david conn
14/11/2026 21:27:09
That one has been stored in my memory bank for years Philip. I have had a few kopites, down the years with that one, asking them how they have got the temerity to sing “fuck the Tories” when you look at how their club, helped to run the area around the stadium down, so they could purchase the houses that werent already vacant, at a cheaper price?
They fume at the suggestion that it was a Tory move if ever there was one… Fuck the Tories, my arse!
14/11/2026 22:21:02
They clearly don't know their history, Antony. The original split, taking the Club across the park to Goodison was largely led by Liberals with a bias towards temperance. Whereas, those who remained at Anfield & formed the new club were predominately Conservatives, particularly involved with the brewing and licensed trade sector. They probably wouldn't exist if it wasn't for the Tories!
14/11/2026 22:38:36
Im sure you have seen those pictures of Emlyn Hughes and Bob Paisley, with Margaret Thatcher, Dennis!
14/11/2026 23:30:07
put yer hands up if you had a 'i hate emlyn hughes badge'
i remember thatcher with emlyn hughes but I thought it was the england squad - kevin keegan too..but not sure
antony re-graeme sharpe no its big bad bob for me he had a better goal per game ratio
and mr sharpe not a very affable fellow. thats me being diplomatic !
i tell the RS we are playing in our 3rd ground and their still in the one that was'nt good enough for us...
15/11/2026 08:42:17
Phillip Me and Tony spent about 20 with Bob before an Aston Villa v Everton game and he listened— well hed have to with me and Tony— as well as talking and he was great company— sadly I wasnt one of Bobs fans when he played for us - he was okay but didnt have that killer instinct when it was needed like the Derby games and maybe it was our ages that made the difference in our preference.
15/11/2026 11:06:11
All about opinions Philip, but just looking at that Rapid Vienna game in isolation, shows how much more overall quality compared to Latchford, that Graeme Sharp had, imo mate.
I remember bunking into Anfield, to see him score for Swansea, but nothing will ever beat the time Sharp, had the Evertonians, going berserk, inside that old shithole of a stadium that we once called our home!
I agree with you about Sharp, badly letting himself down, but thats a separate issue (one that I could never personally forgive him for) and should take nothing away from what he did out on the pitch. Incidentally I was also looking at another little WhatsApp clip of the night Gary Stevens, won us the game at Anfield, in a league cup tie (hopefully Barry, or fucking anyone in a blue shirt can do the same if we get the bastards in the semifinal) and Sharp, had a disgraceful night in front of goal.
15/11/2026 13:16:16
yeah tony & dave, latch never scored against liverpool as I remember. for us anyway he might have for birmingham or swansea ? when he got that 30th goal against chelsea the penalty we were in the bullens rd.paddock and I do remember seeing a quite tall pensioner
or so it seemed ! doing a pitch invasion from the goodison rd.enclosure - though it could have been gordon lee !
off topic this and I put it on TW last week, has anyone heard on radio merseyside they play a trailer for their total sport prog. it's tim cahill muttering something like 'the future for everton is good coz the players signed are for the future' it just sounds awful no doubt penned by mr kinnear (our resident corporate bullshitter)
15/11/2026 18:19:18
Antony/(28), never called you that before!
I think Sharp lacked that bit of bite before Andy Gray came to the club and I dont think it was coincidence that part of his game improved watching Andy giving it out to the opposition — in fact in one programme article Sharp wrote that he wasnt naturally an aggressive player like Steve McMahon was, he certainly made up for it after Gray joined us. Erm except when he wouldnt come to Goodison with the rest of the board during that relegation fight!
15/11/2026 21:55:57
Just watched England deservedly beat Spain, with a very good hardworking performance. Great performance from Trafford, which will certainly put extra pressure on our Gordon.
16/11/2026 13:29:00
Hate to say it, but surely the way to go was what Liverpool have done. Updated their ancient stadium and kept all the good, and added to it. We have lost something indescribable in the move from Goodison. If we had had good owners, that stadium could have been updated, and we could have retained our heritage.
Bramley Moore the inside has no magic at all. Why would it, we've been playing there for a few months. It will take many decades to build back what we had at Goodison, if we ever get it back (which I doubt).
16/11/2026 20:05:59
I think a lot of fans will agree with you Kevin - but presumably there's a generational divide on this.
Apart from a few fleeting moments, the last time there was any real magic at Goodison is now getting on 40 years ago.
Anyone under 50 will struggle to remember the old magic or (like me) be unable to remember it at all.
Anyone over 50 will always have the brilliant Goodison memories but the game and the city have moved on and we're much, much better placed for the future in our new home.
16/11/2026 20:21:53
Ive got to agree with Kevin @(23), partly for selfish reasons, that part is because if Everton still played at Goodison Id be still going to watch them every home game but the new ground is very hard going physically for me and also for quite a lot of fans turned 60 odd and Im afraid unless Evertons form improves dramatically the attendances will start to dwindle especially on those cold winter night games in fact I think if Everton hadnt won their away league game vNewcastle quite a few would have given the Coventry game a miss on the Friday evening.
16/11/2026 22:56:55
Goodison symbolised our decline and reflected very badly on the club. It was totally done. Personally, I had pretty much had enough.
It acted as a mental prison for both the club and its fan-base, shackled to its "traditional" image (in other words unsuccessful and skint) with Anfield towering over it. We had become the footballing equivalent of a wooden tennis racket. The club badly needed a fresh start and it should have happened - and needed to happen - years earlier.
I'm delighted we have moved and much prefer the new ground. I'm hoping we can push forward now we have finally escaped a place that had long since stopped being a positive environment for the club.
I'm 50 yrs old btw for context.
17/11/2026 05:26:08
Kevin, it would have been nice to have upgraded Goodison, it may well have been a lot cheaper.
But how difficult would it have been to increase capacity on the same footprint? Liverpool acquired a number of houses around Anfield to help expand it.
Getting rid of roughly four thousand obstructed view seats may have also changed the nature of the old school stands. While sympathetically done, it still may well have altered the feel of the ground.
Would a renovated Goodison have provided the extra 15,000 seats that BMD has?
A renovated Goodison may have lost a lot of it's magic.
Nowadays, a stadium is much more than just for playing matches. Commercially, It's gone way beyond generating a couple of quid from match day tickets with a few pints being sold on the day. Concerts, other sports, events all play a major part now in generating income. Perhaps BMD is a better option in the modern game.
17/11/2026 08:13:17
Goodison was hocked to the last screw for years by Blue Bill and Philip Green via Earl.Really Everton ended up close to a BHS/ Arcadia MarkIII imo.The play then was a new stadium and to get a third party to pay for it, increasing the Club valuation at no cost to the origin shareholders.
Liverpool Council tried to get into the act as well having made a killing with Finch Farm.
Kevin you are actually right, but there was no choice.At no stage and even now did Liverpool Council do Everton any favour.Fortubately offers of loans for the new Stadium where not taken up and Liverpool Council got burnt for over £700,000.
17/11/2026 10:44:17
Warner @(26) Yes of course I couldnt argue with most of your post but I think Goodison Park rejuvenated would have cost less than the, to be honest, brilliant new ground but while it is a standout building on The Mersey and looks great I really hope our team gets reliable new owners with the pocket to use the transfer market because if they havent the attendances will dwindle like they did at Goodison Park during the managerships of Bingham, Lee and most definitely under Kendalls first couple of seasons.
17/11/2026 10:48:45
Sorry @ (29) Warney not Warner, apologies Warney your grandad was a cracking fullback by the way although I just missed seeing him!
17/11/2026 11:16:11
Favid#29
That is what the Fruedkins bulked at. The £400 million investment needed on the football side and the reduced valuation which prevent it , when Ueafa didn't allow the TFG model for Multi club ownership.They had bet the farm on getting that accepted.
The point of a new investor who would control sufficient, of Everton and reduces the TFG connection, is that it clears the way for such a investment.
This is essential for Everton to be a sustainable Club, as you say.The reduced attendances at Goodison was something I didn't twig at the time.Thsnk for the first hand knowledge.
Hope that gives a general idea without going into the complicated detail.
17/11/2026 19:31:10
Dave # 29, crowds have held up very very well so far despite the football results being nothing to write home about. 52,000 people are voting with their feet.
Things could tail off a bit youre right if results dont go our way but that would also be true of a redeveloped goodison.
And whatever the case they seem unlikely to fall as low as Goodison crowds of just 20,000 at the start of the Premier League era
17/11/2026 21:03:55
Robert, City have struggled to fill their stadium, even with all the success over a number of seasons.
You'd wonder with all the carry on at Utd, have attendances tailed off at Old Trafford.
The glut of games over the Christmas and New Year can also affect attendance figures.
I think a fair barometer could be the waiting list for season tickets.
17/11/2026 21:28:41
Robert (32) To be honest Robert I could write with pride about the younger element of our support from 40 down — they have been incredible with their support especially through those relegation worrying years, they have proved their loyalty during these long periods without ever seeing any silverware for over thirty years, I admire them more than I can say.
I proved my own in my younger years from the age of seven until I was 22 when we won the league in 1963 so I havent had to wait as long as these young supporters of today, some not so young but even with this fabulous new ground to admire it wont keep them coming in fact with the higher prices, messing around with their mobile phones to get in or to give their tickets to friends and relations, the transport fiasco, thanks Rotherham youd look after your Red fans a lot better, I miss going to see the Blues as much as I used to but not as much as I thought because watching them now with their sterile style bores me a lot more than pleases me and I cant see it changing with stability the main reason we will have endure for the next few seasons.
My older son couldnt make the Man. Unt. but couldnt give his ticket away ( free) with three friends refusing the offer and it was too late to let Everton FC sell it for him,
Everton FC have been a big part of my life and I dont regret following the Blues at all but age has taken its toll for me because I would still make the habit of going too see them but not expecting too much pleasure or excitement.
17/11/2026 23:57:19
On attendances, as I remember there was an early 90's slump when it didn't happen for Howard second time around. The gate for his last match against Southampton was about 13k. High teens and early 20k's were commonplace.
Our average gate jumped significantly the season after we stayed up against Wimbledon and it has steadily increased thereon.
We are currently filling out 52k despite being absolutely dreadful for the best part of a decade and lucky to still be in the division. So there's not too much to worry about on that score imo.
18/11/2026 07:40:44
I dont use my season ticket as much as I used to, although thats because I never ever used to miss a game, but whenever I have been inside Bramley-Moore, there have been plenty of empty seats dotted all around the stadium.
Things might have improved but it depends on what you really want, I suppose.
18/11/2026 10:11:17
Warney (36)The reason the gates increased after Wimbledon was because Walker was sacked, Joe Royle took over and Duncan Ferguson became an idol to many fans, Joe made us hard to beat and the team got to the FA cup final and won it, Kanchelsus( sic) came and garnered more support, Joe went and Howard came back but did little, the prices in the ground became stable year after year, with child prices, young adults and pensioners getting rebates on their season tickets helped to keep the gates at a constant 39,000 +.
Lets see if the sell out attendances continue while the fare on the pitch continues as it is!
18/11/2026 11:31:21
Not too sure that is accurate, David.
I had a season ticket and recall gates being up from the beginning of the season. A long running ownership saga had been resolved (Peter Johnson got the club instead of Kenwright), we had spent money in the summer, and there was an air of positivity.
I recall When Skies are Grey characterising it as everyone realising what the fuss was all about post Wimbledon.
We had a terrible start but gates held up - we may have been averaging around 30k which represented a significant bounce - and the fans remained supportive and gave the team great backing as nobody wanted to go through another Wimbledon.
As for "Lets see if the sell out attendances continue while the fare on the pitch continues as it is!" - we are 6th in the table and the team and club is visibly progressing despite negative doom mongers persistently talking us down.
18/11/2026 11:49:27
Bobby (38), Its possible you are correct but if I remember correctly we won only one game at the start of that season under Walker after about 10 games, got two players on loan from Rangers a midfield player who wasnt upto it or unfit and Ferguson, Royles first home game was the Derby when Ferguson scored the first goal and Rideout wrapped a special victory with the second.
Joe introduced the “ dogs of war “ and we had that cup run so maybe that started or kept the attendances up.
18/11/2026 16:38:14
david that other player from rangers was ian durrant..your descripyion of him sums up quite a lot of everton signings !
20/11/2026 23:45:40
Peter Greeson wrote, "I think it's a great pity that the new stadium could not have been named Bramley Moore with its historical link." I thought that too originally but then found out that John Bramley Moore was directly involved in the trade, ownership and use of slaves. He was a ruthless operator implicated in the transatlantic slave trade and I am very grateful that our stadium was not associated with him or his historical crimes against humanity.
Add Your Thoughts
Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.
Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.
41 Comments ↓