FAN VIEW
The Tremendous Tarkowski: An Ode To A Footballing Throwback
In a world of split centre-backs and passing out from the back, the veteran harks back to a bygone era of no-nonsense defending and organisation.
Reader Responses
Selected thoughts from readers05/11/2026 22:16:05
You're right Sean.
Tarks is a throwback. 100% effort and commitment. Tough tackler. Good cross field passer. Could score a few more. Leads by example.
Losing pace, but I love his attitude and determination.
Long live Tarks!
06/11/2026 06:53:54
I remember being impressed with his performance that night, not so much ours.
Imo, he's a good, solid CB who has served us well...but he'd get ripped apart playing for a top team who push up the pitch.
He simply hasn't got the awareness of a Terry, or the recovery pace of a Walker.
06/11/2026 08:27:11
Lets raise a glass, a toast to Tarks! Cheers! Ohhh Tarky ;)
06/11/2026 08:52:13
Ive always liked tarkowski since the day he arrived.
A no-nonsense centre half that are a dying breed, at least in the premier league.
I suppose he was ‘fortunate to come to Everton when we needed him the most so he could show off his talents.
I remember a couple of years ago when he slid in at the corner flag by the paddock/ Gwladys street to win the ball and flatten the opposition player to great acclaim from the crowd and even a couple of his teammates who rushed to congratulate him but he just shrugged them off and trotted back.
Last season wasnt his best and I fully expected OBrien to replace him this season but he has bounced back superbly and is, arguably, the player of the season so far.
He has his shortcomings but he is nothing less than totally committed and I will be sorry when hes gone.
06/11/2026 09:11:21
That 3-2 Burnley result, if Im not wrong, is where he completely cleaned out Richarlison from behind. Dunno how he didnt get a straight red.
Still - hes the No.1 PL defender for Statsmuse and joint 4th with Gabriel for the official PL Rankings, which isnt bad for a 34 year old.
06/11/2026 12:50:20
Enjoyed this and true on all fronts.
He made a brainless error in the first 5 mins of the first game of the season against Palace...but since that point has been arguably our player of the season.
Stats don't lie though, when he plays next to Jarrad, he and the team improve immeasurably.
06/11/2026 13:41:57
I think Tarkowski's greatest asset is his durability, he simply never misses a game, and when he plays he never hides. Obviously age and the sheer number of games he has played will eventually noticeably take their toll, but I would agree with those who say he has been our best player so far this season.
Of the many centre backs I have watched playing for Everton since the 1950's, my personal favourite was Richard Gough. Obviously he came right at the end of his career and only played about 40 odd games, but I thought he was terrific.
For the future, young Branthwaite has all the qualities to become the best of the lot, but he will need some of Tarkowski's durability if he is to fulfil his enormous potential.
06/11/2026 14:05:45
David (7), I also enjoyed watching Richard Gough, wish we could have gotten him earlier.
Colin Todd was another one that I wish we signed earlier.
I have to take issue with you though Sean with your mention of Mick Lyons. A not very good centre half in a poor team, in my opinion!
My dad always waxed lyrical about T G Jones but Brian labone is my first centre half recollection that stood out.
06/11/2026 15:28:51
David @ 7, I think your post is spot on, he's Mr. dependable.
Our defensive record over the last few years has been good so he must be doing some things well.
Darren is not a fan he's made that clear, it's all about opinions
though isn't it.
06/11/2026 16:19:30
Tarkowski has played very well this season not only as a centre back but also as a captain and leader. I noticed on Monday that while the rest of the team was in the corner celebrating the goal Tarkowski stayed close to the referee who was besieged by Newcastle players arguing that Schär had been fouled by Barry in the build-up. Managing the officials is a key aspect of the captains role in the modern game especially since the introduction of VAR. Referees have many voices banging their ear. Ensuring his teams view is heard is something at which Tarkowski is very adept.
The captain has also been effective keeping the team as a whole on track, intervening when necessary to calm Pickford and those team mates on the end of our keepers displeasure.
06/11/2026 17:26:06
Darren Hind, the floor is yours.
06/11/2026 17:58:12
David and Peter, that is interesting bringing up Richard Gough, because I also thought he was as good as any other central defender, I have seen playing for Everton.
The night we beat Liverpool at Anfield, when Kevin Campbell scored, was as good as a performance as Ive ever seen from a centre half playing for Everton, from Gough, although I also really enjoyed John Stones, playing against Chelsea, when Steven Naismith, came off the bench to score a hat-trick, with the crowd singing “money cant buy you Stones”
I like Tarkowski, although I didnt think he was helping the very inexperienced Rohl, out enough, when he started playing fullback, at the start of this season, but he has been good lately and central defenders, who have no pace, usually need a good few games to get upto speed after the summer break.
07/11/2026 01:53:23
I will never understand why you can't just enjoy the moment. Just sit back and grin, and when someone asks you why your grinning, don't answer them.
07/11/2026 09:10:09
Thanks Edward @11
I was kinda hoping I could wake up and bask in our third victory without being called out.
I saw this article yesterday and decided not to respond. I felt it was penned with people other than me in mind. But here goes.
I think in order to make what is essentially a journeyman defender sound like a top player, Sean has been very selective with his "facts". An awful lot of this post center aound one game, but he completely ignorse the bigger picture. The colosus upon which the Burnley defence was built was actually relegated - Despite him being surrounded by better players. While the blue in claret was sinking without trace. the real blues. Much maligned players like Kenny, Godfrey, Holgate, Doucourie, keane were staying up.
Tarkowski has only ever been involved in backs-to-the-wall survival battles, so to put him in the same bracket as trophy winners like Watson, Radcliffe and Labone would suggest his popularity has surpassed his ability. By some considerable distance.
We have all seen what JT looks like without Branthwaite, so it was with a wry smile that I read Sean telling me how much Jarradd (A rolls Royce of a player) was benefiting from playing next to a proven journey man.
I agree that Tarks is a throwback. He is a reminder of the times when Cult figures were often mistaken for Great players. His popularity seems to be based his cunning use of the dark arts. His hard man routine. His last ditch clearances. He is so "clever" because he "NEVER gets a red card" Well ones mans "cunning" is another mans fuck-wittery. Tarks has seen over 70 yellow cards. The majority of which were uneccesary. That means that an already limited player has had to try to see 70 games out while being handicapped by the fact that he cant afford to put another foot wrong. For a man who would likely finish second in a foot race with a lighthouse. Thats not a great position to be in. Thats why when he's marshalling our defence, the back four is more often than not a back six or seven - "Drop Five, Illman". All adds to the stats.
I hope that answers your question Edward. You may not agree, but I can only call it the way I see it. JT's style of play will always afford him impressive stats. Unfortunately the facts don't really support them.
Back to celebration mode; Moyes Barry and Tarks all earned their corn last night. Long may it continue
07/11/2026 10:19:42
Darren @ 15 Stats are, quite literally, “facts.
07/11/2026 20:03:00
Apologies Darren if you thought I was " calling you out" wasn't my intention. I enjoy reading your comments and opinions and whilst I disagree on some, I can somewhat see where your coming from re.Tarks. He IS getting slower ( happens to us all) and he definitely benefits from having Jarred alongside him, but in my opinion he is in a decent vein of form at present and that should be noted too.
Apologies again, just my idea of humour.
08/11/2026 05:36:48
My first of the greats I watched at Goodison was Brian Labone. Mr Dependable who made about 170 appearances with the number 5 on his back.
Tarks has been solid with the odd lapse since his move from Burnley in 2022. Not sure how many appearances he has made but my memory is saying he doesn't miss many so needs to sit in the Dependable Class.
Yes he makes mistakes every now and again but has, and is, immense in our defence.
Tarkowski detractors consider this. In 2022 Wesley Fofana Cost over £70m and Martinez, Man U, cost them a reported £48m or thereabouts so didn't we do well signing Tarks on a FREE from Burnley.
08/11/2026 08:58:47
No problem at all Edward. I was trying to be funny myself...maybe we both need to work on our delivery.
I think you are spot on. Tarkowski has found a very decent vein of form recently. I think you also nail the main reason why when you mention Branthwaite. Its amazing how much better our other center halves look when Jarrad plays. Tarks missed three games at the end of the season before last...They were tricky, but we won them all.
Peter
If believing we have a better options qualifies me to be "Tarkowski Detractor". I can assure you I know he was out of contract and we did not have to pay a fee for him. but he was a million miles away from being FREE.
When a player allows his contract to run down. Its generally because his agent has advised him that without having to pay a transfer fee. Interested parties would be in a position to offer a much heaftier salary.
Tarkowski earns 120 a week - 6.2m a year. With bonuses that could rise to 7.5m. he is contracted up to june 28. His earnings will be north of 40m for six seasons. I'm not one who begrudges footballers earning all they can, but for a guy pushing 30 who has just been relegated, Tarks hasnt done bad for himself.
Theres no such thing as a free player, Peter.
08/11/2026 10:43:06
Darren ( 19)
I just checked the figures..
Tarkowsky, when incorporating full performance related Bonuses, his total estimated earnings rise to approximately, £34,060,000.
Michael Kean. When factoring in performance related Bonuses, his total earnings could rise to £47,346,000.
Next year will be his 10th year with us.
In my Day, at that milestone, a testimonial was due, which was usually achieved by Cub Legends.
David Moyes- almost 13 years with us in total.
In his first stint with us, he earned, £26.5 million.
In his second stint to date, he is at £9.3 million.
,Whichever way you look at it, its nauseatingly absurd, vis- à-vis performance and the lack of them being an integral part of winning…err, emmm.. anything, for our Club.
08/11/2026 10:43:06
Darren ( 19)
I just checked the figures..
Tarkowsky, when incorporating full performance related Bonuses, his total estimated earnings rise to approximately, £34,060,000.
Michael Kean. When factoring in performance related Bonuses, his total earnings could rise to £47,346,000.
Next year will be his 10th year with us.
In my Day, at that milestone, a testimonial was due, which was usually achieved by Cub Legends.
David Moyes- almost 13 years with us in total.
In his first stint with us, he earned, £26.5 million.
In his second stint to date, he is at £9.3 million.
,Whichever way you look at it, its nauseatingly absurd, vis- à-vis performance and the lack of them being an integral part of winning…err, emmm.. anything, for our Club.
08/11/2026 12:22:08
The aggression stuff - throwing players to the floor, pulling hair, squaring up - is usually a sign of a defenders physical dominance is declining as his legs go. Ashley Williams did the same before he got loaned to Stoke.
Tarks was the right player in 2022, but we have not needed his blocking and clearance, throw your body in the way style for the last 18 months. He also forces us to play in a lower block than we would need to with OBrien and Branthwaite.
He has done well for us, including this season, but we need better if/when we get new owners.
08/11/2026 13:00:58
Peter like you Labone was the first of the “legend centre halves we have had but believe he will have made a lot more than 170 appearances at No 5 in his total of 451!
In terms of Tarkowski he has done an outstanding job for us over the last few seasons but I do think its time we look at pairing OBrien with Branthwaite. Whilst at the moment we have 4 centre backs it will be another potential problem position in the summer. Keane will be gone, Tarks will likely be another half yard slower and Branthwaite may be sacrificed to raise funds so we need to see if OBrien is a PL centre back. For what its worth I think he is
08/11/2026 18:12:25
For those who have expressed a different view to me on Tarks okay but let me make it clear that I wasn't suggesting that he was/is the best in his position but I maintain we did very well in signing him and he has been a good solid signing for us. His old fashioned type of centre half is fast disappearing and our next man in that position is probably going to be a Branthwaite type.
Is that new style person going to be as durable as Tarks and Labone. I have my doubts. There is no doubt though in my mind that we got a good servant when we got him and he was paid the ridiculous rate all Prem League footballers get, But don't get me started on footballers pay.
John @23 you are probably right looking at it now. Don't know where I got that number from but as you say it doesn't look right.
Lastly, talking about wages Darren what do you think about Calvert-Lewin getting about £6.5m a year (even though he didn't do his job and score goals he wanted a rise before he would sign a new contract), compares to what Tarks was getting for doing what he was paid to do?
08/11/2026 18:39:59
Lovely piece, Sean.
08/11/2026 18:57:06
UPDATE ON BRIAN LABONE GAMESRe post 18 I've checked as best I can and Brian was a one Club man who played for Everton between 1958 and 1970/71 season before he retired due to a serious Archilles injury.
In that time he played 451 league, 46 cup and 19 European games. Not easy to add up his career injuries and games missed as the numbers have not been aggregated. If anyone want's to go back and add up, season by season, his injury record they are welcome but I'm not going to. My memory is that he missed very few.
European games - what are they????
Thanks John @ 23 for querying the figure I stated which made me go back and check.
08/11/2026 19:25:46
Lot to like about the guy.
I thought last season was his worst for us. Probably because he was so often paired with Keane. Together, they are just way too immobile to play at this level and it seriously affected the structure / tactics of the team. Individually, Keane looked the better player.
This season, paired again with Branthwaite, Tarkowski is performing really well.
My hope is that this is his last season as a regular starter though. His lack of pace does drag the defensive line back (dragging the midfield back in turn and leaving the forwards isolated).
As the playing staff generally improves in quality, we hopefully won't be in such regular need of the last ditch stuff he really excels at. Instead we will need recovery pace and more quality on the ball. If we can find a player with a combination of these qualities then great - but if not then hopefully Branthwaite can turn into a real leader on the pitch.
08/11/2026 19:40:36
As much as it kills me to say, I'd be very surprised if Jarrad is still an Everton player next season.
09/11/2026 09:28:41
I don't think DCL is any of our business anymore, Peter.
I don't think he could get away from our club quick enough. I don't think his job was solely to score goals, he was our plan A,B and C.
I think his presence held us back as a club. A succession of Everton managers placed all their trust in his ability to fight for and win the long ball because they simply didnt trust the other players to football their way up the park.
I know Newcastle and a few other wannabe clubs were interested in him. I was told that he was expecting 20-25m signing on fee if he let his contract run down. I can well believe that, but I also believe he got his fingers well and truely burnt. The form he was in when Newcastle were sniffing went right out of the window when he got injured AGAIN. He was now officially a "sick note" and they were hardly queueing around the block for him.
I was told by somebody who is ITK at Leeds that his signing on fee at Leeds ended up being a mere 5m. My heart bled for him. Especially when I consider I didnt earn a fraction of that for over half a century of hard collar.
Was he a good signing for Leeds ? You'd have to ask a Leeds fan that. Theyre the ones who see him every week. He does seem to be a lot more popular there than he was here.
09/11/2026 11:54:34
Peter out of interest I took a quick look at Labones appearance record, curtesy of transfermarkt. If you take out the first and last couple of seasons of his career as he was breaking in to the team then starting to struggle with injuries at the tail end he played in 423 league games out of 462, or 38.5 games a season out of 42, so pretty durable during the core of his career.
Took a look at Tarks as well for the last 9 seasons in the PL. Out of 342 games he has played in 321 matches so 35.5 games a season out of 38, and some of his misses will be due to suspension so even more durable than Labone!
09/11/2026 12:10:50
Tarkowski reminds me of Lyons in the sense he is rather lumbering and unbalanced and has no speed. Lyons was at the heart of a chronically underachieving Everton era that followed on from the great teams of the 60s. Like Tarkowski, Lyons was admired for being hard and committed and a true Blue. But he was a dinosaur and so very limited as I think Tarkowski is. I think he's a liability, who takes risks with his rash gamesmanship. If we win anything while he's playing for us it will be in spite of, rather than because of, him.
12/11/2026 21:09:12
I like Tarkowski and think he has played very well since he came here apart from last season when I thought he came back too early from his hamstring injury the previous season, he has done well this season and I think that obviously Branthwaite is the better footballer but hes had to be very careful nursing the injuries hes had in the past so Tarkowski has been the main and best defender this season.
From the past players Labone has been one of the best over a very long period and possibly was “ The last of the Corinthians” when he labelled with that title - a gentleman footballer. Richard Gough was very good in that one full season he played for us but unfortunately he only played a couple of games in his last season.
I could name a few more but Peter Hobans @ (7) dad saw the best of the very best in TG Jones - I only saw him through the eyes of a 7 and 8 year boy but never forgot the brilliance of a thorough classy footballer— His arguement with Theo Kelly, the manager stopped me from seeing too many times after Kelly refused to let him go to an Italian club and the money he would have earned from that.
13/11/2026 11:53:44
Sorry Sean, this cannot be correct? There are certain posters on this and other sites (one poster in particular) who cannot wait to tell anyone who will listen that Tarkowski is one of the worst defenders to ever pull on the jersey, and is actually responsible for every goal Everton have conceded since 1960, and also to blame for climate change, most wars, and the cost of living crisis. (Despite all evidence to the contrary in terms of watching him play and irrefutable stats).
Maybe they operate on a higher plane to us mere mortals and can see something that we dont?
Or maybe - could it really be so, surely not - they are just plain WRONG???
14/11/2026 12:28:41
"irrefuteble stats" ? Hahaha.
I think I would trust the judgment of dozens and dozens of managers who have managed top five 6 teams over the past 15 years and have not shown the slightest interest in signing Tarkowski. Not to mention all those England managers who have given him a very wide berth when selecting their teams for tournaments.
The teams he has played for are always anchored to their own penalty area making it impossible for them to progress. Thats why he has won the aquare root of nothing in 15 years.
While some will have their opinions formed for them by spotty faced kids compiling meaningly stats they don't quite understand. Others will form their own based on what they know, what they see and official records...The facts.
"irrefutable stats" An oxymoron if ever I heard one. It explains an awful lot
Add Your Thoughts
Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.
Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.
34 Comments ↓