Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Frank Sheppard
18/11/2026    07:09:20

Under Moyes v1- we usually finished top end of the middle section of the PL.

This was excellent bearing in mind what he inherited.

It says much about the disaster the club has been since he left, that if Moyes v2 repeated this. It would be more of an achievement it was first time around.

If we could manage a cup win, the feel good factor would be a very positive reset.

2  Paul Conway
18/11/2026    15:37:07

Since the eighties, it’s been more than rough supporting Everton, with the exception of an FA Cup win.

It’s even more baffling, when you consider the quarter - finals and semi - finals and the manner, by which we brushed aside Newcastle and Spurs, to reach the final.

I don’t remember us repeating such performances for the remainder of that decade.. unless, someone can remind me.

So, here we are 31 years later and nothing to shout about, except for a few “Oufffs!!, when we snatched relegation, from the jaws of the Crocodile, figuratively speaking.

The emotional ride, over those years, for myself, hasn’t quite equated to the “ Stockholm syndrome “, but more akin to :

The Direct Loss Dopamine Study (Linnet et al., 2010)

The study that most directly proves losing money itself creates a chemical reward rush is a 2010 brain-imaging study published in Addiction titled "Dopamine release in ventral striatum of pathological gamblers losing money

• The Experiment. Researchers used Positron Emission Tomography (PET) scans to measure dopamine levels in 16 pathological gamblers and 15 healthy control subjects while they played the Iowa Gambling Task.

• The Findings. When pathological gamblers lost money, they experienced a significant surge in dopamine release in the left ventral striatum (the brain's core reward and pleasure center), whereas healthy controls showed no such spike.

• The Takeaway. When participants won money, there was no difference in dopamine release between the two groups. For problem gamblers, the brain chemically rewards the act of losing, which drives the compulsion to keep betting.

The above case study has summed up the relationship between Everton and myself.

Some, people ask.. “why Bother ?”.. the answer to that is the “Jam
Tomorrow syndrome !”

I honestly hope that this new Dawn heralds much well deserved success, especially for our younger supporters, who hitherto have been positively starved.
For Arl Fella’s like myself, well! it’s the Twilight.. or the Depature Lounge !

3  Jerome Shields
18/11/2026    15:49:29


Sean it is good that Moyes steadied the ship but let's not pretend steady is the same as sailing.

The article asks the right question, "where could we be if he'd lift the handbrake?" then immediately calls it "purely hypothetical." That's us all over, isn't it? We know the football's cautious, we know there's more in this squad, and we talk ourselves out of wanting it.

I get it. We were on the brink, more than once. Moyes dragged us out of the mud and we're a proper Premier League side again. That matters. But that's recovery, not progress. Recovery has a ceiling, and nobody in the piece ever says what happens after we hit it.

592 games level with Catterick is a lovely stat. Catterick won things though, didn't he? And being disappointed to miss out on Europe isn't progress, it's just us remembering we used to expect better.

The comment underneath says it all, really: if Moyes doing what he did first time round would now be a bigger achievement, that says more about how far the club fell than it does about the manager.

I'll take stability. I'm grateful for it. But when every grumble gets answered with "remember where we've been," we stop asking for more, and that's how a big club settles for being a nice one. Signs of life are great. I'd just like a direction to go with them.

4  Bobby Thomas
18/11/2026    16:17:36

Catterick had massive spending power in the transfer market.

English football’s biggest transfer spenders by decade:

60s: Everton
70s: Everton
80s: Man United
90s: Newcastle
00s: Chelsea
10s: Man City
20s: Chelsea

5  Darren Hind
18/11/2026    16:29:18

I don't think we have anything at all to thank Davey Moyes for,

Everton FC has made him one of the richest failures in sporting history.

He should be on his knees in gratitude. 12.5m to add to the 30m he earned first time around.

Good job he wasnt here when we got all those points deducted. He struggles enough when there is no pressure on him

6  John Raftery
18/11/2026    17:50:20

Lifting the handbrake is an interesting concept. One of Harry Catterick’s most entertaining seasons was the 1968/69 edition when the team played some exceptional attacking football but won nothing. For the following season it could be said he applied the handbrake by tightening up the defence, made the team tougher to beat, lost only five matches, won many important victories by one goal margins and lifted the title. One nil to the Everton was never a terrace chant but it would have been justified during that season.

Both Catterick and Kendall believed the foundation of a team’s success was a solid defence. Although the modern game is very different from their days the fundamentals remain the same. We have had a manager who seemed to have no idea what a handbrake was. His name was Roberto Martinez.

7  Philip Sheehan
18/11/2026    17:53:09

bobby just to give your list of big spenders a bit more context - in the 70's catterick was in charge 70-71 but in 71-72 season he was really only in charge up yo early january 72 when he had a heart attack...i seem to remember trainer tommy casey being a caretaker.
in short bingham and lee did most of the spending in the 70's
inexplicably bingham allowed to make 2 big signings just weeks before he got his p45 !
the players. bruce rioch & duncan mc'kenzie as for davie I was ok with him until he made the knives to a gunfight presser ! a great morale booster to his players - NOT !
& his attitude towards little everton when he got the man utd job was terrible. but fickle as I am if and ita big IF we beat brentford & liverpool all is forgiven !!!

8  Christine Foster
18/11/2026    19:48:12

Sean, a good attempt at saying "we should be thankful for David Moyes" A sentiment I cannot disassociate from how badly this club has been run, especially during the Kenwright era. Many people, rightly want to forget that period (I wish I could) and like it or not, David Moyes will forever be seen as part of that particular problem.
He is more of a stoic scot, than a successful manager, unless you judge success as remaining in the Premier league, which with Everton, has been no mere feat. He is a sold, no risk manager who will deliver you a team that at its peak will be best of the rest.
Clearly TFG in appointing him just wanted that, a safe pair of hands on the cheap while they enacted their 3 year strategic business plan. It makes perfect sense now. Business wise.

Being a safe pair of hands when you need them is a brilliant attribute and after Dyche it's what was needed to stave off relegation and in the eyes of TFG it was an ideal choice.
But Everton aspire to win. Well, the fans do.. but TFG is about revenue, profit and not trophies.
We have gone from one extreme to another, from a club with zero business acumen, to one with one purely focused on revenue. And in both its a place David Moyes excels. Mr Average. He will keep you a respectable league position and drive you mad doing it. He is very good at it but falls short on success. He has been incredibly lucky to have found Everton twice in his life, he has profited greatly for it but failed to inspire fans, well anywhere to be truthful. His three club spell with Man U, Real Sociedad and Underland were awful and yet he delivered exactly what West Ham needed, but still roundly condemned by fans.
He's not a winner like Ancelotti, Klopp, Mourinho etc.. he is the stability. Now many hear appear thankful for that but it should be a building block for success and that for me is where David Moyes falls short, and that's more of an acknowledgement of his contributions rather than a condemnation of his failure.
Steady Eddie's don't win anything, pat him on the back this May, thank him and move on.

9  David Abrahams
18/11/2026    20:14:42

Bobby (4) “ Catterick had massive spending power in the 1960’s ? He bought West, Wilson, Young, Stevens, Kay, Veall and stole Morrissey from Liverpool.

The sale of Bobby Collins bought Dennis Stevens, the sale of Jimmy Harris helped with sale of Young, Tony Kay cost the most but what a brilliant buy, Veall cost £11,000 and shared the left wing role with Morrissey and 4 appearances from Temple.

All those signings were very good and gave years of excellent service to Everton except Veall who helped us win the league title and sold for about the same price we bought him for while Tony Kay was a massive loss and banned for life for a crime he committed with another club — hardly massive spending Bobby even at that time.

10  Kevin Molloy
18/11/2026    21:14:03

I think you're damning with faint praise there Christine. I don't see where we are as 'average'. Moyes took over a shit show, and then had the rug pulled out from him. And yet we seem to have the best team we've had in years.
He's a very good manager, in my view.

11  John Raftery
18/11/2026    21:21:02

Hi Dave (9) I agree with your point with one small correction. Alex Young was actually a Johnny Carey signing along with Billy Bingham, Roy Vernon, Jimmy Gabriel, Tommy Ring and Mickey Lill. The club’s reputation for big spending was established under Carey following the financial support provided by John Moores.

Alex Scott was a Catterick signing in early 1963. He replaced Billy Bingham. A year later came Fred Pickering and of course the one and only Alan Ball for a record fee in August 1966. While Ball and Kendall were key figures in the 1969/70 title success, that squad contained many home grown players including Wright, Hurst, Labone, Kenyon, Harvey, Husband, Whittle and Royle. Most certainly by the late sixties the club was hardly a big spender in the transfer market. The new Main Stand, built in 1969/70, was given funding priority ahead of team strengthening.

12  Robert Tressell
18/11/2026    21:37:07

Another article that holds Moyes responsible for nearly 40 years of club mismanagement.

He’s a very good manager for where we are as a club.

He’s not a great longer term fit IF we demonstrate ambition by way of investment in the playing squad.

Hopefully next summer we do exactly that - and begin the transformation into a much more exciting proposition.

But Moyes has never ever been just about relegation. He is far and away our most successful manager of the last 40 years - consistently over performing and operating at the top half of the table.

And he has done that without the kitty of, say, Joe Royle (noting Kanchelskis would cost about £135m in today’s market).

13  Bobby Thomas
18/11/2026    23:16:42

Dave #9

Gordon West's fee (£27k) was a record for a keeper.

Tony Kay (£60k) Fred Pickering (£85k), and Alan Ball (£110k) were all British record transfers.

Henry Newton (£110k) was a record for a defender.

Howard Kendall's fee was in the same ballpark at about £80k.

I'd call that massive spending power.

That is a level of backing Moyes has quite obviously never received. But it doesn't stop some on here expecting him to match the Cat's achievements. It's bizarre.

Yeah, because that's really likely when you have built a very decent side and are desperate for a striker and your board goes LARGE and gives you the spending power to land Jermaine Beckford on a free.

WHY AREN'T YOU WINNING THE LEAGUE WITH BECKFORD UP TOP, MOYES? FRAUD! LOSER!

When Beckford predictably doesn't work out as he is not up to standard, the board go again and this time pull out all the stops and provide the firepower to sign Denis Stracqualursi on loan.

BUT YOUR STILL NOT WINNING STUFF MOYES. FAILURE! BOTTLER!

The notion that this club has been in any condition to win stuff at any point in the last 30-odd years is laughable.

There are some consistently warped and deeply odd takes on here (see #5) in respect of Moyes. In some cases, I guess these individuals must still support the big club version of Everton that ceased to exist around the turn of the century.

Moyes is easily the best manager to have been through this place since Howard first time around. Easily.

14  Christine Foster
19/11/2026    08:30:39

Kevin I'm not being harsh with my determination of Moyes, in certain situations, as we found ourselves in, he was then and is now, a solid manager, not poor, not great, hence he is safe pair of hands, but that's not going to take us forward on the pitch. Given we are now for sale, I suspect TFG may well extend his contract rather than make a risker decision during any sale.

As a bit of analysis as to why we are where we are, the BBC have just put up an article comparing Everton and the "Big Six" and the impact of just how badly we failed to commercially capitalise the early years of the PL leading to where we find ourselves now and frankly why We are being sold. The gap is almost impossible to bridge financially, even more so now with the advent of SCR.

Good and sobering explanation as to why we, Newcastle or Villa cannot hope to compete.

https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/articles/c6x28e93zv3jo


15  Craig Walker
19/11/2026    09:28:22

Moyes frustrates the hell out of me, at times but it's a case of stick or twist. West Ham thought they were better than David Moyes and tried to be more free-flowing. Look where they are now.

The game has changed since Moyes' first period and, I would argue, it was easier to be the best of the rest in those days.

I must admit, when Martinez took the reins it felt like a new dawn. We played attacking football with some memorable performances. He gave Coleman, Barkley and Stones prominent roles. He recruited Barry, McCarthy, Deulofeu and Lukaku (how we would kill for a striker of that quality, now). There was a swagger about the whole club. Ultimately, he ended up believing his own hype and it proved to be yet another false dawn but that is maybe the last time I genuinely thought we were onto something. There has been the odd period since but it does feel like we are back to where we started; a reasonably competitive team with some quality players but, frankly, just making up the numbers. Do we accept that as our lot and be thankful for preserving our long-running top division status whilst constantly reminiscing about the glory days or do we try something different with the possible risks of going the same way as West Ham and others?

16  Dave White
19/11/2026    10:13:18

Craig, couldn’t say it better myself mate.

Some clubs seem to be set up for yoyo-ing between the divisions…but I’ve always had a chilling suspicion we are not one of them, so to drop out of the prem could be disastrous for us.

17  David Abrahams
19/11/2026    10:29:03

John (11) Quite correct John Young was bought along with George Thomson from Hearts — I don’t know why this skipped my post because I have always thought that Harry Catterick wouldn’t have bought Alex Young if he had that option.

Bobby (13) Yes those last players you named Ball and Kay were wanted by other clubs and Harry used his wits to get Ball, Tony Kay was easier and knew Harry well having worked with him at Sheffield Wed. Henry Newton was a poor buy but I think Harry wasn’t a well man at that time and coming to the end of his time at Everton.

Bobby regards to Moyes being the best manager since Kendall mark one well it’s not a great list but do you think Moyes would have last eleven and a half years while John Moore’s owned the club, you like Moyes Bobby and you can have him he’s not my cup of tea by a long way.

18  Kevin Molloy
19/11/2026    12:45:31

with the worst aspect of all being Christine we don't even want to compete. The last thing our owners want is a lifting of the barriers preventing us from spending money. they have a copper bottomed excuse for not investing, 'we'd love to, but it's the rules'.
If we finished 12th from now until eternity, that would suit the Friedkins just fine.

19  Antony Abrahams
19/11/2026    13:21:53

I read the people who are saying that Moyes, is a very good manager and then I shake my head and think what has he ever won?

He’s an okay manager, with some good traits but when people start arguing about him never having the money, my own view is that I’m not convinced that he would know what to do with it.

He created some good teams in his first spell at Everton, and was very unfortunate that he lost the spine of his team, for his one cup final, but if David, had real belief, a bit more spine and more of a personality, then I’m sure he could have given us a lot more than he ever did.

The whole argument is boring now. David is doing a decent job, under his favourite circumstances imo, because just like it was under Bill Kenwright, he can’t really lose with our current owners either.

One thing that I never thought I’d ever say is that Everton football club, actually bores me right now especially when people argue that a manager who has been in charge for nearly half of our longest ever barren spell, a spell that has never been known before, has been our most successful manager, since we last won a trophy, all those years ago🙈

Prioritise the cups David, because if you could make me eat my words it would be beautiful🤞

20  Kevin Molloy
19/11/2026    13:58:12

I'm not sure the trophy cabinet is the best barometer to judge an Everton manager Tony. Ancelotti is arguably the most successful manager since time began, but comparing the two in their stints here, I'd say Moyes has us on the better trajectory, with a whole lot less money spent, and him having had to take over a much weaker team.

21  Bobby Thomas
19/11/2026    14:17:08

David #17

"Bobby regards to Moyes being the best manager since Kendall mark one well it’s not a great list but do you think Moyes would have last eleven and a half years while John Moore’s owned the club?"

No, I don't.

With respect it was getting on for 70 years ago.

The Moores family exited the club in the early 90's.

The version of Everton you are using as a yardstick doesn't exist anymore and it quite honestly has nothing to do with how we move forward.

It's time for our fans to face facts. If you are over 35 or 40 years of age (I am) then the club you grew up supporting has gone.

To anyone under the age of 40yrs, we are absolutely indistinguishable from Crystal Palace or Leicester etc.

Our main achievement has been grimly hanging around the Prem like a bad smell and being not quite shit enough to get relegated. Moshiri put the lid on the decline. The club is a shadow of its former self.

Many seem to think one managerial appointment, some magic bullet of a manager, will reverse decades of mismanagement and lead us back to the elite.

It will take a decades worth or more of smart decisions and more than one appointment to stabilise the club and get it to where it should be. To me, that looks like regularly playing european football.

The current manager is doing an excellent job of stabilising things and will give us european football if the board actually give him some help in the market.

22  Robert Tressell
19/11/2026    14:21:10

Antony # 19, I think Moyes is a very good manager for a certain type of club.

We are that club (and even then he has annoying traits and limitations).

He is not the guy for a rich club in it to win trophies. But we are not that sort of club.

To others looking on the bleak side of things - I would say YET.

Operating on the fringes of the Rich 6 should stand us in much better stead. At least one or two of them take it in turns to be dysfunctional and underperform leaving gaps in the Champions League places.

Time and money will allow us to fill those gaps on a reasonably regular basis

23  Mal Kay
19/11/2026    14:28:13

Some of the comments from Moyes supporters seem to indicate that the reason that he failed to win anything with us was because he wasn't backed in the transfer market, especially strikers.

I might be wrong but I think he signed Yakubu, Johnson and Beattie and they were all record signings at the time.

Moyes has never been comfortable with strikers, he converted Antonio at West Ham.

I'm not saying he hasn't done a good job at stabilising the club, but with the gap between us and the Sky Six, we can only compete over one or two seasons and then rebuild, which I don't think Moyes can do...

24  Antony Abrahams
19/11/2026    15:26:11

There are two types of Evertonian, imo Bobby. Those who accept our place and praise Moyes, or those who will never accept Everton, being in amongst the mediocrity, and wanting more.

We are not that club, I agree Robert, but that’s because Kenwrightt, kidded way too many Evertonians, which allowed the rot to set in.

Now that rot, isn’t really a rot, to a lot of people, but it will always be a rot to some of us because we have always seen Everton differently.

Catterick won because he had money, Moyes never won anything because he never had enough money. Not for me, because I can still remember more than enough capitulations under David, unfortunately.

This means he has never done more than a decent job imo

25  Harry Hockley
19/11/2026    16:09:28

Moyes is a very good manager, not good, not average, not a make do, not solid, very good.

I’m hugely thankful for his dedication and acumen over both stints with us especially given the circumstances whether it be a shoe string budget or dicey owners (usually both!) the man certainly knows how to navigate a club no matter how challenging it may be. We should be thankful as he cares dearly about us.

I also think this year may yield silverware? no one deserves it more than Moyes with us. New owners on the horizon? Things can only get betterrr can only get betterrr now I’ve found you! :)

26  Darren Hind
19/11/2026    16:17:48

Bobby Thomas

I think you'll find it's your opinion which is warped. Moyes has earned (rather been paid) around 40m by this club. Do you want to dispute that ?

While many other managers have won trophies with lesser clubs on smaller budgets. Moyes, despite earning comfotably more than every single one of them, Not to mention getting so much more time, has not been able to come close to winning one for us - Wanna despute that too ?.

Do you honestly think ANY other club would have paid him so handsomely for so long For nothing in return.

You make excuses for Moyes by claiming he was only given the likes of Beckford and Straqualursi to work with. Do you think we werent there too ?. He was given 36 million in 3 seasons to buy Beatie, Johnson and Yakubu. That may not seem like a lot today, but it was 20 years ago. They all came with reputations for being prolific scorer, but Moyes eventually Killed them all with his cowardly get-after-that- balls into the corner flags, No striker could score goals in his set up. Thats why Goodison became known as the strikers grave yard.

BTW he was also given 12m to spend on Mirallas and Jelovic to supply goals. Not to mention high cless loans like Donovan and Saha

Nobody has ever held Moyes responsible for the forty years in which this club has been poorly run. Thats just a claim designed to excuse the times when he has personally failed.

He will always be judged by his own failures. Nobody elses. Just as he will be judged by his own success.....At least he would be if he ever achieved any.

Forty mill and counting to have your mediocrity happy clapped. Nice work if you can get it.

27  David Abrahams
19/11/2026    17:15:59

Bobby (21) I know how Everton look to supporters of other clubs and how you see them— I see Everton the same way and it’s been like that for a long time before Johnson took over but made worse when Kenwright took over and mortgaged the club bit by it until we owned very little of it and Moyes first time at the club he became one of the highest paid managers in Europe and had a job forever under Kenwright and was happy to stay that way until his ego got the better of him and he thought was good enough to manage one of the top clubs — he lasted less than a year which was a lot longer than United fans and some of their players wanted.

During that time Moyes stated, in an article I read, that the manager of a football club should be the highest paid person at the club and indeed he was until Arteta was paid more to keep him at the club the first time Arsenal came calling.

Moyes, for me, is the luckiest manager in the game to have been paid those enormous wages with the mediocre, very mediocre, talent he has got.

Harry (25) Younare very grateful for Moyes dedication and acumen over both periods of his time whether it was with shoe string budget or dicy owners and he cares about us — it might surprise you that Dyche running the club with the help of Thelwell when that dodgy chairman and his board of directors left the club in the lurch got the same number of points in his last season as Moyes did last year when you add the points deducted to his total.

We are sixth now after playing most of our fixtures against teams in the bottom of the table — let’s see we were are when it counts — in May 2027.

28  Robert Tressell
19/11/2026    19:11:07

Antony, there is some fundamental misunderstanding here.

No posters accept mediocrity. Being crap for most of the last 40 years is clearly not good enough.

Recognising why we have been crap over different periods of those 40 years is a completely different issue.

29  Christine Foster
19/11/2026    19:13:17

Be thankful for what you got it's a phrase I have heard for the past 20 odd years from supporters of the dynamic duo, M & K right through to today.

I'm not and never will be. Not only that, the article from the BBC puts the blame for where we are now squarely on the management of the club and its failure (yes, failure) to take advantage of the commercial opportunities others did.

Chicken or egg, a successful team generates income or income generates a successful team? You can't have one without the other. Moyes has never been and never will be seen as a successful manager. Success is about desire to win, not a desire of not to lose. Therein lies the story of David Moyes. Mr Pragmatic.

And before the happy clippers rush in to clobber me over the head with their shovels, remember, I wanted him back for that very reason to get us out of the hole dug by the charlatans who have run this mighty club into the ground.

But as I said then, short term. But no, we let him get his feet under the table. He will need prising out to go and take the Scotland job at some point.

I believe in winners, they create the magic of generations, not David Moyes. He has his uses but teams who aspire to winners would never choose him. His one chance at immortality as Fergusons successor was blown in less than a season, fans aren't wrong mostly.

To succeed you need the right blend of owner, manager and timing. The latter because the current Big Six are the flagship of the Premier League Inc. Protected as a business model by rules designed to keep it that way. The gap as pointed out by the BBC is huge and not only that, in my opinion almost insurmountable under the current regulations.

What then is success? Just existing in a league where the stakes are huge? Just competing for a European place? Or winning the odd trophy here and there?

I would love to here from anyone of those fans who are happy just to be here, what is your idea of success? And exactly how we are going to achieve it without the drive, passion or expertise of all involved pulling in the same direction?

Winners make winners.

30  Kevin Molloy
19/11/2026    19:55:11

I don't recall too many people saying be thankful for what you've got through the reigns of our last eight managers Christine.. But yes, I can see why some people are saying it just now. We've got a manager coming into his last six months, who has overseen a shift from Jack Harrison Doucoure and Dwight McNeil to three outstanding teenagers, KDH, and a striker who is either scoring or assisting in every game.
this didn't just happen, this is down to the manager. And it's impressive work, particularly when factoring in the shits from Texas.

31  Christine Foster
19/11/2026    20:10:51

Kevin, on this site alone, the majority of people polling believe Moyes should be offered a new contract. 53% that is, over 31,000 to be more precise. Why?
He builds a better team? That achieves exactly what? Trophies?, that's one in total throughout his career.
I am not just saying it now, I said it when he was appointed, his attributes are limited but they were still the attributes we needed to survive. But they will not take us a step up unless we now admit we are just happy to survive?
There is something fundamentally wrong in a competition were only 6 clubs can win unless there is an aberration bt VAR or some other outliner. But that's doesn't mean we should accept it either.

32  Bobby Thomas
19/11/2026    20:45:52

I think Moyes has actually evolved into a better manager than he has ever been, which is pretty remarkable when you think he's been at it since the late 90's and how much the game and players have changed during that time.

Lets say Moyes gets a 3 year extension and moves Everton to being consistently in the mix for european qualification and we actually (gasp!) start having decent cup runs. Lets say we qualified for europe 2 out of 3 seasons.

He managed it last time he was here. Did it at West Ham.

What is it about this very real and achievable prospect - we are moving towards it - that some find so objectionable?

In case anyone hasn't noticed, we have a track record of DOING ABSOLUTELY FUCK ALL.

It would be an enormous improvement on the previous decade. We blasted through countless managers. The constant churn damaged the club.

There is a significant element in our fan base that is persistently fractious and welcomes any excuse to kick off.

These toxic people do not help the club. They undermine it.

I'm sure the current Barcelona winger - who was shite apparently - misses being chased down the street by our "fans".

33  Antony Abrahams
19/11/2026    20:58:17

As far as I’m concerned Robert, any supporter that says David Moyes, is a very good manager, is a person who is accepting mediocrity.

My own view is that a good manager would have put silverware in the trophy room, when they had players like Baines, Pienaar, Jagielka, Arteta, Yakubu, Cahill, Coleman & Distin, in their squad, and a very good manager, would have won at least a couple of trophies.

We all see different things and have different opinions, mine is that David Moyes, would have been so much better if he knew how to use a squad of players, whereas others will say poor David, has never been given the money to assemble a proper squad.

Kendall, had Richardson and Harper, players who could fill in a number of different positions, and Moyes, signed players like Neville and Heitenga, for exactly the same reason. The one big difference is that in Kendall’s day, you could only use thirteen players, and therefore needed a little bit of versatility, whereas it’s pretty clear (to me) that David prefers versatility because he doesn’t like having too many choices.

Like I say, nothing would give me more pleasure than watching David Moyes deliver us some silverware, but for him to do this then he his going to have to break the habit of a lifetime, and generate the belief that would make him a lot braver, imo. Like I said we all see different things and that’s my overall view of David.

34  Philip Sheehan
19/11/2026    21:48:33

i find myself agreeing with christine & antony @ 24 DM guilty by association with BK. [ could imagine bill saying 'sorry dave we can't afford to buy a full back so play sylvan or joleon there but never mind we'll make you one of the highest paid managers in the league'
anyway as per usual with everton, everything is up in the air as new owners seem a million miles away so will TFG retain his stability services or to save a few bob will they let him go when his contract is up - and then hire a cheaper option.
DM too many capitulations for me and how we fell down last april and may would have been a sackable offence at any other club..

35  Paul Conway
19/11/2026    22:44:12

Harry Hockley ( 25 )

There’s nothing wrong with expressing an opinion, that David Moyes is “ very good”.

But, stating that “we should be thankful, as he cares dearly about us”, is absolutely outrageous and bordering on sect like mentality, given the way he showed us back in 2013, exactly how much he cared about us, when he sneaked out of our Club, to manage United.

Now, whether there can be an argument made, for the fact that he was only trying, to better himself, as players also do, is another subject.

But, there is definitely argument to be made, about the fact that he would do it again, if a similar offer of management at a successful Club, was to be offered to him.

Trust in me… trust in me… close your eyes and go to sleep…

36  Steve Brown
19/11/2026    00:16:04

Debates about David Moyes are always very circular, but..I actually think it is remarkable how little he has evolved as a manager over the last 25 years. His tactics, game management, attitude, caution, reliance on experience over talent and building a team from the defence - they have never changed.

Very good managers win trophies, get their teams into Europe every year, develop young talent and have a win ratio of 50% plus. Unai Emery is a good example. David Moyes is none of those things, but as Robert says, he is probably the right manager for right now.

Owners who want to sell, small squad and the need to sell players to buy in the transfer market - Moyes is able to work in these circumstances and get the team to mid-table.

If TFG want to make a profit of £200 million on the sale of the club, then it could take years to get rid of them. And during that time, their investment in the squad will be minimal.

37  Steve Brown
20/11/2026    03:31:30

Bobby @ 32, “ There is a significant element in our fan base that is persistently fractious and welcomes any excuse to kick off. These toxic people do not help the club. They undermine it.”

Blaming the fans for the state of affairs over the last 25 years is deplorable and disgraceful.

The fans are the only reason that this club is still in existence. From 2021-2024, they lifted this club above successive relegation fights when our auditors put in the club accounts that dropping down would affect our ability to remain as a going concern.

Relegation battles, points deductions, absent owner, chairman and board.- we were on an absolute precipice and the fans dragged us through it. You should withdraw that comment.

38  Kieran Fitzgerald
20/11/2026    07:35:34

With the benefit of hindsight now, the PL was a little more of a level playing field during his first stint than his second.

He built a decent enough squad the first time around, but it was based on players being cheaper than now, even with our limited finances at the time, and an advantage in a detailed knowledge of quality players from managing in the Championship.

These two factors gave him the chance to win things, when it was still a little easier to do so. Moyes just lacked that something in his makeup.

Martinez, in his first season, showed what was possible with the squad Moyes had in his last season.


39  Antony Abrahams
20/11/2026    07:44:32

A lot of those traits you mention about David Moyes, are the keys to staying in the premier league, imo Steve.

Then when you’re given over eleven and a half years to slowly build on things, without having any real pressure, I don’t think it’s that hard to improve, especially when you have got most of the fans onside, inside a snarling Goodison Pk.

That was Moyes part one, but to go through exactly the same again would be too painful for a lot of us, so hopefully he has evolved and knows how good it is to win a trophy after his experience at West Ham

40  Darren Hind
20/11/2026    08:30:27

I don't think any comments should be withdrawn, Steve. They prove to be a really good insight into the thinking of a sizeable section of the fanbase. They've had their expectations managed to the point where They now believe we are comparable to Leicester and Palace. Even though our next home attendance is likely to top their combined total.

Can we ever be successful again with this mentality ? No. I don't think so. Why would any owners risk going for broke when they are consistently told by so many fans that they are happy with the way things are.

Ordinary players who wouldnt get near top six teams become "legends" they are grateful for a manager who "Loves the club" despite his disgraceful behaviour towards it when he tried to expose our desperate financial state when trying to get Fellaini and Baines for a song.

You are right of course, Fans may come on forums like these to express their frustration and criticism of a club they love so much, but their can be little doubt that they (more than any manager) have kept this club solvent. It staggers me that some want to forget all that and focus on a couple of spotty scallies who ran after Anthony Gordons car shouting nasty names.

You are also right to point to points deductions, a board which deserted the club and a complete madman who brought this club to the very edge of oblivian...But this thread is about Davey Moyes, He didnt have to endure any of that.

I honestly think some people support Davey Moyes more than they support the club. When he was refusing to play our youngsters last season despite the fact that we were sliding down the table with alarming speed. They were all over forums like this claiming they were not his players. That he had nothing to do with their signing Now they are all over them giving him credit for their form now he has been forced to play them...

Yes other managers have failed at the club over the last thirty years, but as pointed out, some of them had to overcome far bigger problems than Moyes ever faced. I think those using the last thirty years of failure in Moyes`s defence would do well to remember that...And the fact that he has had as many bites at the cherry as the rest of them put together.

41  Jimmy Salt
20/11/2026    08:52:40

Said What I was thinking better than I ever could Darren.

42  Paul Conway
20/11/2026    09:12:10

Darren Hind (40)

One of the most sensible nailed on assessments, that I have read over many Forums.

43  David Abrahams
20/11/2026    09:31:26

Bobby (32) I also would think it would remarkable if Moyes had evolved into a better manager than when he started off at present — unfortunately he hasn’t, too frightened to go into the deep end! It was truly remarkable that he won one away game against the top four teams in the league out of a possible 40 while being one of the the highest paid managers in Europe— not only remarkable but really unbelievable.
Those toxic fans you talk about founded KEITC saved us from going to Kirkby and included solicitors. doctors amongst many more solid Evertonians, Moyes, Cahill and Jagielka thought it would be a good move —- telling us on literature to vote for that move! You wouldn’t be one of them who agreed to this move Bobby ?

44  David Abrahams
20/11/2026    09:34:59

Sorry on that 2nd. line above @(43)should have read “ started off at Preston”

45  Raymond Fox
20/11/2026    09:41:21

The articles about Moyes always end up the same way, all you Moyes critics line up in support the same old criticisms of him.

While I agree with the opinion on some his faults, he has never had a squad that compares quality wise to the consistently successful clubs. They have all the advantages, he's never won anything which is hardly a surprise, is it, when your up against teams that cost many many times more.

Personally I don't care particularly one way or the other if he is dismissed at the end of the season, a change might be refreshing.

You have to admit though, that any manager of ours under the current conditions is pissing into the wind.

46  Kevin Molloy
20/11/2026    10:21:39

A look at our front six shows the clear progress that is being made. We all also know that he's not been given much money, and that he inherited a hospital pass of a club. the two key players Doucs and DCL leaving for nothing, remember that? And then people say, 'he was given money'. it took sixty million just to replace Doucs and DCL, just to get us back to that awful squad Dyche left. And after that, he's not been given ANY money. So to effect a change where we have such a talented front six from that horrible beginning, being happy with that is not happy clapping, or settling for mediocrity, it's acknowledging the job a skilled manager can do, even in the most trying of circumstances.

I mean, I've watched Ronald Koeman come in, rip a team up, and piss away hundreds of millions. And sleep like a baby. As things stand currently we have a manager who has a gehuine connection with the club. and who is performing very well. Is he going to win us the league?no. If Real Madrid came in for him, would he tell them to bog off? Again, no..

I couldn't care less, I can see progress on the pitch in very trying circumstances. That will do me for the present.

47  Bobby Thomas
20/11/2026    10:35:23

Some genuinely funny comments here from some of the usual suspects.

"WITHDRAW!"

Good grief.

I'll keep on enjoying the club making positive strides, thanks.

Some of the perpetually incandescent members of this place frankly need to get a grip, as some of the jaundiced stuff they come out with is genuinely odd.

48  Christine Foster
20/11/2026    11:22:31

Slight diversion I know but Colin Chong has apparently been terminated from his role within the club without any announcement from the club 11 days ago. No reason given but I suspect it's tied to TFG divesting all its interests including the regeneration of surrounding area and real estate, after that there is no role for him. Disrespectful not to acknowledge his efforts pre TFG and the stadium though, but just another indication they don't give a toss about the way things are done. Thank you Mr Chong, job well done.

49  Les Callan
20/11/2026    11:29:18

I was just about to post that Christine. Absolute appalling behaviour it seems towards a guy who was left holding the baby when the rats deserted the sinking ship. All that and he had the new stadium to deal with.

50  Harry Hockley
20/11/2026    12:41:36

Steve 37,

You’re right, it’s just nasty people spouting off vitriol looking for any excuse to be provocative, as you can probably see over various threads they stick together fiercely because it’s a satanic hive mind. Some can’t actually help it so I find compassion is a good wat to approach them.

God bless. :)

51  Antony Abrahams
20/11/2026    12:54:47

My advice would be to put yourself in that jaundiced bracket Bobby, if you want to cast the same aspersions to others.

52  Peter Hoban
20/11/2026    14:21:52

Re Colin Chong: it now appears he is still at the club and continuing with his existing role, he’s just no longer a board member.
As to the Moyes debate:-

My mates used to refer to me as the ‘voice of reason’ so that would mean I would more than likely be a Moyes supporter.

However, whilst he has done a good job since returning ( with the exception of the last seven games of last season) he will never lead us to any great heights.

I can live with that, that’s just the type of manager he is, so whilst he hasn’t been able to bring enough new faces through the door it has, so far, resulted in a decent start to the season with some of our younger talent getting quite a lot of game time.

I really want us to do well and to win a cup would be fantastic but aspiring to more than that in the short term, and possibly even the longer term, requires the club to move forward and whether it’s Moyes or someone else in the hot seat it’s going to be slow progress.

Every manager has his faults and it maybe that we highlight Moyes’s due to frustration with not being as successful a club as we would like but he’s never going to give us exciting football we just need to see where we are in January after the glut of December fixtures

53  John Fitzgerald
20/11/2026    14:28:10

Death, taxes, Evertonians arguing about David Moyes. I look forward to the day when it’s the football played on the pitch that’s the main topic of discussion about the club, not the manager, endlessly.

54  Steve Brown
20/11/2026    15:17:02

Darren @ 40, “I honestly think some people support Davey Moyes more than they support the club.”

I never thought about it like that Darren, but that is dead right. It is incomprehensible to me, but they would rather slag off their fellow fans than accept anything but plaudits for Moyes.

Insulting your fellow fans who have carried ths club on their shoulders over the last 5 years is lower than a snake’s belly. But I suppose that’s how some people roll.

55  Steve Brown
20/11/2026    15:19:03

Harry @ 50, so fans who disagree with your opinions are satanic?

Honestly.

56  Paul Conway
20/11/2026    17:06:29

Harry Hockley (50)

"And I will execute great vengeance upon them with furious rebukes; and they shall know that I am the Lord, when I shall lay my vengeance upon them

57  Jay Harris
20/11/2026    18:32:36

I don't know why we are just identifying Moyes as the reason for our failure to win a trophy in the last 40 years.

To win a trophy takes a lot of factors to achieve: - good players, a complementary team, good recruitment and development, good coaching (not just the manager), supporters 100% behind the club, players and manager, good owners and harmony in the boardroom and most of all a little luck.

If all theses factors and others come together as a synergistic whole then it leads to success.Just look at Brighton. Everton can only dream of being at their level right now and it isn't because of Moyes.

The support has been numbed by 40 years of mediocrity and underinvestment in the club.

The manager has never got the players or the squad he wants and we deserve because the owners past and present wee only interested in themselves. Where is the John Moores drive and spirit that drove the club to success previously.

Where is the champion who will challenge the hierarchy of the Premier league. Do we think Sir John would have stood by and watch this great club treated so shabbily by the likes of Masters and the PGMOL.

Moyes is only 1 pawn in the game. There are many other players who contribute to our success or failure.

58  Bobby Thomas
20/11/2026    19:10:26

David "Poirot" Abrahams #43

"Those toxic fans you talk about founded KEITC saved us from going to Kirkby and included solicitors. doctors amongst many more solid Evertonians, Moyes, Cahill and Jagielka thought it would be a good move —- telling us on literature to vote for that move! You wouldn’t be one of them who agreed to this move Bobby?"

Gah! You've blown my cover, David.

I was, am, and always will be a Kenwright man to the core of my being and wanted nothing more than to move to Kirkby.

I often thought of little else.

Particularly when I was attending every Blue Union meeting, occasionally contributing at said meetings, leafleting outside Goodison on match days, and participating in marches.

Yep, you've nailed it.

59  Robert Tressell
20/11/2026    19:42:07

It always descends into this.

Anthony: "As far as I’m concerned Robert, any supporter that says David Moyes, is a very good manager, is a person who is accepting mediocrity."

Why?

I don't accept mediocrity at all. I want only Champions League standard players at the club - and Champions League runs and trophies. I believe we can do it too - off the back of increased revenues, improved club management and proper investment in the playing squad. I can't see how that in any way accepts mediocrity.

I can, however, see that we currently have the 5th cheapest squad in the entire division (Ipswich have spent more to assemble their squad than we have), the smallest squad in the division and only two players of Champions League quality (Pickford and Branthwaite). This therefore comes with limitations that no manager will overcome. That's not accepting mediocrity - it is just plain obvious.

I can also see that Moyes inherited a similarly skint basket case when he first arrived and got us into the Champions League and regular European runs through astutely assembling a good squad and developing players on what would now be a Brentford-ish level budget (i.e. lots of £20m + players and a few £40m to £60m players).

At the moment, we don't have a Brentford level budget. They have spent £150m more than us in assembling their squad and are buying more expensive individual players too.

We will do - hopefully starting next summer. And then in the relative short term we should be in a position to outspend them and overtake. But we are probably many years off working our way back to the spending power to buy a Lukaku (£90 to £110m in today's market) or a Kanchelskis (£125 to £150m in today's market).

So to answer the point on whether we're at the level of, say, Crystal Palace - well sadly we are financially and in squad terms. Palace have spent all of £3m more than us on assembling their squad and are our closest match in the Premier League. The fact that we have a bigger crowd is largely meaningless at the moment - since that doesn't give us the spending power YET to have a better set of players (noting that Mitchell, Wharton, Sarr and Mateta at least would all almost certainly start for us).

Again, all pretty obvious.

Do I think Moyes is brilliant and a good fit for any club?

No. He shat his pants at Man Utd and even appeared to have a nervous breakdown that took him a long time to recover from.

Would I trust him with a big budget?

No, I think modern data driven recruitment has made his old approach completely obsolete.

I also think he has a track record of spending a bigger budget poorly and unimaginatively - just forking out a large sum on the standard of player he was previously buying on the cheap.

Would I trust him with a squad of Champions League standard players?

No.

It is plain as day that he's unable to organise front-foot attacking football (e.g. opening up passing lanes through rehearsed positioning) anything like as well as he can organise more defensive negative football.

I also think it's plain as day he lacks the self-belief and charisma to manage players like Bellingham in this era - or the likes of Ferdinand in years gone by.

But sadly that is by the by because we don't have Champions League standard players with big egos and huge self belief.

Personally, I hope this season is his last with us because I want this coming summer to be the beginning of our transformation into Champions League club. But much of that will come down to the kitty. If we remain poor then sadly Moyes remains a painful but sensible appointment.

61  David Abrahams
20/11/2026    20:17:48

Bobby (58) I might have stood next to you at some of those Blue Union meetings outside the ground or in The Casa in Hope St. — did you find any of those other fans at those meetings toxic?

62  Philip Sheehan
20/11/2026    20:18:57

bloody'ell its getting like the bible belt on this post !
harry @ 50 evertonians have just as much of a right to criticise DM as you have to praise him. the epl has changed since moyes's 1st spell and not for the better.FFP & now SCR make it nearly impossible to challenge - monday's game is a real tester for how and if we are progressing and next week well on paper liverpool should roll us over, they have 3 players who cost over 100m (ok 2 of them only look like 10m players ! ) our record signing that icelandic guy for 45m. but the games not played on paper so davey lets have a good go at them if we do and fail we can forgive as long as we try and the players give it 100%
just get the right mixture of compressing the play in midfield, don't defend too deep and as they play a high back line hit em on the break..
darren @ 40 has hit the nail on the proverbial, when I call out moyes for his non use of subs or team selection I don.t want a trumpian response or if I predict our league position to be 12th to 15th its not negative its realistic.yes darren some seem to be moyes fans more than everton fans I called someone more of a friedkin fan than an evertonian as he tried to justify TFG selling up as dan needed the dosh for his other 'projects' yep I can hear it now " stop moaning we are 6th and in the quarter finals " yes thats true but if we finish in the top 6 I will bare my arse in lewis.s window
(old scouse saying)

63  Darren Hind
20/11/2026    20:58:20

Fuck me theyre still at it.

Seeing as TFG have no interest in Everton. Perhaps they may be interested in contacting the owners of Palace with a view to doing a straight swap ? You know with them being a London club like ?

Of course they wouldnt. Despite the toe curling claims that we are on the same level as Palace, it would take a rare level of stupidity to enter such a transaction.

Palace and their merry little band of followers (not enough to fill their pokey little ground) will be back where they belong next year. This poxy little club has only ever been able to defy gravity for brief periods.

On one hand they tell us they don't accept mediocrity. On the other, they tell us we have no right to expect to be achieving more than Crystal fucking Palace.....

64  Robert Tressell
20/11/2026    21:14:14

I think it’s fair to say that some of us have a bigger club aspiration for Everton than poor plucky underdogs trying to pretend to compete.

65  Antony Abrahams
20/11/2026    21:27:13

Regular European runs, is when I stopped reading your post Robert.

I really enjoyed one season playing in Europe until that fateful night in Fiorentina, when I witnessed a very cagey Everton performance, from a team that didn’t quite know how to stick or twist, but not even one quarter final was ever reached in those regular European cup runs.

I then carried on and agreed with a lot of what you said about Moyes, Robert. A decent manager is my opinion of David, but until we get much better than decent owners, then like you say, i think everything else is pretty much immaterial.

66  John Fitzgerald
20/11/2026    22:45:18

This “they love David Moyes more than Everton” line is on the same level as saying that “they (anti-Moyes crowd) want us to lose games so they can they can do their “told you he was shit” schtick”. Both are childish bollocks. I go to plenty of away games and every game, win,lose or draw, they sing Moyes’s name and reciprocate his applause. Try telling away fans that’s them accepting mediocrity and see where it gets you.
Why does it always have to get this divisive? I love Everton, but fucking hell there are more important things out there to get pissy about.
We should be talking about line-ups against Brentford, not the same entrenched alehouse gibberish about David Fucking Moyes.

67  Bobby Thomas
21/11/2026    00:34:34

David #61

I hadn't mentioned KEIOC or Kirkby at any point before you began telling me that is what I was referring to - which I wasn't.

68  Darren Hind
21/11/2026    08:38:34

"We should be taking about line ups against Brentford not some entrenched alehouse gibberish about Davey fucking Moyes"

Breaking news. The manager who isn't endlessly discussed by the fans of his club has yet to be born. The advent of social media has meant that discussions and arguments which were once confined to the alehouses have gotten even endless...er. They act as fillers between games - Especially during international breaks. With three days to go, nobody knows who will be fit and available for the Brentford game. That conversation will have to remain on the back burner. These managerial discussions/arguments are not compulsory. You don't have to take part. Coming on and bleating about the fact that they are taking place is like going across the road to tell your neighbour you don't like the TV programe he is watching.

I know many of Davey Moyes's supporters think he is persecuted, but the reality is, compared to many other managers he gets away with fucking murder. Arsene Wenger came in for far greater criticism and created far more division and he was one of the greatest managers who ever lived.

I think the suggestion that Evertonians want Everton to lose is probably the most idiotic argument I have ever heard. The notion that people who invest so much time,effort,cash,emotion...Their entire being would want to trade a win for a meaningless I-told-you-so to people they will never meet is laughable.

Moyes has a disgraceful record at the grounds of the top six. I was there for nearly all of those games and I have witnessed the anger, frustration and misery of thousands who have had their weekends ruined leaving those ground in silence and then complaining about his tactics and cowardice all the way home. Those fans were not accepting mediocrity. Nor were they happy clapping it. They were enduring it. Try telling them otherwise.

Ive also been there against lesser teams when Moyes`s name was chanted at the end of a victory, often by the very same people who were critical of him the week before. That`s how it works. Footy fans are essentially uncomplicated. Give them what they want and have paid through the nose for (or at least try to) and they will show their appreciation. Go into matches without any intention of winning it and you will deserve all the criticism that comes your way.

69  Antony Abrahams
21/11/2026    10:11:01

Dave, mentioned KEIOC, because they were considered toxic by certain sections of the fan base Bobby, which is something you would have already known after putting in so much good work for an organisation which helped save the long term future of Everton Football Club, imo.

He told you about people you already knew about. Good people who love Everton Football club, were actually considered toxic, because of the lies perpetrated by Mr Kenwright.

You referred to fans chasing Anthony Gordon, down the street, my own view is that if a man from South America, can get out of his car and speak to a few young frustrated kids, why couldn’t the kid from Walton?

It was a horrible day, the toxicity was started by the stay away, dirty, cynical, lying members of the Everton Boardroom, and when Gordon, left Everton not long after, he was just another young scouser, who was vilified by the fans once again because of the cynical lies constructed by the greatest “player” never to play for Everton.

Remember Ian Wright, a man who had a great rapport with and was always respected in return by most Evertonians, coming out with a lot of misinformed lies and backtracking when he was made aware that it wasn’t quite true?

Toxicity has ran through Everton for years and things like this always start at the very top, imo mate.

70  John Fitzgerald
21/11/2026    10:14:34

Nothing wrong with healthy debate. But when it degenerates into the same tedious barbs repeated over and over again regarding Moyes, it’s flat-out tedious. Personally, I come here to glean knowledge and insight from a couple of regular contributors, not to witness ToffeeWeb Mk. 2. I actually don’t think there’s this massive divergence of opinion about Moyes in the eyes of most Evertonians, it’s social media that creates the division - it’s the constant, entrenched side-taking which just ends up getting needlessly personal which is grating.

71  David Abrahams
21/11/2026    10:15:24

Bobby (67) That’s fair enough but you did mention toxic fans and I was pointing out that some of those possible toxic fans saved Everton from going to Kirkby while being members of
KEIOC and we all are allowed different opinions without being called toxic.

72  Antony Abrahams
21/11/2026    10:28:55

Funny John F, because I was having a discussion with my oldest lad the other day and he was telling me all his mates, call him a moaning bastard, because he hates David Moyes. Do you know what though dad, not one of them has got the answers when I start dissecting Moyes, especially when I tell them all that they’re stupid bastards, who are just accepting mediocrity.

He goes everywhere, has that same argument everywhere, and the conversation only came about because he was telling me has never felt so disillusioned with Everton. He was telling me all his little gang, got tickets out the ballot for Fleetwood, so let’s hope they have a great night (because winning a cup game should always be more important than winning a league game, for a club like Everton, who have got no chance of winning the league - what about gaining enough points to stave off relegation though🙈) beat Man City, in the semifinal, and Moyes, can become the true Moysiah, when we beat Liverpool in the final🤞

It can be done, I had a great day a few weeks ago watching my stepson playing for Hibernian, who finally beat Hearts, in a big game at Hampden Park, and although witnessing the Hibs fans singing “sunshine on leith” at the end was magical, it’ll be nothing like the explosion Wembley Stadium would see, if our dream became a reality, singing “WE SHALL NOT BE MOVED” one day fucking one day….. it’s got to fuckin happen one day🤞💙

Just read your next post John F, after posting this and my thoughts when I finished writing were poor Lyndon, probably doesn’t want another Toffeeweb. Only Lyndon can answer that!

73  Darren Hind
21/11/2026    10:59:35

John

The article is about Moyes. The thread is inevitably going to be about Moyes.

We all know how it goes, so anybody coming on here to use rhetoric like "Childish bollocks" to describe a lot of peoples opinion, or dismiss their point as "entrenched alehouse gibberish" is simply joining the virtual affray. They may claim it is tedious, but they were unable to walk on by.

I agree with your basic point. By now we all know whats is going to be said and we have a very good idea of who is going to say it.

I'll make a little deal with you. You submit an article that has nothing to do with Davey Moyes and I will do the same. That way we are both being pro-active in steering the conversation somewhere else. Just be aware that if mine's crap. I will definitely blame you

74  John Fitzgerald
21/11/2026    11:03:36

Your stepson plays for the Hibs? That’s cool. Sunshine On Leith is the best football anthem anywhere.
And I reckon we’ll win at Anfield next Sunday. There, I’ve said it.

75  Steve Brown
21/11/2026    11:19:14

John, we’re playing at Hill Dickinson next Sunday.

Don’t want you to turn up at the wrong stadium!

76  John Fitzgerald
21/11/2026    11:41:34

Ah fuck, of course. Not so sure of that win anymore.
Anyone got a spare ticket? I can make myself available for alehouse gibberish afterwards.
I can do that, Darren. I’m promoting ChatGBT now for 1000 words of “childish bollocks”. That’s a joke, btw. At my expense.

77  Steve Brown
21/11/2026    12:01:10

We’ll win John, 2-0.

78  Bobby Thomas
21/11/2026    18:13:34

David #71

To clarify, uppermost in my mind when I used the word toxic were match going fans who start completely losing their shit and creating a negative atmosphere at the first hint of things not going well, as was very much the case against Newcastle in the cup recently, and those who persistently talk the club down and push a negative narrative when things are in fact going pretty well.

79  David Abrahams
21/11/2026    20:01:06

Bobby I think it is wise to see how the game is going before you start going overboard one way or the other, a game can change in a second with a brilliant goal or a very bad mistake, we ‘ve all seen games we have deserved to win but lost and I’d describe the game that way and visa versa when we’ve won games that the opposition were much better and should have.

This season I haven’t been impressed much at all even though we are in 6th. position and got most of our points from teams in the lower half of the league when I think we should have had more, we have had our share of good and bad VAR decisions.

We have a small squad so that makes a big difference but I think more players could have been utilised a lot more often than they have been and you might agree that it is a 16 man game now in a 95 minute + match.

80  Antony Abrahams
21/11/2026    20:33:47

When TSF, sell Everton, I’d personally love to see a root and branch clear out, in so many different departments, all the way across our club, Bobby.

There are so many Evertonians, working inside finch farm, and when we lose it feels like they’re trying to snarl at us, was something I was once told by Sean Dyche.

The starting team was also getting out early every week, and Dyche, said he didn’t really have an alternative (and because there were that many Evertonians inside finch farm, then it wouldn’t be easy to set a trap) because if he didn’t practice set-pieces and the team conceded a goal from a set-piece, then it wouldn’t be very professional.

These people must have very high opinions of themselves because they’re employed by Everton, but an even bigger gripe is how people within the club carried on after we beat United at Old Trafford, last season.

The club actually issued a statement saying how they would like to thank the fans for sticking with them through the dark days, which is something I personally found a lot more toxic, than anything I’ve ever heard coming from the mouth of any supporter in the fifty two years I’ve attended Everton games.

Acceptable losses, was something that was uttered under Moshiri. Moyes, joking with Haaland, after he scored two against us last season, showed me that the manager must also think that losing to Manchester City, is completely acceptable.

I want owners and a manager, who are absolutely desperate to win, and until we get those type of people, then I’m not really convinced that things are going pretty well, especially when the next visitors to Bramley Moore, start singing that piss taking song, that keeps going up another digit, every fucking year.


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.