EVERTON MATCHDAY
Issue #3: Floating on Air, Branthwaite Brilliance and Manuel Fernandes
It’s been a rough week for Evertonians but the team fought hard to rescue a point against Manchester United on Sunday.
This is Issue #3 of Everton Matchday, and here are my takeaways from the Toffees’ 2-2 draw at Hill Dickinson Stadium.
Never Leave Early
I never left a game early for years. Never. Sometimes, I’d be the only one left on my row in the Gwladys Street as the opposition knocked it around in the dying embers of an embarrassing defeat. In recent seasons, however, amid all of the off-field daftness, I’ve not been as committed to the principle of hanging around until the bitter end.
On Sunday, and with 94 minutes on the clock, I decided to make my way to the exits knowing I’d still the see the final kick of the game due to how long it takes to venture down the steps of the South Stand.
Shuffling out of Row 24, I got into the aisle and it was gridlocked as hundreds of us stood, transfixed on the final moments of the game, hoping and urging for an equaliser that really didn’t look like it was going to come. Progress was slow as Blues lingered at the bottom, holding off from actually leaving, just in case.
The Toffees went forward but the play fizzled away and it looked like that was that. As more supporters wandered out, I was able to take another few steps and was now on the aisle of Row 18 when the ball broke to Ainsley Maitland-Niles a couple of yards from the edge of the area.
As I hovered on the steps, you just knew where the ball was going the moment it left his boot. With nothing to hold on to but surrounded by other South Stand regulars, time stood still as everyone leant forward on their tip-toes and watched with bated breath.
The shot seemed to fly in slow motion and I sensed myself bracing. All I could think was ‘Where the hell am I going to end up here?!’
Whizzing through the air, the ball then smacked the net. Two-two! The place erupted and it felt like I was floating on air, carried by the pandemonium of the South Stand. The aisle roared in seismic unison and clenched fists appeared out from the melee. Pure Evertonian ecstasy.
I’ll never forget that.
The last time I had such a perfect view of the ball hitting the top corner like that was in the away end down at Upton Park in 2013 as Leighton Baines scored two-free kicks in a 3-2 victory over West Ham. Glorious.
Only Everton…
We’ve waited years for a new right-back to simply come in, stop crosses and get up and down the wing. That was the requirement.
And on Sunday, he’s smacked one in the top corner in the 96th minute.
To think, Maitland-Niles might not have made it on the pitch if Garner hadn’t gone down.
The Carlisle Kaiser
Branthwaite was brilliant yet again today and it’s little wonder he was compared to Franz Beckenbauer back in his hometown of Wigton. He is absolutely flawless.
The defender made a perfectly-timed tackle just before half-time and let out a roar of celebration before raising his fist to the South Stand. It was majestic.
He’s one of the best players I’ve seen in an Everton shirt, up there with Wayne Rooney and John Stones. Branthwaite’s reading of the game is impeccable.
Hopefully his career is trophy-laden with Everton. If that’s not to be, surely when the time comes to hang his boots up he’ll have played for Real Madrid. He’s a class act.
By George, I Think he’s Got it
I really enjoy watching Tyrique George. The way he slaloms past the opposition is a sight to behold. He’s so skilful but plays with such purpose too.
Wide players can often be the most frustrating as so often they will be tasked with playing the final ball or requiring risky tricks to get the better of a defender. Not George though.
Every time he gets the ball, his aim is to get Everton forward and make something happen in attacking areas. There is a real efficiency to George’s play and he’ll grow into an even greater threat as he gains more experience.
The way his goal struck the top corner took me back to Manuel Fernandes’ finish against United back in 2007. Phwoar. See also: Tomasz Radzinski vs Southampton in 2003.
Armstrong Boasts that Nasty
Fans love to hate the pantomime villain, but when it comes to Bruno Fernandes, his antics on the pitch create real irritation in the stands.
So, when young Harrison Armstrong grappled the United midfielder around the neck and hauled him to the ground in the first-half, it raised a cheer and a few pats of the chest.
While it was ill-advised and not the most sensible thing to do, Armstrong is clearly fearless and far from intimidated by anyone on the pitch. Later I saw him chatting back to another United player, completely unfazed. He plays with a real authority.
Helpful Hackney
Hayden Hackney looks like he’s going to be a brilliant signing for Everton. The best player in the Championship last season moved the ball so well in today’s cameo, making important and incisive passes which helped the Blues move smartly into the final third. Loads to come from Hackney judging by his first appearances for the club.
Different Rohl
Merlin Rohl isn’t a right-back. He’s an excellent footballer but not a right-back. Again on Sunday, he was caught out of position a few times and easily beaten by Marcus Rashford. Hopefully David Moyes starts playing a right-back at right-back so that the German doesn’t have to endure a torrid time of it in defence.
I actually see Rohl being the man who gets the nod to start up front in the absence of Thierno Barry. Brennan Johnson is the obvious choice and George has been tipped to play there too if required but I think Moyes will see Rohl’s attributes as suiting a sort of false nine role.
It’s the same vibe as when Marouane Fellaini and Tim Cahill were deployed as the sole central attacker. The former Freiburg man isn’t like those two in his playing style but I think he is someone who would pop up with important goals and boost the frontline with his presence.
Rohl won’t play with his back to goal but he is rapid and direct on the counter attack. I’d be surprised if he isn’t deployed up front at some point should Barry be unavailable between now and January.
Transfer Failures: Questions Still Need Answers
CEO Angus Kinnear appeared on the big screen at full-time, clapping the players off with his raised hands in the air. It was only for a second before it cut off and an Everton graphic appeared.
While the performance and last-minute equaliser meant everyone was buoyed leaving the Hill Dickinson Stadium, questions still need answering about Deadline Day and the Transfer Window as a whole. Fans need to see some accountability.
You would hope there will be communication this week addressing what went wrong. Medicals don’t always go to plan and so I personally have no issue with Folarin Balogun not signing. However, allowing a striker to go with no replacement through the door? That was woeful.
Trust has been eroded after this last week and fans lack faith in the ownership and overall setup. Radio silence won’t do.
Yet again it’s ‘backs to the wall’ and ‘hoping for the best’ with some discourse online suggesting everyone should now just ‘get behind the team’. 50,000 did, fervently, on Sunday, but questions still need answering. Responsibility needs to be taken for a shambles of a window which has left us depleted and up against it for a good while yet.
Big respect to the players today.
Is there any more annoying sentence than “just get behind the team”, as if we haven’t been doing that our whole lives.
— Han's Tours (@Hanstours) September 2, 2026