This Monday, David Moyes will be feted as the man to have managed Everton for more competitive fixtures than anyone else who has occupied the Blues’ hotseat. At the pre-match press conference before the trip to Brentford, James Tarkowski and Leon Osman presented the incumbent with a framed photo collage to mark him passing Harry Catterick’s total of 592. It is certainly a remarkable achievement, particularly in the febrile world of modern football, where the life expectancy in post is generally measured by months rather than years. There is a ‘but’, however.

After nearly three dismal seasons for Everton, on the back of the glory of 1969/70, it was announced on the afternoon of 11 April 1973 that the club were moving Harry Catterick away from his role as manager and into a (poorly defined) executive role. The reason for Harry staying at the club was down to John Moores honouring the time Harry had left on his lengthy contract. It was a rare example of sentimentality from the Littlewoods empire supremo, but he held the Toffees’ manager since 1961 in high esteem.

Over the years, it has become ‘gospel’ that this date, 11 April, spelled the end of Harry’s time as Everton manager. Yet, with no replacement manager in post, Harry, assisted by his deputy Tom Eggleston, was asked to oversee first team affairs until a new man was appointed and sat in the dugout. Accordingly, Harry and Tom travelled to The Hawthorns for the heavy away defeat to West Brom.

As it transpired, it would be the summer before Billy Bingham was offered and agreed terms, after a failed pursuit of Don Revie. Therefore, after the defeat to the Baggies, the Catterick-Eggleston combo oversaw the remaining five matches of the 1972/73 season, culminating in a tame 3-1 defeat at the Baseball Ground. It had been a dismal run, with only one win. The Daily Post report of the Derby County match makes it clear that it viewed this as the definitive end of Harry’s time as manager — meaning he had signed off on 598, not 592, matches in charge.

Harry would remain at the club, very much in the background, in something akin to a highly-paid scouting role, until the urge to manage again became too strong and he took the reins at Deepdale in 1975.

So, depending on how you interpret the events of April 1973, the celebrations for David Moyes could be seen as premature. If we count the matches at the end of the 1972/73 season as being under Harry’s stewardship, it will be on 20 December at the City Ground, when the Scot can officially be crowned as the Toffees manager with the most matches under his belt.

Read More

Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Jeff Armstrong
22/11/2026    16:15:52

I am sure if Catterick was in the dugout for the last 6 games of the season, he would’ve been picking the team, granted, he hadn’t been taking training for a long period before he officially lost the manager title, but he was in charge for those last few games, who else was picking the team, making the sub etc
So Davey needs to wait a few games before hanging up his picture.

2  Harry Hockley
22/11/2026    17:30:34

Let’s just concentrate on the here and now, there’s a man that just made Everton history and what do we do? Crucify, vilify and chastise him.
A man who is Everton, a man who is steadfast, fervent and devoted.

His name is David William Moyes. Thank you and god bless you.

3  Paul Conway
22/11/2026    18:16:06

Whichever way you want to Pump up Moyes Everton Career, he still has only a 41.72% win rate, Compared to Harry Cattericks 46.5%.

But hey!.. it’s Davy Lad, who loves us and gets us and for some he’s the “ Moyesiah!”

But, please take the blinkers of and remind yourselves that During his career with Us, he won Sweet Diddly Squat, compared to our Arry!

So, all that considered, there is absolutely no comparison between the two.


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.