If some had been wondering when the James Garner of last season was going to re-emerge or where, apart from Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall and Thierno Barry, Everton’s goals were going to come from this season, they got some answers on an evening that emphatically lifted the gloom that had set in following dismal defeats to Chelsea and Arsenal.

This was an often frenetic and occasionally testy bout between two teams who have both made an erratic start to their respective Premier League campaigns but the Blues landed the crucial blows and ran out comfortable winners, with Dan Burn’s 88th-minute header the only consolation for Newcastle United.

Everton were 3–0 up and coasting by that point thanks to first-half goals from Garner and Hayden Hackney and an expertly-finished third from Barry midway through the second period as David Moyes’s men gave the Bramley-Moore Dock crowd something to cheer with clear passage to the League Cup quarter-finals and a date with Fleetwood Town.

As expected, the manager rang a couple changes to the team that had started at the Emirates Stadium last Saturday, with Harrison Armstrong given a rest until the second half and Hackney handed his first start since the win over Wolves in the previous round.

Likewise Tyler Dibling who lined up wide on the right in front of Merlin Röhl and on the opposite flank to Tyrique George who kept his place with Jack Grealish absent from the team sheet, reportedly due to disciplinary action.

After putting together a nice move very early on where Dewsbury-Hall saw a shot deflected behind for a corner, Everton’s general start to this tie was a little ragged and Jordan Pickford was called into action three times inside the first 20 minutes to repel a Harvey Barnes header from Nico Gonzalez’s dangerous cross and shots by Joe Willock and Fabian Schär as the Magpies tried to draw first blood.

Having weathered the opening, though, the Toffeemen found their feet and carved out their first opening in the 20th minute when Vitalii Mykolenko swung a ball in towards the near post but Hackney couldn’t get enough purchase on his shot to steer it inside the upright.

Dibling, who was industrious but not as remarkable when compared with his stellar outing in the last round, then screwed a left-footed effort wide while, at the other end, James Tarkowski put in an excellent block to deny William Osula.

11 minutes before half-time, however, the hosts made the breakthrough. George chased Amar Dedić into the corner and benefitted when the Bosnia international’s attempted clearance struck his leg and bounced to Hackney. He slipped it neatly inside to Garner who swept it on the stretch across Lukáš Horníček and into the far corner of the goal to make it 1–0.

It was the midfielder’s first goal since his penalty in the FA Cup against Sunderland in January and it set the seal on what was a vastly improved overall performance from him.

Back in front of the North Stand, Barnes lashed a loose ball wide when he might have done better and a mistake in midfield from Röhl let the visitors in but Barnes’s shot was deflected into the arms of a grateful Pickford.

From the ensuing counter-attack, Everton doubled their lead. Driving forward from midfield, Dewsbury-Hall, another player enjoying a welcome return to his best form, was chopped down in full flight by Jacob Ramsey but referee Farai Hallam sensibly played the advantage as Barry shimmied the loose ball past the retreating Lewis Hall and out to the far side of the box.

Turning back, he spotted the run of Hackney, curled a pin-point cross to the edge of the six-yard box and the former Middlesbrough man made no mistake with a cushioned volley that he guided home past the stranded keeper.

Matthias Jaissle made a triple change at the break in an effort to rescue the tie, throwing Yoane Wissa, Joelinton and Anthony Elanga on in place of Ramsey, Barnes and Osula and the Magpies would have the first two chances of the second half without making a dent in the scoreline.

Wissa ghosted in behind Jake O’Brien but couldn’t put enough on a header to loft it over Pickford while a long-range Dedić strike took a wicked deflection off Hackney and looped over for a corner that Burn could only plant into the stand behind the goal.

With Hackney having been withdrawn in favour of Armstrong after picking up a booking, the Blues put the result practically beyond doubt with their third of the night. Garner stepped in smartly to intercept Dedić’s infield ball and sent Dewsbury-Hall away with a nice reverse pass.

The latter powered to the left edge of the Newcastle box before squaring it to Barry who held up his run to receive the pass, set himself with a touch and then calmly place the ball between Horníček and his near post. It was a consummate striker’s finish that belied the Frenchman’s gangly and occasionally awkward style. It also took his tally to seven in all competitions for the season.

Newcastle would finish the match having had 28 shots, only nine of which were on target, an indication of how open the game was at times. However, though Pickford was the busier goalkeeper in terms of saves he had to make, on the whole he wasn’t unduly troubled.

His save from Hall’s low drive in the 71st minute was routine, he bailed Mykolenko out by denying Willock while O’Brien got in the way of Joelinton’s goal-bound missile from the rebound, and then dealt with Elanga’s late chance before his clean sheet was muddied by a late Newcastle goal.

Willock did well to float a cross in from the Barcodes’ left where Burn rose completely uncontested by the static O’Brien to simply nod home from a yard or so out. An irritating blemish on an otherwise stirring evening of cup football that sparked a melée in the goalmouth as Burn tried to grab the ball to quickly restart the game resulting in two players from each side being booked.

While it was loose and a bit porous at times, this was a markedly better performance from Everton than the two that preceded it in the Premier League and that sort of energy, drive and purpose must be the template moving forward, starting on Monday when these two sides meet again, this time at St James’s Park.

Whether Hackney, the most exciting performer on the night, has done enough to convince the manager that he deserves to start remains to be seen but he will definitely have given Moyes more food for thought.

Beyond that lies that Quarter-Final matchup at Highbury where another professional display against League Two Fleetwood would see the Toffees into a first cup semi-final since 2016. 

Read More


Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Jack Convery
29/10/2026    21:40:16

Well done Blues. Amazing what happens when you give youth a chance. Think on Moyesiah.

2  Antony Abrahams
29/10/2026    22:09:33

Energy engages the crowd and the crowd looked very happy tonight 💙

3  Robert Tressell
29/10/2026    22:14:41

Very pleased to be wrong about the team selection. Front foot approach tonight and it paid off. Best performance of the season probably with Hackney looking like a really excellent signing.

4  Paul Conway
29/10/2026    22:33:09

Incredible contribution from Barry.

Both, his assist and goal were delivered with identical aplomb.

The control and delivery, in real time was rapid and skilful.

I think He still has a lot to offer, to this Team.

5  Philip Sheehan
29/10/2026    22:54:01

Well, what a turn around after Saturday. I thought HH did more in 65 minutes than Johnson had in his last 3 games... Barry, KDH, Garner excellent but Myko for me was our best player.

Surely HH must be a starter every game? BYW, officer Dibling was poor. Nothing seemed to work for him...

6  Peter Mills
29/10/2026    23:15:42

A good evening at HDS, very pleasant to win a cup tie in a relatively straightforward manner.

I agree with the shouts for KDH and Mykolenko, Hackney’s touch was off at times, but he was always positive and will get up to speed if he is given opportunities.

Dibling was a bit frustrating, but he is showing signs of better discipline, there is a player in him.

Barry was his enigmatic self - awful, but then showing great awareness to set up Hackney, and pulled back nicely to score his goal.

I enjoyed the VAR-free match.

7  Mike Owen
30/10/2026    00:14:49

This result is a mood-changer.

Perhaps rode our luck a bit in the first 15 or 20 mins, but overall an encouraging performance.

Just goes to show it's all about getting the ball in the net (and not having it disallowed). All goals were very good finishes.

We're on our way to Fleetwood, We shall not be moved.

8  Paul Hughes
30/10/2026    00:21:01

I thought Dibling had a decent game, by and large he used the ball well, and did his defensive duties diligently. He showed a brief display of his ability,at one point, leaving the England left back on his arse, as he skipped past him.

9  Peter Hoban
29/10/2026    00:32:42

Glad to see Hackney (played okay I thought without being any great shakes but I like the way he drives the team forward), Dibling (didn’t do a huge amount but a much different player than last season, just needs more game time), and George (didn’t okay) all start.

Got to disagree with you somewhat Paul (4), Barry did take his goal well and his pass to Hackney was excellent but in every other department he is shocking.
He never puts the centre half under any pressure, rarely gets his head on the ball, is always on his heels when the ball breaks loose and most times he cannot control the ball.

Mykolenko was excellent but KDH was my man of the match.

It was lovely to score and be able to celebrate with no VAR.
It’s the way forward!

10  Nicolas Piñon
30/10/2026    01:29:47

Good win without brainthwait and with O’Brien in his position finally. Clear Upgrade on keane.
Hackney has to play more. As well as George and dibling.
KDH MotM.

11  Mike Gaynes
30/10/2026    01:52:23

Hackney's aggression was a joy to see, and his attacking instincts were on full display -- a perfectly weighted one-touch lead pass for Garner to slot away, and two superbly-timed runs into the box for the crosses from Myko and Barry, the second of which he converted. I trust we will now see more of him.

I always enjoy the "mixed" comments on Barry -- how awful he is at this or that, followed by the grudging respect for the goal and the assist. But to me a striker's primary job is goals, and Barry now has nine goal involvements in just over 900 minutes of play, more than his total from all of last season. His improvement is obvious -- his conversion rate is better (if still far from perfect) and his passing, running off the ball and work rate are exponentially improved. He clearly has been putting in the extra hours, and it shows. Sneer at his ungainliness if you will, but a continuation of his upward curve is going to produce a very effective player down the road.

12  Steve Brown
30/10/2026    02:34:01

David Moyes plays talented young players, sets up the team with positive intent, and we win handsomly.

Hackney was very good, George turned in a better performance than Grealish has managed recently, and Dibling played better than Johnston has managed in any game since he signed.

Good performance, right selection, same team again in the away fixture.

13  Jerome Shields
30/10/2026    03:36:33

I missed the game, playing my Uku.Glad of the result Could it be that Moyes is thinking of a Cup run?I was nervous of this game,since it was one of those progress games.A hurdle Moyes can have difficulty with.

Fleetwood will find it difficult against Moyes '# Everton unaccommodating style.

14  Paul Conway
30/10/2026    06:11:10

Mike Gaynes (11)

As a long suffering Evertonian, since 1968, and not being an expert on all things Football, like yourself, eating Humble Pie, or Crow, as you would call it, can be quite a pleasant experience…
especially, when hugely beneficial to your Team.

I myself, have been very critical of Barry and quite frankly, it never crossed my mind that I would ever write that last sentence, in my post above.

But, you knew that all along, that Barry would come good.

It’s also very Satisfying, to have a resident ToffeeWeb expert grace these pages, to become the new pseudo - expert of Evertonia.

15  Frank Sheppard
30/10/2026    07:47:07

Very welcome win, a real mood changer.

16  Antony Abrahams
30/10/2026    07:51:03

Your post has got me thinking about David Moyes, Paul C, because if there is one person in the world who I would love to have to eat humble-pie over, then he his hopefully going to be that person.🤞

17  Jeff Armstrong
30/10/2026    08:49:40

Good win, great night out, no VAR, same 11 on Monday please Mr Moyes, don’t change a winning team, fans will back you.

Simples

18  Paul Conway
30/10/2026    09:01:41

Anthony (16)

I would gladly share that experience with you, as I too have been ultra critical of him.

There’s nothing with being proved wrong … in our case, it’s a win win situation !

19  John Raftery
30/10/2026    09:14:47

Goals change games. This was a very welcome victory if not a wholly convincing performance. The first half was a game of two halves with Newcastle on top in the opening stages and our team struggling, nervously, to live with them. Credit goes to the players for sticking with it and giving themselves a chance to compete.

Hackney was not the only player looking ill at ease in the early minutes but he was the one on the end of Pickford’s wrath after he allowed Schär far too much space for his shot on goal. Tarkowski did well, as captain, to intervene. Hayden subsequently grew into the game, looking far more effective in the opposition half than he did in his own. His quick, simple pass to Garner for the first goal gave the scorer the space and the angle to despatch a superb finish. Hackney’s goal also looked simple but was a reward for making the late run into the box, something we have seen too rarely from our players. Enormous credit must be given also to Barry for the perfect cross.

Hackney’s contribution perhaps encapsulated the dilemma faced by our manager in his overall team selection. Last season’s Championship Player of the Season most certainly plays with skill and ambition going forward. The downside risk concerns his lack of experience and positional awareness when the team requires a defensive shape. With more experience, he should be able to learn those fundamentals of any Moyes team.

Likewise Röhl, Dibling, George and Armstrong are at an early stage in their development as Premier League players. Even Barry and O’Brien still have much to learn at this level. Given the lack of viable options Moyes must hope regular selection will accelerate their progress individually and collectively. To quote a phrase used by the club in promotional material around 1967/68, they could be part of the ‘team of the future’!

In the meantime we remain heavily dependent on Dewsbury-Hall and Garner. Only when those two were in possession could we feel really confident we would retain it.

Like Peter Mills and others I thoroughly enjoyed a VAR-free match. That also could be a thing of the future.

20  Peter Fancy
30/10/2026    09:20:50

Finally! Has the penny dropped now Moyes or was your hand forced and you will revert to type as soon as possible? Only time will tell I guess…

Special mention for Tarkowski who was immense yet again. He has been a beast this season. Can’t wait for a certain person who cannot wait to jump over any mention of Tarkowski to tell me why I am wrong despite all visual and statistical evidence, and that he is the worst defender ever to play the game…

21  Antony Abrahams
30/10/2026    09:30:56

I think it is always worth reading any post from John Raftery, even when I don’t agree with everything he says!

Hackney, is ready imo John, take away the caution and he his ready.

Seriously I think every single player in our very small squad is ready. Some might be better than others, but it could be argued that others simply don’t get enough chances to prove themselves?

That’s my only real gripe and until (rather than unless- hopefully) the manager starts believing in his overall squad a lot more, then it always will be

22  Warney Creswell
30/10/2026    09:34:39

Spot on, John Raftery.

23  Darren Hind
30/10/2026    10:19:05

Barry will continue to draw mixed responses until he can improve on his one goal in every four EPL games. He will only do that if he stops missing open goals and starts bullying EPL defenders. Never a footballer as we can all see. He has to make up for his lack of grace and skill with power and desire. He doesnt do this nearly enough. The sight of him being rag-dolled by stronger defenders has become an almost weekly one.

He's having a good cup though. Took his goal really well and put very good ball into the danger area last night (Hackney must have ran 50 yards to get on the ened of it. great work from both men.

Doesnt matter how gangly he looks if he can score the decisive goal in the next three rounds he will be called legend.

Loved the absence of VAR last night. I thought it added to the atmosphere. Also saved the village idiot from being red carded.

Myko MOTM for me. KDH not far behind.

Just a pity we couldnt keep a clean sheet. Thats 9 goals we have conceded since the international break. I think X marks the spot when we look at the reasons why.

24  John Fitzgerald
30/10/2026    11:19:43

What a pivotal result. The manner of the win and the confidence boost it’ll give the team at this stage of the season is immense. Not saying it’ll define our season, but it’s good to have that win glow for a change. Special mention for Tarkowski throwing Joelinton around, then laughing in their faces. Monday night should be fun, they look toothless up front.

25  Peter Fancy
30/10/2026    14:08:39

‘Just a pity we couldnt keep a clean sheet. Thats 9 goals we have conceded since the international break. I think X marks the spot when we look at the reasons why’


😂

26  Robert Tressell
30/10/2026    14:47:15

John # 19, I agree with every word of that.

I think it is also interesting to look at the impact (or lack of it) from Sebastian Jaissle at Newcastle. Jaissle is one of the highest rated young coaches in Europe after learning his trade at Salzburg and then taking a big money job in Saudi, coaching the likes of Toney, Mahrez, a handful of Europa League (at least) quality Europeans / South Americans and a patchy bunch of Saudi players at Al-Ahli.

There are loads of videos and articles about his tactical acumen and I think we'd have all been excited to have had him at Everton.

But to be honest, from what (admittedly fairly little) I have seen of Newcastle this season - he seems to have quite an amateurish set up. Or maybe the players aren't yet at a standard that suits his set up. Or maybe it will take a bit of time for him to properly get his tactics across to the squad. Anyway, whilst we were pretty open last night (as has been pointed out on another thread), Newcastle were much more so. To be honest, in the two games I've seen they have an awful defensive set up.

Hopefully they continue that kamikaze approach in the next game, as it would be a huge lift for us to pick up back to back league and cup wins.

27  Paul Conway
30/10/2026    15:52:28

Kevin Molloy, he is taking up a Berth in the Squad.
He’s Damaged Goods.. send him back in January.

28  Jeff Armstrong
30/10/2026    20:33:06

I n your world the players are not culpable?

29  Jeff Armstrong
30/10/2026    21:04:26

I would love to send Grealish back to City, unfortunately it won’t be that simple, we will continue to pay him £150,000 a week for him to be “unavailable “
Should not have brought him here in the first place, including last season, Guardiola knew he was finished the moment he stepped on that bus 2.5 years ago, pissed up and out of it.

30  Don Alexander
30/10/2026    22:09:55

Peter (#25), I think "X" for their goal just grievously failed to be in two places at the same time - an unforgivable lapse according to some of course.

For those unfamiliar with Fleetwood's ground it's a grim place for away fans, with no pubs anywhere close by either. And dependant on which way the wind blows the whole town can get notably smelly from a poorly managed local tip.

Enjoy!


31  Brendan Mclaughlin
30/10/2026    23:03:54

Our best players played very well.

Our journeymen put in a performance.

It's an exception not the rule.

32  Darren Hind
31/10/2026    08:00:12

I didnt just talk about the goal we conceded the other night. Thats just an idiotic attempt to distort what I actually said. I spoke about the NINE goals we have conceded recently (Man U. Arsenal.Chelsea. Hull and Newcastle. I could have opened it out and talked about all of the soft goals we have conceded over the past two seasons and then pointed to the common denominator. Nobody expected Tarkowski to be in two places at once when Newcastle scored (Thats just another idiotic claim), but I think you would be hard pushed to find any Evertonian who thought he took up a good position - The "second goalkeeper" position he always adopts.

James Tarkowski Has only ever been a low grade EPL defender. Thats why he has spent a career battling to avoid the drop. I can see why people like him. He does lots of last ditch tackles, clears balls off the line (because he isn't out engaging attackers) and shakes his fist a lot.

I always smile when I see people who relentlessly criticise the manager for employing a negative low block, excessively happy clap the selection of the player who absolutely guarantee's it.

If you don't understand why we concede so many soft goals, Why our captain retreats to his own goal line 5-6 times every match or you havent asked yourself why he has the need to make so many last ditch tackles. Then somebody else needs to explain it to you. I don't have the words.

Happy clap the last ditch tackles all you want, but this team will never improve while the most negative manager in the EPL continues to ask the slowest defender in the world to play on the goalkeepers toes.

33  Antony Abrahams
31/10/2026    08:47:52

The biggest issue defensively at the moment imo Darren, isn’t Tarkowski, it’s Merlin Rohl.

I’m also looking forward to seeing Jake O’Brien, playing in his real position a lot more but for such a big lad, I think he needs to start getting off his heels and learning to jump.

I’m glad I’ve just put the highlights on to see Tarkowski’s position for the Newcastle goal, because as much as I liked watching our goals, it was the delight on the faces of the people in the stands, that gave me the most joy💙

34  Raymond Fox
31/10/2026    10:17:39

I wouldn't overate the performance too much. Apart from our goals which we did take well for a change, I can't think of any more chances we created.
They had 2 or 3 very good chances that they botched, although I'm very grateful for 3 goals and a win the score flattered us.
Maybe I'm too hard to please but that's how I saw it watching the full game again online.

35  Darren Hind
01/11/2026    08:35:40

I wouldnt have even mentioned Tarkowski,Tony. I thought he hadd a very good game. But there are fans who simply cannot enjoy a good victory without trying to ruin it for others.

I've been highly critical of Tarkowski when looking at the bigger picture. I could write twenty pages justifying that criticism, but I am always delighted to see any Everton player playing well. Long may the form he showed on Thursday continue But when somebody who doesnt understand that legitimate criticism and wants to isolate one match as an example to "prove" he is Bobby Moore comes on trying to ruin the celebratory mood of a thread by triumphantly challenging me to show him he is wrong. I feel it incumbant of me to oblige him.

We will play over 40 games this season. Tarkowsli has already given plenty of reasons to criticise him. The notion that he wont be giving plenty more is frankly, for the birds.

36  Antony Abrahams
01/11/2026    09:09:04

I thought it was ridiculous that you got called out Darren, and was actually going to write a post but then thought to myself “what’s the point”?

I prefer to debate, but there doesn’t seem to be that much around these days though, and then I thought about our defensive line up and thought to myself that sometimes I actually like to see a team playing very compact whilst defending deep.

I actually blame the coaching personnel for the big hole that often just suddenly appears in the middle of the park, simply because it’s clear that we are always going to have to defend deeper, until we get a lot more pace at the back.

I hate that there is no real combinations, down the sides, (it’s why I smiled, when you gave your motm, to Mykolenko👍)and I hate that we are often miles away from each other defensively, but sometimes I don’t blame the central defender, I blame the overall shape or system, and think to myself that this is probably why Moyes, couldn’t wait to get Norgaard on the pitch, even though he looked nowhere near it.


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.