The second half of last season showed that the club, and it's playing squad, do not seem to be relegation candidates for the new season due to start in August. If you were to ask most Everton fans, myself incuded, they would be feeling a lot more positive about how the club will do over the course of a 38-game season. However, there would still be a number of lingering doubts and ingrained fears beaten into Everton fans over a number of miserable seasons. With this article, I've tried to show that while not suddenly Champions League contenders and world beaters, it may not be as hard as you'd think for the Blues to climb the league table next season.

There's been a lot said and written in recent seasons about the quality of our squad. "Poor", "in decline", and "paper thin" are some of the adjectives that have been used. Throw in a couple of financial years worth of PSR issues, financing the cost of the new stadium, and our general unattractiveness to potential signings, and it can be hard to see how the squad can be improved enough to rise above a thirteenth or fourteenth place finish. 

However, look at who we signed recently: Ndiaye cost £15m, Alcaraz cost just over £12m, and Beto, who has shown the potential to hit between fifteen goals and twenty goals a season, cost £25m (the going rate for a striker of that calibre.). The club has shown that there are decent signings out there for a price that suits our pocket that will improve perfromances. 

Financially, the pressure has eased with regards to PSR, there is increased revenue from the new stadium, including naming rights, and the debts have been restructured by the new owners. This should allow us a modest transfer budget to continue with an improved approach to signing players. 

Of the players due to be out of contract, none of them that seem to be leaving were felt to be match winners. Re-signing Gueye was essential though and this would provide consistancy. Loans and freebies are a valid option and Mangala before his injury, plus Alcaraz, have shown that we are capable of getting this right. 

When you look at Everton's 13th-place finish in the completed league table for last season, there is a gap of 17 points to Nottingham Forest in the closest European qualification spot of seventh, and then a 13-point gap to Brighton in eighth. After Brighton come Bournmouth, Brentford, Fulham then Crystal Palace. While you might think that 17 points and six league placings is a huge gap to make up for a European qualification, it's not when you break it down a little.

None of those teams listed above hammered us last season. We dropped points against them, horribly so against Bournmouth, but we more than held our own. This was in spite of the perceived differences in how we have been run complared to these clubs. Since the end of last season, Brentford have lost a quality manager and are having their better players poached. Palace's small squad will now have to contend with European football. Brighton, while they have money to spend, may well lose players again over the summer and will have ro start afresh in August. None of these teams would or should frighten us next season. 

Also, we had 15 draws last season, the highest amount in the division. It's said that small margins can make a big difference over the course of a season. We did create chances last season, not millions of them, but we did. Converting them was the issue. Next season, the ball crosses the goal line a couple of times more than it hit the post last seasons and there is a positive points swing. Game management was something that was an issue last season, with the timing of subs an issue. We get our subs on five or ten minutes earlier over the course of thirty eight games and again, draws can be turned into wins. 

We were poor at times against the three promoted teams last season. We dropped points with the draw with Ipswich and the loss to Southampton. I don't see the three teams next season being much better and I do think that we will have more in us to pick up more points against them. 

What I will be watching closely next season is how Palace and Forest cope with European football. Balancing this, and remaining competitive in the league, is a difficult act to get right for clubs in our position. It isn't what it was like under Moyes the first time around as I think the gap financially has widened even more than it was fifteen to twenty years ago. However for now, I do think climbing the league table, and potential Eurpean qualification, isn't as out of reach as we would think.



Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Lyndon Lloyd
14/06/2025    20:48:14

I agree and my feeling is that, assuming we keep Branthwaite and Gueye, the core of the team will remain intact. Purely on the basis of Moyes’s record over the second half of the season just gone, that side could finish higher even by just plugging the “squad depth” holes.

With targeted additions, we could take a step beyond that. How big a leap depends for me on our recruitment this summer. Can we add the kind of quality that allowed Newcastle to take immediate and big strides forward or is it going to be phased (more likely given the scale of the task at hand)?

2  Chris Jenkins
14/06/2025    20:57:24

An excellent contribution Kieran echoing very much my own thoughts on the forthcoming season.

We have the nucleus of a decent team and, in David Moyes, an astute manager who knows the club extremely well. As he proved, during his first managerial term, David is certainly very capable of finding quality players at affordable prices within a sensible age range. The club also appears to be assembling a formidable recruitment team capable of ensuring strict adherence to the Profit and Sustainability Rules.

Hopefully, with a fair wind, the necessary slice of luck and a reasonable transfer budget, the club will be able to move forwards and be competing within the top six or so places over the next three to five years.

3  John Chambers
14/06/2025    21:09:54

I think you are being a bit optimistic looking to Europe next season, unless we can break the habit of the last few years and have a cup run.

Assuming we keep Branthwaite and Gueye from a starting 11 we need a new right back and winger, although I thought Ndiaye looked good against England and, in my view a 15 goal plus centre forward, I'm afraid I don't share your optimism about Beto although I would keep him. From a squad perspective we need a goalkeeper an extra centre back and left back, either old pro's like Young or prospects happy to understudy and probably another central midfielder.

To resolve all those positions successfully, integrate them into the squad in one summer is a big challenge so my expectation is an improvement on this season competing for 8th to 12th

4  Peter Quinn
15/06/2025    11:09:29

The great unknown to me is the new stadium impact. 50000 Evertonians bringing the atmosphere we created at Goodison could be a frightening prospect for any other team in the Premiership. Let us hope it can become our colosseum next season. Our home form was poor last season. Our away form was much better,think wins at Forest, Newcastle, Fulham and Brighton. We can start looking at top half if we get it right at home. I for one cannot wait to hear the whistle for our first game at home. I do not think our home firm can be any worse next year so top half finish for me

5  Mike Allison
15/06/2025    11:38:05

I think ‘savvy recruitment’ is the thing. We’re still 11 players short of having a squad at all, let alone judging its quality. Given that Roma under the Friedkins have been happy to utilise the free agent market, I’ve been expecting us to do the same. It’s a relatively good year for Premier League experienced players being available. However, there’s been very little movement on this front and the fact that we’re still putting the recruitment team in place has me worried that we’re behind the curve on getting things done this summer.

In terms of buying young, quality players it seems we’re only going to be able to get 2-3 and these need to be chance creators and goal scorers.

This means a lot of free agent work and a couple of loans to be in any kind of position to compete next season.

6  Kieran Fitzgerald
15/06/2025    13:37:25

John @3, yep, integrating that many players will be an issue. A slow start, added to Peter @4 very valid point about adjusting to a new stadium, could soon have the players under pressure.
I think getting our transfer business completed early will be essential. Mike is right about the free agent market and if we can get players in this way early, it will help a lot. There are a number of pre-season friendlies lined up that will help with the new stadium, although off the top of my head, I don't know how many are in BMD. The tournament in America will help as well.

A European spot may well be out of reach but surely a jump of three to five places is achievable. Like I said, the mid table pack is nothing to be afraid of.

7  Derek Wadeson
17/06/2025    11:19:46

Walter Smith used to use the 10 points margin, what every team would of done with an extra 10 points be it turning one goal defeats into draws or draws into one goal margin wins.

You can see where he came from teams at the bottom not getting relegated, teams lower table looking at a top half finish, teams in the middle table looking at euro qualifying, teams in the euro spots looking at champions league.

With David Moyes now back at the helm you can see that possibility. Here's hoping for a fair wind and settling into the new stadium quickly because under Sean Dyche it was not fortress Goodison.

8  Craig Scott
18/06/2025    19:41:11

I'm assuming (hoping) that the new administration is putting in place the foundations for a long-term plan that will be focused on the recruitment and development of young talent rather than foraging around for older players at the end of their playing careers filling the gaps in the roster.

For all Moyes's achievements last season, I don't believe he is the answer for the club beyond this next season nor are most of our current squad except for a few. While there may be fine margins to winning or drawing on the pitch, the differences in getting it right off the pitch can be quite large so the acumen and hard work behind the scenes has to start now not kicked down the road to sort out in future seasons.


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.