A Normal Business
Everybody wants a well-run club, until they get one, and realise that it’s about mixing hard work, hard negotiation and patience.
The world is full of normal businesses. Ones that you don’t hear about. Businesses that plan, recruit and do their work thoughtfully. Businesses that work on the basis that if you do the right things consistently for long enough, you get the right results. You never hear about them because the media, and users of social media, tend to be interested in spectacular failure or incredible success.
Since January, I’ve watched Everton take this path, to the disappointment of many. Got rid of the underperforming manager, recruited one who knows the club, knows how to build teams and clubs, even when they move to a new stadium. One who is, frankly, a bit steady and unspectacular. Dismantled the hierarchy, bringing in the people they want when they become available, rather than who’s available right now.
Even with transfers, waiting for the right person at the right price, because as good business people (and punters!) know, you spend your money when there’s value, or you negotiate till you create it. You might miss out on a few things, you’ll get the odd one wrong, but in the long run, you’ll be better off. Whatever happens with Dibling, it is significant that it was Southampton who dropped the price after we walked away, just like Moshiri changed his tune when TFG walked off first time round.
Everybody wants a well-run club, until they get one, and realise that it’s about mixing hard work, hard negotiation and patience. It’s remarkably unsexy. It sometimes seems like you’re doing ‘nothing’, because it’s all happening behind the scenes. I’ve worked for businesses that grew spectacularly quickly, looked invincible, until they crashed just as fast. It’s not so exciting when you see people lose their jobs because of ego and a lack of governance, just like it’s a horrible watch when your cub implodes to near-extinction because an oligarch’s mate thinks money solves everything and keeps woefully inadequate people in charge. That hard work and diligence really makes a difference and it shows.
We’re building foundations on rocky ground here. I’m not expecting to see much for a year or two, possibly a cup run. I’m looking for steady improvement, the kind that might see players and agents take us more seriously. No news about the finances, because they’re being run properly, to let us focus on the football. Little news about the directors, because they just quietly get on with the job of running the business. If we know we’ve been a basket case, what does the rest of the industry think? It’s going to take time to change perceptions. Look at the successful teams over the past few years. Solid structure and foundations first, then improving the business on and of the pitch. Look at those, not just us, who have taken the quick, ‘easy’ path.
I run a one-person business. I’ve made quick decisions to ‘make something happen’ and regretted those costly lessons. These days I take my time and think longer term. I’m glad our new management takes this approach. It isn’t very spectacular, but I think it will work better in the long run. It’s what normal businesses do. So far so good for me.
Reader Responses
Selected thoughts from readers25/08/2025 14:45:47
Completely agree, Dennis. I started going to the game when John Moores started to loosen his grip. I'm greatly encouraged by the long-term outlook of these owners.
25/08/2025 22:55:22
Really good to read that Paul. I wish I read it 5 years ago, before I started my business that failed 3 years later lol.
Anyway, UTFT!
26/08/2025 10:18:39
Sorry to hear that, Peter. I should have mentioned that there's plenty of luck involved in keeping a business running as well. As we'll find out with these new signings of ours!
28/08/2025 12:36:15
Paul, quietly efficient, our new custodians have determined to fix the business first and safeguard our premiership existence at the same time, it may be a disappointment for those who wished for resurrection and got resuscitation instead, self included in that list, but it shows they are in it long term and not to make a quick buck. I suspect the expansion plas include the adjacent Nelson dock and probably more over a couple of years. Previous interested investors could see an opportunity along the waterfront and I am sure TFG are no different.
I guess their decision to appoint Moyes on more than a short tenure, something I still have a problem with tbh, means they want improvement and stability, but I also doubt Moyes will get much leeway if we struggle, those days are gone to be sure and he certainly doesn't look like a man without worries.. he has to earn his crust this time round without the benefit / luxury of time to do it.
We have a far better set of players, missing a few links yet, without a polished striker and an established right back.. fingers crossed!
28/08/2025 14:13:07
Yes Christine, they're doing it properly. I'm happy for them to make money out of it. I actually think Moyes is on steady ground here. TFG won't be expecting trophies; they're clearly looking for stability and signs of progress, which suggests they've recruited the right man. It'll get interesting when there's a perception that we should be seriously challenging for trophies.
28/08/2025 14:52:37
Aye, Paul. It'll be interesting to see who TFG turn to when that expectation comes to the fore. I find it hard to imagine Moyes getting a contract extension unless he's proves to be a significant development from Moyes Mk I - i.e. if he now aims to actually win things!
15/09/2025 07:31:44
Paul, thanks for tampering the expectations of some of the "impatient" Evertonians (IMHO, they are more fed up with the Moshiri era than impatient).
We owe Roma a bouquet of flowers because they served as a guinea pig for TFG, in terms of how NOT to run a football club: firing gaffers at will, ignoring strict Financial Restrictions (signing Dybala even when the club was almost right at the UEFA Financial Cap that is 70% of the club's revenue, which is a lot stricter than PSR) and irritating the most loyal segment of the fan base (tipping my hat to the Roman Ultras who don't mind going a long distance to show TFG their fingers).
So, I am grateful that TFG, after having learnt things in a hard way in Italy, is steering our ship steadily and quietly under the radar (if not for Grealish & Dibling, I would categorise our transfer activities this summer as effectively & stealthily).
Compared to the loud, yet false, promises and lack of any expertise in running a modern club in arguably the Top League in the world across the Liar Bill & Moshiri era, I am sitting back and enjoying every minute of the ongoing "unsexy" rebuild.
Add Your Thoughts
Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.
Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.


25/08/2025 14:42:15
Paul, I largely agree with everything you've written. However, I think there are many of us who will be mightily relieved if, as seems to be the case, we have owners who are quietly effectively planning for the long term. Clubs don't usually succeed unless they are quite well run, & if they're not then they definitely don't sustain success. I finally feel like we're in safe hands for the first time since John Moores grip started to loosen in the '70s.