It’s a Grand Old Team to play for; it’s an insanity-inducing team to support... That’s how the song goes, isn't it? Well, it’s how it feels at least. For Evertonians of a certain vintage, chaos and calamity have been synonymous with the experience of supporting England’s last sleeping giant. A horrible, skin-crawling analogy when referring to a football club. Yet, it is one that has been levelled against Everton for a generation, and maybe more... 

As fog descends on memories of Everton Football Club’s great days, tales of '85 and '87 become distant enough that they begin to wilt into the annals of football mythology. A disdainful situation.  

Our history pior to the 1990s was one decorated with glory. When Nil Satis Nisi Optimum was our standard, not our aspiration. Aside from the aberration of the 1995 FA Cup victory, the years following have been anything but glorious. Feckless ownership, abhorrent commercial decision-making, lacklustre player recruitment, and, of course, misguided managerial appointments have been hallmarks of these most tumultuous times.  

Despite this, there has been one man able to navigate the good ship Everton through stormy seas.  

David Moyes.  

Yes, I know. I understand. I’ve said it myself... 31 years without a trophy for a club the size of ours is unacceptable, regardless of the managerial incumbent. Moyes is guilty as charged. We’ve not even been close that often, have we? The 2009 FA Cup Final against Chelsea, with Moyes at the helm. The 2012 Semi-Final against they-who-must-not-be-named, again Moyes. 

Ever heard of The Curse of Bela Guttman? Supposedly, the outgoing manager of Benfica at the time had declared that his former employers would not see European glory in the next 100 years, having himself been refused a pay-rise. Eight finals, eight losses. It’s the kind of brazen optimism I'd expect from an Evertonian.

Yet, such a record suggests a club whose pursuit of success had at least provided communal hope amongst their faithful. Alas, we Evertonians cling to the promise of a brighter future, regale of past glories, and wrestle with the perpetual state of mediocrity that has befallen our club. Curses, eh...  

Yet, context matters. And, frankly, David Moyes matters. As Everton stormed back to an impressive 3-1 victory against Coventry, Moyes equalled the number of games managed by a true Everton giant in Harry Catterick. 592 games over two spells, in the cutthroat Premier League, is no mean feat.  

Imagine being a school-age Everton fan these days. Year in, year out, the same dreary football existence. Dreading the derby, wincing at the inevitable "Campeones" chants, and, frankly, planning your next sick day around when they may or may not inevitably be lifting their next trophy.  

But for folk of a certain age, this was not always the case. Yes, I may have developed an intense nausea when experiencing Liverpool win that penalty shoot-out against AC Milan. And, yes, this did render double Maths the day after a simply inexcusable form of self-flagellation, leaving me with no option but to stay home and lick my proverbial wounds... 

Despite this, pride and a competitive spirit were hallmarks of a formerly young Evertonian’s life. Since his return, there have been hopeful suggestions of Moyes bringing back this sense of steely optimism. Certainly, to end last season disappointed in not attaining European competition is a sign of progress. Continuing to this campaign, Everton find themselves in the lofty nether regions of the European positions, and a League Cup Quarter-Final to look forward to.

As stated earlier, context matters. We must not forget for a second where we have been, or where we may have been. Everton were on the brink, and more than once, both financially, and on the field of play. We are quick to point the finger at our lack of “success” during his two tenures. Fine, but show me a manager who, under such relative financial constraints, could squeeze as much out of as little.

Consider how he has developed players. Everton currently have three regular England internationals in their ranks, and in Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, surely soon to be four. Not since he was last at the helm was this the case. This has been managed in the goldfish bowl of a massive institution. We’re not an easy fanbase to appease. Nor should we be. We hold everybody fortunate enough to pull on the royal blue to a high standard, and so does Moyes.

I, like so many Evertonian’s feel the frustration of Moyes’ football. Where could we be if he’d lift the handbrake? Especially against the so-called “better sides”, who, in this most average of Premier League offerings, aren't ones to be feared. That's purely hypothetical. What isn’t is how he has moved the club onwards, from relegation dog-fight certainties to a competitive Premier League football team.  

The final chapter is yet to be written in the David Moyes volume of the Everton anthology. Regardless of what the conclusion may be, it will be a complicated one. But one thing is for certain: though the giant continues to sleep, there are signs of life. For that, we have David Moyes to thank.



Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Frank Sheppard
18/11/2026    07:09:20

Under Moyes v1- we usually finished top end of the middle section of the PL.

This was excellent bearing in mind what he inherited.

It says much about the disaster the club has been since he left, that if Moyes v2 repeated this. It would be more of an achievement it was first time around.

If we could manage a cup win, the feel good factor would be a very positive reset.

2  Paul Conway
18/11/2026    15:37:07

Since the eighties, it’s been more than rough supporting Everton, with the exception of an FA Cup win.

It’s even more baffling, when you consider the quarter - finals and semi - finals and the manner, by which we brushed aside Newcastle and Spurs, to reach the final.

I don’t remember us repeating such performances for the remainder of that decade.. unless, someone can remind me.

So, here we are 31 years later and nothing to shout about, except for a few “Oufffs!!, when we snatched relegation, from the jaws of the Crocodile, figuratively speaking.

The emotional ride, over those years, for myself, hasn’t quite equated to the “ Stockholm syndrome “, but more akin to :

The Direct Loss Dopamine Study (Linnet et al., 2010)

The study that most directly proves losing money itself creates a chemical reward rush is a 2010 brain-imaging study published in Addiction titled "Dopamine release in ventral striatum of pathological gamblers losing money

• The Experiment. Researchers used Positron Emission Tomography (PET) scans to measure dopamine levels in 16 pathological gamblers and 15 healthy control subjects while they played the Iowa Gambling Task.

• The Findings. When pathological gamblers lost money, they experienced a significant surge in dopamine release in the left ventral striatum (the brain's core reward and pleasure center), whereas healthy controls showed no such spike.

• The Takeaway. When participants won money, there was no difference in dopamine release between the two groups. For problem gamblers, the brain chemically rewards the act of losing, which drives the compulsion to keep betting.

The above case study has summed up the relationship between Everton and myself.

Some, people ask.. “why Bother ?”.. the answer to that is the “Jam
Tomorrow syndrome !”

I honestly hope that this new Dawn heralds much well deserved success, especially for our younger supporters, who hitherto have been positively starved.
For Arl Fella’s like myself, well! it’s the Twilight.. or the Depature Lounge !

3  Jerome Shields
18/11/2026    15:49:29


Sean it is good that Moyes steadied the ship but let's not pretend steady is the same as sailing.

The article asks the right question, "where could we be if he'd lift the handbrake?" then immediately calls it "purely hypothetical." That's us all over, isn't it? We know the football's cautious, we know there's more in this squad, and we talk ourselves out of wanting it.

I get it. We were on the brink, more than once. Moyes dragged us out of the mud and we're a proper Premier League side again. That matters. But that's recovery, not progress. Recovery has a ceiling, and nobody in the piece ever says what happens after we hit it.

592 games level with Catterick is a lovely stat. Catterick won things though, didn't he? And being disappointed to miss out on Europe isn't progress, it's just us remembering we used to expect better.

The comment underneath says it all, really: if Moyes doing what he did first time round would now be a bigger achievement, that says more about how far the club fell than it does about the manager.

I'll take stability. I'm grateful for it. But when every grumble gets answered with "remember where we've been," we stop asking for more, and that's how a big club settles for being a nice one. Signs of life are great. I'd just like a direction to go with them.

4  Bobby Thomas
18/11/2026    16:17:36

Catterick had massive spending power in the transfer market.

English football’s biggest transfer spenders by decade:

60s: Everton
70s: Everton
80s: Man United
90s: Newcastle
00s: Chelsea
10s: Man City
20s: Chelsea

5  Darren Hind
18/11/2026    16:29:18

I don't think we have anything at all to thank Davey Moyes for,

Everton FC has made him one of the richest failures in sporting history.

He should be on his knees in gratitude. 12.5m to add to the 30m he earned first time around.

Good job he wasnt here when we got all those points deducted. He struggles enough when there is no pressure on him

6  John Raftery
18/11/2026    17:50:20

Lifting the handbrake is an interesting concept. One of Harry Catterick’s most entertaining seasons was the 1968/69 edition when the team played some exceptional attacking football but won nothing. For the following season it could be said he applied the handbrake by tightening up the defence, made the team tougher to beat, lost only five matches, won many important victories by one goal margins and lifted the title. One nil to the Everton was never a terrace chant but it would have been justified during that season.

Both Catterick and Kendall believed the foundation of a team’s success was a solid defence. Although the modern game is very different from their days the fundamentals remain the same. We have had a manager who seemed to have no idea what a handbrake was. His name was Roberto Martinez.

7  Philip Sheehan
18/11/2026    17:53:09

bobby just to give your list of big spenders a bit more context - in the 70's catterick was in charge 70-71 but in 71-72 season he was really only in charge up yo early january 72 when he had a heart attack...i seem to remember trainer tommy casey being a caretaker.
in short bingham and lee did most of the spending in the 70's
inexplicably bingham allowed to make 2 big signings just weeks before he got his p45 !
the players. bruce rioch & duncan mc'kenzie as for davie I was ok with him until he made the knives to a gunfight presser ! a great morale booster to his players - NOT !
& his attitude towards little everton when he got the man utd job was terrible. but fickle as I am if and ita big IF we beat brentford & liverpool all is forgiven !!!


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.