David Moyes Successfully Protects Another Defeat: The Everton Banality Lays Heavy
The Blues seemingly achieved their aim at Arsenal on Saturday
A great deal has changed for some football clubs over the last 20 years.
In 2007, Brentford finished bottom of the Third Division while Brighton and Bournemouth were 18th and 19th respectively. Today, the trio are the darlings of the Premier League, lauded constantly for running smartly and executing efficient player recruitment to compete at the top level. They are fearless and take on every team in the same way, unfazed by the opposition’s stature or strengths.
Then there’s Everton, however. Two decades ago, they were a capable side under David Moyes but had no interest in going on the attack when it came to facing the top sides away from home. They were scared to. Hesitant, meek; subservient even. Today, that remains exactly the case.
On Saturday against Arsenal, the current Premier League champions and one of the biggest clubs in the land, the manager opted to start the runners, those perceived to be robust enough to keep the game tight, ahead of anyone who dares try to make something happen. No way could we compete, apparently.
The ball players like Hayden Hackney and Tyler Dibling were left on the bench for an age as Everton looked to protect a defeat for more than an hour. They went behind after only seven minutes despite their cautious set-up taking hold from the first second.
It’s a game I’ve watched a hundred times before and why Everton, in this, a supposed new era, has never felt so samey, so tired and so, so uninspiring.
Would the managers of Bournemouth, Brighton and Brentford been so obsequious? Doubtful.
But am I calling for Moyes’ head? Not at all. There’s no point. It’s the latest placeholder season in which circumstance simply feeds into the narrative that the Scot is the man for the job. The owners are looking to get off, another recruitment window didn’t go as it should, it’s a small, dysfunctional squad and so Moyes is there at the helm once again with the observing outside masses insisting, ‘What more can he do?’.
Using his squad and mixing things up would be a start. The names he seemingly sticks with… I’ve seen so many variations of Brennan Johnson at Everton over the last 25 years and they are the antithesis of the players the club should be signing. He’s earned a move, stalled, ended up here and I can already tell you exactly how Johnson’s career will go at Hill Dickinson Stadium.
The forward is going to have very little impact in more than half the games. He’s going to get a few assists and a couple of goals. One will be a memorable winner against United or Chelsea at home. He’ll leave in January 2029 to a Fulham or a Forest or a West Brom. His Everton record will read 65 appearances and seven goals.
So middling, he’s the type of player who keeps the engine running while the car doesn’t actually go anywhere. We absolutely love signing these lads while anyone with potential is seemingly dismissed for not being the finished product and deemed not safe and solid enough. It’s why Adam Aznou is out on loan while Everton have only one recognised left-back.
It is your Tyler Diblings and Hayden Hackneys who have a huge ceiling to grow that can have a genuine impact given a sustained run. But under Moyes’ stewardship, it’s these players who must prove themselves via a seat on the bench for weeks and months on end.
The Blues boss has at least started playing Tyrique George again but there just seems to be too much emphasis on a safety-first approach. It’s not defensive as such but the handbrake is firmly on. It’s tedious to follow and conjures a real feeling of monotony.
Everton trailed by a single goal for a long while at Arsenal on Saturday. They went two behind on 68 minutes. On 72, Dibling was introduced. On 74, Hackney came on. Too little, too late, but so predictable.
Now, to Moyes’ credit, he has more about him than the managers labelled long-ball merchants like Sam Allardyce and Tony Pulis. But if they are one-dimensional, Moyes is 2D yet managing in a football world now played in 4D. So many clubs in 2026 are investing in young, unproven talent and throwing players in at the deep end. They are allowed to flourish while making their mistakes in order for them, and the team, to grow. Not at Everton though.
I’m tired of the noise around the club constantly pointing to how difficult everything is, how we are trying and hoping while other teams with nowhere near our standing are simply giving it a right good go and reaping the rewards. Other sides in the division play with a braveness and boldness that provides the opportunity to beat AC Milan in Europe as Bournemouth did just a few days ago. We, however, shun such valiance.
Supporting Everton under Moyes is like when your Indian gets delivered but they’ve forgotten the Naan bread. A Chinese without the prawn crackers or a Big Mac without sauce. Sure, it’s a meal and you’ll eat, but you can’t help but feel deflated when you open the bag and know you’re missing out on the full experience.
Now nobody is saying you should head to Arsenal, the Premier League champions no less, and beat them 3-0 having played them off the park. But come on, have a go by being dynamic and playing with a bit of creativity. Be proactive from minute one. Sure, the game may still end in defeat but you can take pride in attempting to play and at least get the away fans on the edge of their seats now and again.
‘What do you expect?’ will be the question posed by some following this afternoon’s defeat. A great deal more than what’s on show right now. A proactive plan. A desire to go for it. A positive, morale-boosting outlook.
You can count our wins at Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool and United on one hand over the last 30 years but it’s telling that Moyes was in charge for only one of those, beating a poor Red Devils side last season. Carlo Ancelotti claimed more victories away at these sides in just 18 months.
We have 5 Premier League away wins at Arsenal (1), Chelsea (0), Liverpool (2) and Manchester United (2) combined in the past 30 seasons. That’s 5 wins in 120 games.
— Jimmy Driver (@jnd_90) October 24, 2026
It’s all too rigid, in the play, and the approach, and the manager time again at these places gets exactly what he sets up for.
This juncture, with genuine talent in the squad, should be the perfect time to put belief into your players and let them grow together. Lay foundations. If we aren’t going to win trophies, why not have some fun in trying to stick the ball in the back of the net? There is no long-term thinking however and right now, the club is pointless. Sure, they very likely won’t go down but they won’t achieve anything noteworthy either.
Until Everton are sold to serious people, this is our lot and we will bob along, almost stationary, as those around us speed off in the pursuit of progress. Moyes being in charge is a symptom of the difficulties at the club but, make no mistake, his team selections are a cause for elements of the disillusionment and dropping of points too.
The predictability of Everton under this manager is that I started writing this piece at half-time and didn’t have to make a single edit thereafter. The blue banality lays heavy.
Reader Responses
Selected thoughts from readers25/10/2026 07:17:39
Absolutely sums it up. Now fans just feel apathy, rather than anger.
25/10/2026 07:22:55
Fully agree.
Yesterday was the most disinterested I've been in an Everton game for as long as I can remember, and it's 36 years this month since my first game (drew nil nil against Crystal Palace).
We all knew what would happen, from the result and the performance, right down to the starting 11 and late subs.
It really is Groundhog Day.
BJ should be our back up striker, Hackney and Dibling should be developed and trusted to develop rather than persisting...blah, blah, blah.
We all typed the same comment many, many times.
25/10/2026 08:14:22
Moyes Everton premier league away record v Chelsea, Liverpool, Arsenal and Man Utd: P52 W1 D18 L33 GF 34 GA 93.
A win rate of 1.9% and a goal difference of - 59.
That was before yesterdays result, where Moyes packed his team with runners who ran around a lot before slumping to defeat. Brennan Johnston touched the ball 10 times in 72 minutes. Dibling touched the ball 24 times when he replaced him as sub.
Moyes has shown he is incapable of learning from outcomes, he is as stubborn as he is ineffectual. Mind you, who would want to replace him? The owners are trying to sell the club, they will not put more money up to strengthen the squad and there will be n incomings in January.
Completely unattractive to quality candidates.
25/10/2026 08:20:29
Spot on.
David Moyes has to go. his team selection and tactics are abysmal. He'll stick with his favourites no matter their form or how crap they are. 0-0 is a result for him.
We need someone with ambition, someone for who entertainment is a goal.
#MoyesOut
Rob
25/10/2026 09:52:51
Superb article Brell.Youve nailed it.I want Moyes gone.I wrote on the match report itself that Ive had an absolute bellyful of him and his negativity.But as you say, theres no point in calling for his removal because the club is currently in such a state of uncertainty regarding the future ownership.Sadly, it means that in the short to medium term, the fans are going to have to put up with Dour Dave and his dull, dreary unadventurous approach to team selection and tactics.
I honestly believe weve got players that under a more positive, progressive manager willing to really encourage them to play with more freedom could very well thrive.Alcaraz, Dibling, George, Hackney, Armstrong…also Braiden Graham, who hasnt had a look in so far.But these lads are NEVER going to thrive under Moyes managerial approach.His tactics simply dont encourage bravery and creativity on the ball…and that must be soul destroying for young players eager to show what they can do without the handbrake constantly being on.
Unfortunately, this is the situation were now in.And its likely going to continue this way until we get new owners with a genuine interest in our club, and who are genuinely keen to make us properly competitive again, which the Friedkins no longer are.So, so frustrating and sad, particularly for the younger Evertonians whove had so little to sustain them over the years.And whilst Dour Dave is in charge, theyre not even going to see much in the way of exciting football, let alone silverware.Heartbreaking…☹️
25/10/2026 10:28:50
Moyes's anti football gets worse season on season. If you went to the odeon wasted £20 & 2 hours watching a crap film. Would you go back 2 weeks later to see that same film ? Or a restaurant where the service and food is awful and there's a hidden service charge- would you say let's go back there it might improve ?
The moyes / tfg combination will take us to another relegation cliffhanger.
Crisis what Crisis ?
25/10/2026 11:34:45
Absolutely spot on Ell
Boring boring boring
Is this why we fell in love with football??
25/10/2026 11:38:40
Got the usual emails off the club offering me tickets for Thursday game.
I've no intention of wasting a few hrs watching more shite than my fragile foorball enthusiasm can handle.
25/10/2026 12:34:37
I want Moyes gone at the end of the season too - because I would someone like Kieran McKenna to come in, be given a competitive budget and develop a better brand of footballing identity.
But it is a strange logic that Moyes is holding us back in league position when his track record for us is the best and most consistent of the Premier League era - being (in reverse order):
2012/13:6 (Europe)
2011/12:7
2010/11:7
2009/10:8
2008/09:5 (Europe)
2007/08:5 (Europe)
2006/07:6 (Europe)
2005/06:11
2004/05:4 (Champions League)
2003/04: 17
2002/03: 7th
2001/02: 15th (a mid-season relegation rescue job)
Outside of the Moyes era (Premier League) we've finished better than 8th only 3 times and with much more expensively assembled sides (Royle once, Martinez once and Koeman once). No-one has beaten his fourth place finish.
He can be horribly boring and negative and suck the life out of the fans (albeit given 52,000 keep turning up I think that is overstated on here). He's also guilty of spending a big / bigger budget poorly (although he hasn't had the opportunity in his 2nd spell - with only the 14th lowest budget in his first season, and the pretty dire spending this summer).
But he is good at developing / building a good side on a lean budget and then (having done that) playing pretty good football too. He's also demonstrated a good track record of getting a club into Europe.
What he isn't good at is taking a really good squad to the next level (since we're currently a fair bit off that, he doesn't seem to be half as much a problem as the extremely low levels of investment).
I think Hurzeler would be a really popular choice as our next manager, but it is worth noting that for his first two seasons he hit the Hurzeler glass ceiling of 8th with an extremely well assembled Brighton squad. And made little impact in the cups too.
And for context, the Brighton squad cost €567m to assemble - which is €234m more than we spent on the fifth cheapest squad in the division (ours is €333m). And Hurzeler has been unable to develop (or even maintain the value of) talented and sought after players like O'Riley, Gruda, Wieffer, Rutter, Tzimas and Osman over the past couple of seasons or so.
To be honest, I think most Everton fans would have considered him completely incompetent had he achieved so little with Brighton's €281.45m spending spree in 2024/25.
So Hurzeler, if he were to come in, seems very unlikely to be an instant hit given what would be available to him. However, if we were to start spending big (i.e. year on year net spending of between £100m to £300m), then I expect Hurzeler's more progressive / sophisticated tactics could take us further than Moyes would - with the same level of investment.
25/10/2026 12:46:04
Robert...it's pointless talking about new managers until moyes has gone.
He has a decent squad albeit threadbare, it's how he uses that squad that boils my piss.
When he made the substitutions yesterday we looked more threatening and lively, this has happened on several occasions this season but still he reverts to safety first football.
25/10/2026 14:14:20
Robert #11, Moyes was initially somewhat of a yo-yo manager, as your stats show. It was only in his 6th full season that he achieved successive top half finishes. Even thereafter, I don't think we were massively outperforming, relative to our comparative expenditure on players. I fail to see what Moyes II has to offer that we wouldn't expect from Allardyce or Dyche. This cannot be the future for our Club.
25/10/2026 14:28:28
Dennis # 13, I see what you are getting at but Moyes' arrival was off the back of the following finishes:
2000/01: 16
1999/00: 13
1998/99: 14
1997/96: 17
1996/97: 15
1995/96: 6
1994/95: 15
1993/94: 17
1992/93: 13
We'd been largely terrible since the start of the Premier League in 1992 - playing generally awful football under a series of crap managers. Royle's 6th place in 1996 was a highlight but that was the season we bought Kanchelskis - a player who would now cost anywhere between £125m and £150m.
Moyes wasn't really yo yo at the start - he was a massive improvement. Even 11th was a big improvement on what had come before. It really is staggering that we've never been relegated - given just how awful we've been for such long stretches of the Premier League.
25/10/2026 15:07:55
David @10, fragile football enthusiasm, brilliant and depressingly true.
25/10/2026 15:17:16
Conway
25/10/2026 13:12:31
absolutely nailed on Ell.
Especially the reference to Johnson and Aznou.
I was going to refrain from posting, as I would have only morose and negative comments to add.
But, then again, if I was checking in to read the comments. They would be negative comments, that I would be reading.
And, as a family of Blues, why should we not unite in grief?.. a bit like mourning !
Im sure that each and every one of us, has said to himself / herself, at least once “ Thats it!, Im done with this Club… whats the point ?.. we are not going anywhere. We are always looking up.. or, looking down, to see if there are three worse Teams than us… “
For example, I used to read ToffeeWeb, as I was Banned from Posting, as Michael was editing my post, so, I called him out with some advice, after a night on the Beer, hence never go on social media after a few too many Drinks !
Nonetheless, I used to sneak a peek, out of morbid curiosity.I found that comments became more and more negative and toxic, to the point where people were turning on each other, with personal attacks and slurs and a lot of it was out of pure frustration, so I ended up by blanking it altogether.
God forbid that nothing ever happens like this on this site, which, Ive become very fond of.
However, I had similar moment, to what I referred to above.
Something weird happened to me at the end of last Season —- Well, after having witnessed an implosion, in the last 7 games, being so close to a European spot and seeing that Moyes, was introducing Tyrique George ( he didnt just come good this season !), as a supstitute, in three games on the trot, to replace McNeil.
I screamed ” I will never, ever look at anything Everton, until this Charlatan has gone !”
No Social Media, no nothing !
But, like the prodigal proverbial Gambler, who knows hes going to lose, but can still get as much of a kick out of losing, than winning ( its the betting that counts !), I came back, with renewed fervour.
Sniffing out all things Everton the lows and the lowers!
I have noticed, that we have un uncanny knack of buying players that are long over their peak.
The likes of Grealish, Norgaard, Maitland Niles, Johnson, who by the way could fast become the next Deli Ali!
Maybe Im jumping the gun a bit, on a couple of these players, in the eyes of other supporters, but Im going to go with my gut instinct.
lets not forget, that to other supporters, The Dour one is, after all, the Moyesiah!
Its all a matter of crazy opinion, at the end of the Day.
Myself, I was vehemently against the appointments of Allardyce, Benitez, Dyche and Moyes and couldnt wait to see the backs of all of them.
But after all things considered, from of all four, I would argue that, it was Dyche, who achieved the most for our Club.
In the face of adversity, and lumbered with a points deduction, he pulled us up by our Bootstraps and saved us from certain relegation and the inevitable oblivion.. but boy did we suffer the insufferable, with the the gaslighting and drivel, that we had to witness before the agonising end.
What gets me about these type of long in the tooth bang average Managers, is that they keep banging on about, how long theyve been in the game and how much experience they have gained and experience should equate to youngsters, having to wait their turn on the Bench and all the McBollox rest of it.
Experience for what ??
To win what in your Managerial career?..
Tout ça, pour ça !!
Dyche held OBrien back, as in his “ experience “, he wasnt ready.
Moyes is hesitant with George, Dibling and Hackney have to ride the Bench, as they are a wee bit young and inexperienced, in his Managerial experience !!
One thing is Certain.. The Dour one, will walk away, or get ejected and find himself a lot Richer, than when he arrived, for his second stint of pure, unadulterated mediocrity.
But there will be another last payday, for failure.
He will probably get the Celtic, or Scotland Gig after this one.
And if not, who cares? Theres always room for another loser at the Uber gig, Along with Pardew ( Parody!), Pulis, Allardyce.. all paragons of failure and walking Parodies of themselves.. thus proving, that there is after all, Money in Muck !
25/10/2026 15:34:33
Paul, eventually the phone just stopping ringing for a lot of these managers. Club by club, season by season, their inadequacies become bigger and more glaringly obvious. Moyes may well fet one more gig after us, but little else I think.
25/10/2026 15:55:00
Just read on TW, two wins in fifteen league games. Poor quality football in all fifteen games as well. People say we won't get relegated. But teams are starting to pick up points while we're not doing much. Given the squad, and pitential lack of investment in January, and we could easily get sucked into a relegation battle.
What concerns me is the lack of drive on the pitch. Id wonder how much of a stomach there would be fir a scrap.
25/10/2026 16:26:54
I don't subscribe to the seemingly widely-held belief that we are safe from relegation with Moyes in charge.
I don't see Forest and Sunderland staying in the bottom three for long.
Don't get me wrong. I am NOT saying we will go down. But we are struggling to create chances, let alone score, and I am expecting a season where we are looking over our shoulders. And a poor run of form could lead to a lack of confidence, with no Seamus to keep up morale.
A good cup run, or two, would be great for morale. Am hoping Hackney and Dibling start on Thursday as I can see them giving us a shot in the arm.
25/10/2026 17:01:07
we are without doubt in the frame for the big R. But it's not the catastrophe it would have been two years ago. We've got a disastrously shallow squad, and we haven't even got to November yet. Wait til we hit Christmas. It already feels like the players aren't running as hard as they can, and we don't now have Goodison to bail us out. The only upside is the Friedkins would lose an absolute fortune, and they would have brought it all on themselves for being such tight arses.
25/10/2026 17:20:35
Mike #19, completely agree on Hackney. He came off the bench like he was shot out of a cannon. Every touch was forward, every run was aggressive, he got off a decent shot and knocked an Arse on his arse. Great stuff. Should definitely start.
Dibling, on the other hand, was completely passive yesterday in his total 26 minutes on the pitch. Completed 18 for 18 passes, exactly two of which were forward. The other 16 were backward or sideways. He had six back passes to Hackney alone. Despite being given plenty of space, he never once attempted to take on a defender, or put in a cross, or get into a shooting position. And he never made contact with an opponent or set foot in the Arsenal penalty area until the final 30 seconds. He was a human Quaalude in cleats, and that doesn't earn a start for me.
25/10/2026 20:05:02
Paul@16.
Nail on head mate...those managers (Allerdyce,Dyche...et al) have between them years of experiencing winning next to fuck all.
The yanks have put this club back into turmoil, no buyer by Xmas and we're stuck with the same loser and same squad.
25/10/2026 20:33:15
Jesus, those '90s League placings are truly depressing reading.
Funny, because '94 to '96 are my best memories of being an Evertonian...Great days under JR.
Relegation battles so every game felt like a Cup final, the actual Cup final itself, the amazing semi final performance, the Blood and Thunder of a classic QF against Newcastle, towering performances from Big Dunc and witnessing the brilliance of Andrei Kanchelskis!
I was so excited/scared in every match, my stomach would turn every time the opposition attacked!
I didn't even bother watching yesterday.
25/10/2026 20:33:28
Dave @22, that is the concern.
No one knows, whats going on behind the scenes, in terms of potential investors and buyers. But sods law and unlikely that TFG will fund new players.
The cloud of chaos is in the distance, but let's hope starting Thursday, Everton turn up and beat the Skunks.
Sadly, the old match menu from 20 years ago is back in vogue. Limited squad size but numbing to watch. Chelsea was soul destroying, barely put a glove on them, except for 13 mins after Armstrong's booking.
Yesterday was default and Hull, rank defending.
A funny old game...
Massive match on Thursday.
25/10/2026 21:58:58
Lee Courtiff (23)
I remember that cup run, so well. Especially the 6th round and the semis.
I was living in Hove ( actually 😀),at the time and the guy that cut my hair just before the semis, was a mad Spurs fan and was going to the match with his son.
A time when B&H Albion hadnt got a pot to piss in, by the way.
Its a good job I didnt leave my hair for a week, or it would have been a throat cut !
But, joking aside, what I would really like to highlight, was the clinical way in which we dispensed, of both Newcastle and Spurs.
With Newcastle, it was a well deserved 0-1 but, with Spurs it was a total devastation of the opposition — something that was totally out of the blue, after some good exchanges from both Teams.
I remember ( might get it on YouTube), the game was played at an exhilarating Breakneck pace, which absolutely belied our league form
.
Both games were played at an extraordinary high level of quality.
When it got to the final, I think it was more about nerves, as overall, for the neutrals, it wasnt easy the eyes.
I think that, thats what made our Victory all that more special.
despite our League position, we still showed resilience.
Nonetheless, a serious example, of a funny old Game.
25/10/2026 22:26:41
Paul, the full 90 minutes BBC coverage is available on YouTube of the QF, I've watched it a couple of times over the last few years.
It's a proper FA Cup game, the pre match atmosphere comes through the screen. Both sets of fans were up for it, as were the players.
A game of many chances for both teams, could have easily been 4-3 either way!
Well worth a watch, mate.
25/10/2026 22:55:53
lee Courtiff
Cheers Bro !. Ill check it out.
It will be the first time to see it again and definitely an escape route, from the current Fare, that we are witnessing.
Wouldnt you like to have Amokachi in This Team, in place of Barry?
I remember, we bough him, off the back of a 94 WC exploit with Nigeria, I think.
Wouldnt it be great, if Moyes could find some more Absolute Gems like him ?
wouldnt it be nice, to get on with me Neighbours ?.. But, they make it very clear, they aint got time for Ravers !..
26/10/2026 03:07:38
Paul (#27), great song by the Small Faces of my distant youth but the following verse from that same song speaks volumes to me about where we true fans find ourselves;
"There's no one to hear me
There's nothin' to say
And no one can stop me
From feeling this way."
Our club's been bent over a barrel, fucked senseless for personal financial gain for decades by self-serving-only conniving bastard owners (including Friedkin now) and frankly I see no reason to be cheerful before I die.
I'm 71 so I remember the success we had in the early and late 60's, and the mid 80's after what I thought at the time had been a hideous period of mediocre ownership, but once Kenwright and even more devious bastards got their hooks into us, still now and probably to come I suppose, my lifelong devotion to Everton FC is withering.
It's like being wed to a wife who's "successfully" sought to be fucked by all and sundry, whilst in my own company still giving me an occasional kiss on the cheek to keep me satisfied.
It's shite.
26/10/2026 06:54:48
Apparently Eddie Howe is in the running for the Utd. job if Carrick is sacked. Another decent option potentially off the table. If your an Eddie Howe, or a Ciaran McKenna, and you're potentially in the running for the Utd job, Everton is a non runner.
26/10/2026 07:36:35
Moyes is in negotiations on a contract extension.They are currently stalled.IMO TFG are only offering a year and the Dour Moyes is looking longer.This actually makes sense in the Sales process.He has told the younger players they have to be patient,It does not matter whether they like that or not,as far as Moyes is concerned.
Johnson is a player that needs to run onto a ball beyond the defence He always struggled in front of a set up defence. He is actually getting further away from that, because Moyes expects him to track back.
Everton did look a bit better getting the ball forward quicker, because there was no Grealish to hold the ball up,The problem was that the play was too far back in Moyes:s set up and the two central defenders stayed deep, so much so they unsighted Pickford for the first goal.
Moyes attempt at the low block with inverted wingers,something he learnt from Dyche means that the players are too close to defenders to get on the ball properly losing possession.If there was a more coherent forward movement as a team the opposition defence would be forced back, giving the forward players more space facing towards the goal, rather than having defenders able to breath down their necks and stay in position.The faster the attacking movement the more out of position the defenders will be.You never see Everton Centre backs waving the defence to move up.They would get shot by Moyes.
Moyes knows the stats he has had seasons of them.He had decided before the game that Arsenal where going to win.It might have thought when younger he might be lucky, but not now.
For Arsenal defending against Everton was a training ground exercise.
26/10/2026 08:43:33
It is definitely not down to David Moyes, that we are so embarrassingly light up top, but I have seen the same isolation of our centre forward tactics, so many times from this manager, over many soul-destroying years.
I was thinking about it yesterday, would a team looking to get out of the championship and into the EPL, have any real chance if Tierno Barry, was their only centre forward, and yet some people have consistently told us that the recruitment wasnt that bad.
Waited years for a right back and we got a player who is a better midfielder. Got rid of a left back, leaving only one other fit left back, to go alongside the midfielder playing right back.
Appalling recruitment, absolutely, devastatingly, appalling recruitment, and I would be genuinely surprised if anyone thinks that this squad is getting managed properly?
26/10/2026 08:50:23
Pau#29
You are in good company getting banned by Michael Kendrick.You should wear it as a badge of honours.I am proud of you.
26/10/2026 10:43:44
Jerome. Whats the source of your information about Moyes and a contract extension ?
26/10/2026 10:57:15
Yep. That a 0-2 defeat at Arsenal is viewed with a weary shrug says it all. When Leeds went there a few weeks ago they gave it a good old go and scared the shit out of them.
Yeah, we have a tiny squad but we have a better first team XI than last season, (if used properly), except we were getting some decent results on the road last year.
Still - hell have to dump KITANO in the bin on Thursday and go for it - his starting lineup should reflect that. Note that I said “should”.
26/10/2026 11:05:10
Thanks Jerome.
It was very frustrating getting my posts edited, just to facililitate his narrative.
So, I sent him an email, asking him to… “ Kindly put his head between his legs and do a disappearing act!”
Those werent my exact words, but you get the picture.
I then applied, when the site changed hands and was accepted back, a bit like when a Pub changes hands, its not unusual to see some Ex Barred Punters, come strolling Back!
So, Michael came back and I had to resign in and found, to no avail, it was impossible.
So, it thought me not to go on social Media after a few.
There was a very funny Irish sketch on that particular subject, doing the rounds on Tik Tok a few years back..
This guy comes back from the Pub, after having a right few.
He is feeling a bit frisky, so he decides to text his Girlfriend, Named Gráinne ( Pronunciation GRAWN-ye), and asks her, does she fancy a bit.. he gets a reply.. “ not tonight, Im a bit tired, Maybe tomorrow night !”
He then asks her “ well, can I at least send you A @ick Pic?..
She replies..” oh! Go on then..”
The next Day, whe he wakes up, he checks his messages and realises, that he sent the picture to his GRANNY!!
26/10/2026 13:44:36
Antony, I dont think anyone believes our recruitment has been good enough.
I only ever want us to sign players capable of gracing the latter stages of the Champions League. Were clearly not doing that.
Some such players are available from cheap markets and / or very young - and generally require some development. Even then you have to kiss a few frogs.
We should obviously do that - buying, loaning and developing at high volume.
And we also need to buy such talents at decent volume in the mid-price zone of about £40m to £70m in order to get hold of players better equipped to hit the ground running like Manzambi and Jackson who gave City a torrid time for Villa yesterday.
That sort of suggestion (which seems plainly obvious) is very controversial on here - with many fans insistent we should somehow flourish only as plucky, poor little Everton.
26/10/2026 16:22:27
Lees#33
I had no source up to when Moyes stated himself he was in contract extension talks.I thought it the most likely situation when I looked at the Finances and the way TFG where conducting themselves.
No matter what I think of Moyes, which is probably similar to Tony, he is doing the job that TFG and not questioning them. They are not talking to him.
26/10/2026 16:33:31
Paul#35
I ended up using my daughter's e mail address to get back in and managed to get my name up in posts
The must frustrating part was getting cut of in threats and not able to reply, having self indulgence victory posts follow.
I knew others had similar experiences, but they have been largely vindicated in their opinions.
But no hard feelings and hopefully it made me a better poster for Evertonia.
26/10/2026 16:33:39
To paraphrase the Immortal Madeleine Kahn
I'm tired
Sick and tired of EFC
I've had my fill of Moyesie
From GP to HD
Tired, tired of being taken for granted
Tired of footie uninspired
Let's face it, I'm tired!
I'm tired
Tired of playing the game
Ain't it a crying shame
I'm so tired
God dammit I'm exhausted!
26/10/2026 17:14:53
Great article, Ell.
I'm bored now. There is no point to supporting a club like Everton anymore. There's no excitement in the possibility of winning anything and there's no enjoyment in the way we play.
Since 1995, there's been a few sporadic and brief periods that I enjoyed. A couple of spells under Moyes. Martinez's first season. The few games when Dunc was in caretaker charge. Briefly under Silva when we thumped United over Easter and then, Ancelotti and James Rodriguez up to Christmas. The rest has been pretty uninspiring on the whole and predictable. My lad is now 15. He's experienced us beating the RS twice in his lifetime.
I saw Moyes before the Arsenal game and he never comes out and says "we're coming here to get 3 points". He was talking about "the footballing Gods can sometimes surprise you" or words to that effect. To get the footballing Gods on your side, stop playing underperforming players like Brennan Johnson.
Everything I predicted during the summer has come true. I said we would be scrabbling for players on deadline day and it would come to nothing. I wasn't deceived by Barry's improvement during the close season. I forecast the wheels would fall off during October and we'd start looking over our shoulder. I don't want to be proven right but we all see patterns at Everton which just continue. It's one false dawn after another.
We have the makings of a decent side but we have two centre backs who are past it and too error prone. Another centre back who is quality but is never fit. No good fullbacks and, crucially, nobody who can put the ball in the net. We haven't had one of those for about 10 years. With those limitations we will never be where we aspire to be.
Moyes will probably keep us in the division and that is the sum of our ambition until we get genuine wealthy backers who are interested in getting us back to the top of the game and not just using us a play-thing to earn a quick buck.
26/10/2026 17:41:05
Jerome ( 38)
absolutely !
Also a site where posters remain respectful, of one and others arguments, without getting personal.. We are all Evertonians and want only the best for our Club.
UTFT!
26/10/2026 17:58:20
ha ha well adapted jack ! I doubt if blazing saddles would be made today !
tired of footie uninspired indeed. best not go near - springtime for h----r and germany !
26/10/2026 18:36:37
Cheers Phil@42.
One other comment from Madeleine, when meeting Teri Garr in Young Frenkenstein, that could also apply to The Board, Recruitment Team, and Management
What is it, that you actually, do, do ?
26/10/2026 18:49:18
Don 28. Memories of the Small Faces. Could it be that our team talks are delivered by Prof.Stanley Unwin ?
26/10/2026 19:39:03
jack we need a bit of gallows humour as evertonians - eases the agony
26/10/2026 20:38:52
Paul#41
For me all your posts followed that.Never will understand the criteria used. Enjoyed the Granny joke.Tech can be risky, especially autocorrect , which I hate.
Add Your Thoughts
Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.
Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.


25/10/2026 06:01:07
I had the house to myself for the afternoon yesterday. At one stage, I momentarily thought to pay for a day pass on Now T.V. A chance to watch and concentrate on an Everton game. Almost immediately, my reaction was no point. I just instinctively knew it would be another flat useless performance against a 'big team', another of this season's rubbish performances.
Instead I faffed about on the Internet for a couple of hours with some beer. Gilette soccer Saturday wad on in the background. It told me all I needed to know, and expect, from the game. I didn't, and still don't, feel upset or annoyed about the game. It's Everton, it's Moyes, it's the same old.