For years, Everton’s struggles and failures have been excused. How can they compete against such riches in the Premier League? How can the club attract players when we can’t offer European football? What more do you expect when the team has battled relegation and dealt with so many issues in recent times?

All the points made are relevant to certain degrees.

But football is a simple game.

And so it’s little surprise Everton beat Newcastle 3-1 to reach the League Cup quarter-finals on Thursday night when you look at the line-up.

Hayden Hackney started. Tyler Dibling started. Jake O’Brien started.

Everton won.

All three have been on the sidelines too often this season. So much so that a number of fans have called on David Moyes to give them a chance, questioning why they can’t get proper game-time?

Given an opportunity from the off and Hackney, Dibling and O’Brien helped the Blues get the job done.

Were they world beaters? No. Did they contribute and aid an improved showing? Yes.

It’s true, the squad is small. It lacks quality in certain areas. But Thursday evening emphasised that there are solutions. There was energy in the showing and a freshness to the play.

Everton aren’t going to win every game this season by simply picking the ‘right’ team supporters shout for down the pub and on social media. They may not win the League Cup. But making sound decisions when it comes to the starting eleven means that the campaign could be more productive and enjoyable than the opening months suggested.

Hackney, for instance, got a goal and an assist. Confidence will be high and another start on Monday must be granted to keep that feeling going. Build the momentum, set the positive narrative and watch the club thrive.

So often, the Blues have been up against it over the last decade as a mass of dysfunction curtailed any chance of progression. Just this summer, the owners have admitted they want out and the recruitment was horrendous, with gaping issues still so glaring.

However, the biggest problem that has most dented results, league standings and cup progress has been simple decision-making from the dugout.

Too often, the wrong choices have been made on matchday. Players who ship goals have started. Names who don’t offer enough have been preferred to those who dare try to make things happen. And veterans lacking match fitness have been given the nod over younger alternatives.

The outcome? The same as always. Poor performances, dropped points and a real malaise and feeling of boredom.

So many solutions stare Everton in the face and are missed. They weren’t missed tonight however.

Stick with Hackney. Keep the faith in Dibling. Back O’Brien at centre-back.

See where it takes us.


Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Jerome Shields
30/10/2026    06:29:31

Ell is right that Hackney, Dibling and O'Brien brought energy .All the reports and what I seen in highlights support this.

The deeper issue though is systemic. Moyes' reluctance to rotate has made Everton readable, and opponents now prepare for the same shapes and substitutions.

With SCR arriving and Everton already near 77% squad-cost ratio, rotation is also a financial necessity—fringe players must be sold and valuations protected. TFG's own signals about a "next chapter" suggest the club is being positioned for investment or sale, which raises the stakes on smart squad management now.

Sticking with Hackney is a start, but the broader test is whether Moyes can vary the formula week to week, protect the squad through injuries, and create the headroom for a later European push under whatever ownership and managerial structure follows.

2  Kieran Fitzgerald
30/10/2026    06:43:46

Jerome, do we have the luxury of fringe players right now? Not being sarcastic, it's a genuine question. Alcaraz maybe as he appears low enough down the pecking order in terms of minutes on the pitch. Apart from him, I honestly can't think of a player who isn't a necessity right now.

For me, the only option is to sell an asset for top dollar if we need to bulk up the squad with anything approaching quality.

3  Geoff Chaucer
30/10/2026    07:10:55

Dead right, Ell. Moyes’ problem is that he's got stuck in the mud. He doesn't seem to listen to anybody, take advice, hear new voices, explore new methods. I sometimes wonder what he talks about with AI and Baines. He’s become stubborn and closed-minded and mistakes that for being practical and hard-nosed.

4  Antony Abrahams
30/10/2026    07:46:17

It’s only one game, but like you have written Ell, it’s what the paying customers want to see.

I think it’s clear that Tyler Dibling, needs a run of games to feel part of it, because he his still playing safe and without real freedom, but he has got to be given the opportunity to play more because he has got loads of ability and could become a very good player for us once he gains more confidence and starts to play with more freedom.

Hackney, is a player, O’Brien, looks a lot better playing in his proper position, Rohl, still worries me defensively, but he definitely gives the team more pace and a lot more energy, and I think it was our energy levels, especially in transition, that were more noticeable last night👏👏

5  Christine Foster
30/10/2026    08:27:17

Having such a small squad the default position with Moyes is still keep it tight and nick one. As such we are predictable in team selection and tactics, that is of course when things out of his control force change. It was a good win last night, which I have to admit I was surprised at but thankful of. But we didn't dominate Newcastle we finished superbly. There were holes all over midfield were noone was a midfield general, we looked disjointed and although better in the second half, we conceded far too much in the middle. I never though how much I would miss the sheer tenacity of Gueye in the middle of the park.
But we won and won well, and unless Moyes bottles it we should make the semis ok. What a lift for the club that would be.

6  Jeff Armstrong
30/10/2026    08:34:38

The problem is Moyes won’t do what he should do, Monday night,stick with a winning team, go again.
Give those players belief and confidence by starting the same eleven, yes, maybe even keep Branthwaite on the bench if fit.
But Moyes knows better.

7  Jerome Shields
30/10/2026    09:00:17

Kieran#2

Agree Kieran, we don’t really have “fringe” players. The squad is about 18 outfield bodies, dropping to 16 with injuries, and Alcaraz is the only loose candidate given his limited minutes and fitness issues. Under SCR, with only £30–40m headroom and a likely net spend around £40–50m, selling an asset for top dollar isn’t a luxury,it’s the only realistic way to fund genuine squad quality. The debate is which asset, not whether.

8  Warney Creswell
30/10/2026    09:08:39

The manager continues to do an excellent job despite being thoroughly shafted during the two summer transfer windows he has been in charge, and being left with an absurdly small and unbalanced squad.

We are far from perfect. But we have a very committed, genuine, and in several instances a young group of players who are giving it a proper go.

Some clown was booing after 15 minutes last night.

Some of our fans - including some notable individuals on here - seem to actively enjoy being negative and talking the club down. They cannot wait to have a go. For us to fail so they can have their "I was right" moment. They revel in it and wouldn't have it any other way.

Whilst the team selection was a bit more progressive in possession - which is the only aspect fans tend to think about - the mid of Garner and Hackney (who I like but is frankly dodgy out of possession) was very, very open.

This, along with the two young wide lads (who were both lukewarm) and Rohl being the right back, resulted in us being very open and easy to play through. Newcastle had nearly 30 shots.

If a side consistently gives up that volume of shots and big chances there is usually only one outcome: it loses matches.

A better side than Newcastle - who have problems - would have punished us for being so open and easy to play through. Moyes would be wise to tweak things for the away fixture, which will no doubt trigger the usual suspects.

9  David Bromwell
30/10/2026    09:35:33

I was tempted not to go last night, transport difficulties getting to the ground, game on TV etc. But boy was I glad I did, it was a great game, certainly not school of science but a great performance of commitment, energy and flashes of skill from our much changed side. Yes our players made some mistakes but we were worthy of the win and it was a rare pleasure to watch them.
Rightly we should concentrate on two players who have seen too little football, namely Dibling and Hackney. This was the best I have seen from Dibling, and he showed flashes of how good he may become if he is given an extended run in the team. As for Hackney, he began all effort and lots of errors, but as he settled I thought he was tremendous, and as a result Garner had his best game of the season. Let's hope David Moyes keeps them together. I also thought Rohl, had by far his best game to date. He wasn't caught wandering, tackled well and used his speed and energy levels to good effect.
Overall it was a great night, and throughly enjoyable. Just one dark cloud that I have to mention, the missing Jack Grealish. Sick on Saturday ? And apparently dropped last night for disciplinary reasons ? Well Jack, that's NOT good enough, and I seem to remember you did the same last season. So it's a final warning from me, one more indiscretion and you can drive your flash car back to City, the one essential that we demand from our players is commitment, please note.

10  Benjamin Dyke
30/10/2026    09:37:18

I was made up last night when we got Hackney and Dibling in and generally agree with the headline here BUT I have to admit afterwards to feeling more sympathy towards Moyes as this was a long way from a simple victory. Newcastle had 26 shots, 11 on target! Moyes hinted afterwards that he's not so overawed with Hackney yet and I'm sure the same goes for the other players excepting perhaps the back line. We were so vulnerable the whole 90 minutes. Newcastle burned a large amount of pretty good chances and then Pickford and the back 4 rescued us on a good amount more. He would have hated that. I bet the 2-0 defeats to Chelsea and Arsenal gave him more satisfaction honestly! Before I would have said he's mad but after last night I get it.

11  Kevin Molloy
30/10/2026    11:11:39

I agree Christine, Gana is a big miss. Add that to Ndiaye and Jack on the slide and we are severely undercooked from last season, but we have the shrewd billionaires to thank for that.

And further on Grealish, if we end up 'taking a stand against' bad behaviour' and not picking him cos he's been a naughty boy, that represents another disastrous cock up for our crack recruitment team. His wages are mind-boggling, for us to be paying half a season while he sits on the sidelines (like last season!) would be negligence. No other proper clubs went near him, and now it looks like we are going to get our fingers burnt with him. Again.

12  Steve Brown
30/10/2026    11:23:09

Hackney, Rohl, Dibling and George are club signings, while KDH, Grealish, Johnston and Norgaard are likely Moyes signings.

So I wonder who he will select for the league game away to Newcastle? He should keep the same team and positive gameplan, but he will default to type.

Dibling out for Johnston, Hackney out for Armstrong and George only staying in the side due to Jack’s love of the top shelf.

13  John Raftery
30/10/2026    11:26:03

Warney (8) Absolutely spot on. As I said in the match report comments, goals change games. They also change the narrative. Against a team with better finishing we might well have fallen apart in the opening twenty minutes. We had no control whatsoever with our players struggling to impose themselves.

As Christine says we were so disjointed with gaps in midfield where we are certainly missing Gana Gueye’s industry. Finding a balanced approach in midfield will be vital if the team is to attain the consistency required in the top half of the Premier League. That may well come down to Hackney or Armstrong or Nørgaard (eventually) being rotated between and within matches.

14  Jeff Armstrong
30/10/2026    12:42:24

Cannot understand why Nørgaard is not being brought up to fitness in the Under 21’s, surely that is much more competitive than training.

15  Antony Abrahams
30/10/2026    13:20:52

I really liked Gana Gueye, but anyone who tells me there wasn’t many big gaps in the midfield, when he played there was definitely watching a different game to me.

The team, hasn’t been set up properly for years imo. We get it right sometimes but I’m often not sure that the players are on the same page covering around and protecting each other the way they should defensively?

We won, we scored three goals against Premier League opposition, and two of those goals were scored because we were very quick in transition.

Concentrating on the positives, I’d sooner see us playing quick in transition, because I think it will help us win more games, although because I don’t think we defend as a team properly, this will probably mean that we will also suffer a few bigger defeats

I’d personally take that to see progress. Win some, lose some but concentrate on trying to play quicker and with more partnerships developing throughout the team, but to do this would mean that the manager would have to move away from what has stood him in good stead over many years, even though it hasn’t won him many prizes.


16  Mike Allison
30/10/2026    13:30:13

As always with Moyes, there’s plenty that’s done well with that nagging feeling that it could be better.

Yes, it’s a small squad, but is that because last season we had a small squad and he still didn’t use everyone? If you’re the one counting the purse-strings then the calculation would seem to make sense. Why buy an Aznou, Dibling or other young talent when you know the manager won’t use them?

Moyes has got the squad he wanted, minus the extra striker as the Balogun deal was intended to go through. The rest of the complaining about a small squad is disingenuous from him as he could have used 5-6 players far more often last season and didn’t.

17  David Bromwell
30/10/2026    14:02:22

Come on everybody, watching Everton under David Moyes is generally boring, last night was a crazy game which we so easily could have lost, but we won ! And boy did I enjoy the game, there was hardly a dull moment. So I would be happy if that was the way we approached games in the future. It's clear our young players lack experience and they will only get better if they are played regularly.

Young Barry is a very good example, still raw and frustrating, but he is leading the line on his own, he generally keeps going and as last night he was rewarded with a well taken goal. I expect Mondays game will be feisty, and we will need to be careful, the referee will have been pre warned. Hopefully Branthwaite will start but I see no need to change the rest.

18  Robert Tressell
30/10/2026    14:27:15

Warney # 8, I'm with you with a lot of this. I am not sure why we cannot just applaud the side for navigating a difficult tie in a cup competition we traditionally do very badly in.

We don't have a very good squad but there are signs that a decent team is emerging - although it is desperately in need of quality reinforcements. You make a good point that is not just a question of selection or "letting the handbrake" off - because across a league season we would ship a lot more goals and probably lose a lot more matches.

I'll finish with a shout out for Thierno Barry. He is by no means a top class striker but he's now got 7 goals in 11 games this season. He is second only to Haaland in League & Cup goals this season.

Plenty to improve upon, of course, but that is really good going for such a cheap signing. He is not a natural and has had to work his way up from a very low standard to get where he is.

19  Raymond Fox
30/10/2026    15:03:25

I was critical of our lack of goals before the game so 3 was a bit of a shock. A good one and a win, I don't think it was as comfortable 3-1 though, they had 2 or 3 other decent chances.
Dewsbury-Hall was all over the field once more, he has some battery. Myko and Rohl also did well.
I don't think Hackney or Dibling played that well, OK Hackney scored and assisted another but apart from that I was a little disappointed with his general play. Harsh to could say but thats how I saw it.
Dibling still appears afraid to lose the ball, whether thats Moyes influence, who knows.
Barry took his goal very well, but he's generally starved of many chances.

20  Antony Abrahams
30/10/2026    18:54:21

I’ve just had a similar conversation with regards people just being happy that we won Robert, when talking to my dad about last nights game.

He said that some people have been saying that it has put to bed the argument about who is the better player out of Hackney and Armstrong, when we should actually just be glad that we have got both of these very good young players.

I think you know my answer already Robert!

21  Mike Allison
31/10/2026    14:41:42

I think everyone is happy that we won. The issue is more that we’ve played really poorly or dropped points in other games where we’d have had more chance of the manager had made better decisions.

We have a small squad due to poor management during the summer, wherever the blame for that lies. However, we also don’t make the most of the resources at our disposal, and fans come out of nearly every game with a clear idea that something should have been done differently.

Team selection and substitutions are the most visible part of football management and most Evertonians can see that Moyes could be doing both of them better. Against Newcastle on Thursday, he got closer to what most fans would do and we put in our best performance. This is where all the frustration comes from.


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.