So it turns out where there was smoke there was also fire.

It’s unfortunate that news of a player missing due to being sick can be greeted with widespread scepticism and one’s mind immediately turning to the Jennifer Lawrence “ok” meme, but that was the case last Saturday when Jack Grealish’s absence from Everton’s travelling party to the Emirates Stadium was explained away by illness.

It might have been quickly forgotten and left to the wither on the Merseyside grapevine had the Club not been moved to confirm, prior to last night’s clash with Newcastle, that the player had been left out of the squad for the Carabao Cup tie as well due to a “breach of club discipline”.

It has since emerged that Grealish failed to show up for more than one training session. Everton would not have taken lightly the decision to release that information publicly but it was, no doubt, necessary to demonstrate that the Club takes these matters seriously and that no one is bigger than the rest of the squad.

David Moyes told the press in his post-match press conference last night that he supports the decision (he deferred all further questions regarding the issue to the hierarchy) but he must surely be angry at a player he pushed to bring to Everton and whose presence is needed in what is a painfully small squad.

The Club simply cannot afford — in a figurative and almost literal sense — for Grealish to go missing. Moyes has just 18 senior outfield players at his disposal; the loss of Jarrad Branthwaite to concussion protocols and Grealish’s transgressions dropped that number to 16 for the games against Arsenal and the Magpies. (Vitalii Mykolenko was forced off with injury during the second half at the Emirates which took another piece off the proverbial chessboard but, thankfully, he was fit to return last night.)

Just as importantly, at a time of Squad Cost Ratio considerations and with The Friedkin Group cinching the purse strings tight, the Blues have no room to accommodate a bit-part player who, on the basis of last season’s figures, is costing them more than £12m to have on loan from Manchester City with no resale value on the other end.

Everton have put an enormous amount of faith and capital into borrowing Grealish and, for the most part, the 31-year-old repaid that last season in assists, a couple of important goals and some exciting performances before he was struck down with a long-term injury in January.

His decision to undergo his rehabilitation at Finch Farm for as long as his loan terms would allow before returning to City, combined with his genuine affection for the Toffees and the supporters, was seemingly an acknowledgment of those sacrifices and a reflection of how at home he felt at Finch Farm and Bramley-Moore Dock.

Sadly, it’s those closest to you who are often the easiest ones to disappoint and let down and that is what Grealish has done this week. It will be confusing for those younger Evertonians who proudly wear his name and numbers on the backs of their replica shirts to whom he is a role model, given that his suspension comes in the same week as he generously donated £10,000 towards the medical treatment of a Blues fan battling cancer.

Where this situation goes now is really up to Jack but it’s hard not to feel at least hugely disappointed or incredibly angry at his actions. He has reportedly returned to training today and it remains to be seen whether he is included in Monday’s squad for the re-match with the Barcodes at St James’ Park, either as a substitute or, less likely, as a starter.

You would imagine, though, that he is going to be afforded very little latitude from here on out in terms of his conduct and that Everton will have clauses in their loan arrangement with Manchester City to terminate the deal should he continue to step out of line.

That would be a very sad outcome for one of the most gifted players of his generation who has achieved it all (asterisks from the forthcoming Premier League censure of City notwithstanding) and earned 39 caps for his country. Should he fail to be integrated back into Enzo Maresca’s plans at the Etihad Stadium, he risks being frozen out from the game he so clearly loves.

Again, what happens next is very much up to him. Everton, meanwhile, should be applauded for holding him to account while also giving him all the support he needs should his own personal demons be at the heart of this latest episode in what has been a colourful career.

Everton need him for numbers. They also need his talent if he can recapture his best form. They can’t afford a passenger when the team is so short on numbers and they have an eye on the January transfer window when transfer funds will, one would imagine, again be in short supply.


Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Kevin Molloy
30/10/2026    14:33:21

Everyone is rightly in a good mood after last night, but the Grealish thing is another big issue we could have done without. Him missing Monday then throws the excuse about missing Arsenal in a new light. Suddenly we are looking at a player going awol for days and days. Ian Herbert who is usually pretty good reveals Moyes had big concerns about bringing him back this year, but the idiot Friedkins felt they needed a bone to throw the baying crowd, and here we are. He's not looked right since he got back, and now that he's made himself unselectable for the last two games, you would have to think that the club's relationship with him is at or near breaking point. So with our wafer thing squad, our 'best player' is now another name we cannot rely upon.

We'll have handed over the best part of thirty million quid to City, and what do we have to show for it...

2  Kevin Molloy
30/10/2026    16:01:33

I fear it's a bit late for that Paul. City are already out of the blocks with 'he's an Everton player' just this afternoon. We could end up in the worst of all worlds, forced to keep paying his wages but not wanting to play him.

3  Robert Tressell
30/10/2026    16:14:41

What has Grealish actually done? Seems to be (unsubstantiated?) suggestions that he's missed training and been fined / removed from the squad.

If so, very disappointing from him.

The big issue with a player like this - inevitably on a downward trajectory after become surplus to requirements at a Champions League giant - is whether they are (a) fit and (b) arsed.

Last season, he appeared to have kept himself in good knick and was very much arsed when on the pitch. I don't think he had any misdemeanours either (but others may correct me).

I'm not really sure of his physical state this season but it's fair to say he hasn't started as strongly as last season. George is raw but seems to offer more in the same sort of position.

It'd be sad if he's now finished for us because it's both a waste of money and waste of talent. He does still have a lot to offer provided he can find the motivation.

4  Kevin Molloy
30/10/2026    18:32:56

Great article Lyndon, it's a pickle alright.

5  Paul Conway
30/10/2026    19:07:21

The backstory to this will be revealed soon enough, as it usually is.

Not a good time to have discord in the Camp and certainly not a good time to be playing on a Monday night.

It could well cause a psychological disadvantage, if the Teams who are 2, or 3 points behind us, get very favourable results.

We could well find ourselves in familiar territory.

I don’t think Spurs could have a better opportunity, to leapfrog us, as they are Home to Palace, a Team that have shipped the most goals, at this relatively early stage.

6  Philip Sheehan
30/10/2026    19:46:09

stupid, childish and selfish...go and wait outside the headmasters office...if as kevin says it was friedkins harebrained idea to bring him back then thats another financial own goal by these shit hot hard nosed businessmen bringing JG back is the sort of thing the teary one would have done and made a big pr photoshoot of it and taking all the credit for it too !
if there is a chance to chuck away millions you can bet everton will find it...
cancel his contract, cancel the standing order paying him way too much a week and re-direct him back to man.cheaty via the m62

7  Warney Creswell
30/10/2026    19:48:46

In my opinion, he is an absolute shadow of the player he used to be.

His career stalled and nosedived after he went on that three day bender when City won the treble (I think).

Still got the talent but his physical decline is pronounced. He lumbers around the pitch like a 34yr old, consistently slowing the play down. It frequently results in samey play that is always in front of teams.

If he wasn't called Jack Grealish and was just a random european attacking mid, no one would particularly be blown away. He'd be regarded as a tidy and talented player but nothing special.

8  Antony Abrahams
30/10/2026    20:05:21

An arl-arse who still knows how to play football, but is unfortunately no longer quick enough to get away from his opponent, which means his best attribute is now just being able to draw a foul.

They say you never lose it. Until the body starts slowing down, is how I see it.

He’s only 31, I’m sure he could still have a final swan song, but first he’s got to find the motivation, otherwise he simply won’t be playing top level football, much longer.

Retire in the summer Jack, win a trophy with Everton first, and then you will be able to spend the rest of your life getting drunk and reminiscing about it with us Evertonians…Do you really need anymore motivation than that!!

9  Lee Courtliff
30/10/2026    22:20:08

I didn't see a physical decline in him this season, it was more just 'ring rust' after a long injury lay-off.

But this news is very disappointing, you'd think at 31 years of age he'd be far more focused on maximising the last few years of his top level playing career. Unfortunately this could be another Paul Gascoigne situation developing, I certainly hope not as Jack has always come across very well and is clearly a decent person.

I wish him well, he's quite possibly got far bigger battles in the future than simply trying to win his place back in a football team.

10  David Bromwell
30/10/2026    22:29:14

I am sorry but I did not believe the tale that Grealish was too sick to be included in the team to play Arsenal. We were lucky last season when the Club took a gamble to loan him, and that gamble largely paid off. Although I do recall him being 'sick' and missing for at least one game. I thought the Club were wrong to take another gamble and loan him for a further season.

He is obviously a flawed and complicated character, and his continued presence in our small squad will likely lead to further issues. If we have a choice I would simply tell him that one further serious indiscretion will result in his contract being terminated. With a small squad of players team spirit will be important, and it cannot be good if your best paid player is unable to abide by team discipline.

11  Jerome Shields
30/10/2026    23:13:15

I think he should be gone.The signs are there and probably have been for a while.I don't believe Moyes was not involved in his signing.I don't believe that TFG where involved, other than what you would expect.

Everton with a tight squad cannot afford an unreliable player and he will not be up to speed to play with the younger players..

Football is littered with such players that lose their way.Grealush had lost his way.

12  Mike Gaynes
30/10/2026    00:00:52

No, Grealish should not be "gone" -- Lyndon is correct that the club cannot afford to lose him.

Yes, he has let his club and teammates down, inexcusably so, but the resolution to the situation is not to make a critically undersized squad even smaller by terminating him.

We have 12 games in less than nine weeks before the January window opens, and we need all hands on deck to get through it.

13  Jerome Shields
31/10/2026    00:11:03

Mike he will be gone anyway.Those were important games he missed and he was on huge wages to at least present himself for them.

He is slower since the injury and he will be slower still the way he is carrying on.

14  Nicolas Piñon
31/10/2026    00:31:45

So we are now ready to call Grealish “The fool on the Hill?” LOL

15  Don Alexander
31/10/2026    02:58:58

Grealish has an irrefutable history of being a piss-artist. Yes, he's been noted for dispensing a small fraction of his mega income to good causes given his family circumstances (and I'm confident many, many other professional Premier League footballers also donate to tax-dispensable charities) but our own Mr Ridge presciently queried, when he was re-loaned by us, what Grealish meant when he said he was happy to do so given the lack of pressure he perceived he'd be subjected to by signing for us at all.

WHAT THE FUCK??!!!!

Does he want to inherit the legacy of a useless Van de Meyde or, just briefly successful, Kanchelskis?

Not much of a question for anyone still purporting to be a conscientious professional footballer is it, or not?

16  Kieran Fitzgerald
31/10/2026    06:45:10

It will depend on what clauses are in the contract. We may have to limp along until the January window, but if there are still issues then, and we can get rid, then he may well be gone. Until then, I think Grealish has us over a barrel, as we need him more than he needs us.

I think it was stupid to give him a second go in the summer. It was also lazy and had an air of desperation about it.

I would agree with Jerome in that I think Grealishs head has gone. He has lost interest. If City had kept him on at the start of the season, perhaps he would have gotten a second wind. We were likely a poor second choice for him and his mood has gotten everyone to this week.

17  Jerome Shields
31/10/2026    07:32:17

Kieran#16

That is basically the true situation. Another factor is that Grealish has bullshited Moyes and Moyes now knowing it, has had to act.

The whole Grealish thing since the injury and probably before has been a parallel farce,which has now come into the open.Everton could never afford this as they supposedly are battling the financial constraints they are under.

He really has to be gone as soon as possible, so proper injury recovery back up is in place for the New Year. Depending on Grealish is not a option.

Actually Grealish should be heading down his own recovery path.Maybe the only good thing is that there may be talk of that.

18  Robert Tressell
31/10/2026    09:22:14

Does anyone know what has actually happened - ie why he missed the training session(s)?

19  Jerome Shields
31/10/2026    09:59:28

Robert he has been disciplined.He was not listening to the Manager or Club.

20  Mike Owen
31/10/2026    10:15:15

Circumstances, details and backstories are different, but I can't help wondering if there are echoes of Dele Alli here.

However, I believe the situation with Grealish is far more recoverable.

I do wonder if he is a bit bored, being stuck on the wing. If I was manager, I would try him centrally, next to the target man, a certain M.Keane. Bring Barry on as sub.

Either way, I think Grealish still has plenty to offer us. And with his cavalier nature, I see plenty of scope for him to be an anti-hero this season in a cup-winning Everton squad.

21  Frank Sheppard
31/10/2026    10:18:06

I am hoping for clear the air, it’s behind us from player and club statements.

Hope he becomes available, and we start 4 or 5 games with George on the left, with Grealish coming on after an hour.

22  Robert Tressell
31/10/2026    10:43:04

Jerome # 19 - I think that means you don't know what he's actually done either (i.e. why he missed the training session(s)). No-one does!

This is what David Moyes has said:

"It's something I don't really want to speak too much about. It's a club decision, so I support the decision."

"The club are the people you should go to if you're looking for more information."

This seems to be Moyes aligning himself with a club decision about Grealish's treatment - and then distancing himself from the situation.

23  Raymond Fox
31/10/2026    11:00:34

He could have been sick only he knows the truth, he could have played the sickness card again when he missed training.
We all get ill or simply not feeling well for reasons unknown.

He will have been given a stern warning not to miss training again so if he has any sense at all he will behave himself.

When you have been earning the money he has been for a long time now I would imagine it's very easy to go off the rails sometimes.
Just imagine.

I think he will have got the message and behave himself for the rest of the season, we definitely need a fit Grealish.

24  Antony Abrahams
31/10/2026    11:52:04

Do you really think that Robert, that it is a club decision which the manager has aligned himself to?

It really does seem crazy to think that it isn’t the manager who is in charge of such a decision to begin with, because it is him and his squad of players that have been let down the most.

25  Robert Tressell
31/10/2026    12:13:17

Antony - I don't know. It depends why he missed the training session.

Clubs tend to act when there are reputational things afoot like domestic violence, sexual assault and drugs. Hopefully that's not the case here.

Equally, I am not sure what Moyes has to gain from positioning it as a club decision. It might mean there is more to it. It might mean he's trying to protect Jack. It might mean (as is often the case with press conferences generally) he's talking rubbish.

Like I say, none of us know.

26  Noleen Daya
31/10/2026    12:14:10

I said at the start of this season we should NOT take him back! He is a serial problem-child. I don't give a stuff about talent if players can't be responsible and be professional. We have enough bloody dramas without him adding to it.

27  Paul Conway
31/10/2026    13:08:06

Professional footballers are under contract to contact the Club Doctor, when they fall ill, for whatever reason.. even the slightest cold.

This is so the Doctors can access them.
it’s the protocol and to avoid viruses spreading throughout the Squad.

Jack obviously didn’t follow the protocol and said he was “sick”.
Obviously miffing Moyes to the max and causing conjecture among fans.
I would imagine that the Honeymoon period is now over.

28  Jerome Shields
31/10/2026    13:12:25

Robert#25

It has already put out that Moyes was not keen having him back and TFG insisted Grealish was signed on Loan.He is trying with that recent statement to distance himself and put the blame on someone else.

The fact Moyes has last say on who comes in means he agreed.He is the one Managing instructing and coaching him.

29  Jeff Armstrong
31/10/2026    13:39:03

First I’ve heard about Moyes not wanting him back.

30  Steve Brown
31/10/2026    14:09:44

Robert @ 25, no-one on here has a clue why he missed training.

But a few posters are writing as though they spent the last 2 weeks sat on his living room sofa.

31  John Houghton
31/10/2026    14:27:01

Bringing Grealish back a second time was another lazy, sentiment based decision which made little sense, either from a footballing or financial point of view.

Extremely likeable character, great with the youngsters, no doubt. But not reasons to hand somebody a huge contract.

If the terms of the contract allow it, suggest we end the arrangement in January and invest the funds elsewhere.

32  Mike Gaynes
31/10/2026    19:25:50

First time I've ever agreed with Steve Brown on anything. I must have a mysterious illness myself.

Jerome #28, no such thing has been "put out" anywhere. In fact all reporting has been the opposite, that Moyes pushed for his return over internal management concerns at the club.

33  Jerome Shields
31/10/2026    20:43:31

That's your opinion.There will be open season on reports and counter reports and those inside the Club trying to influence the narrative .

Grealish has been disciplined.He is news and not careful.

I actually never believed it to be true and said so .But that what you get with influencing narratives.

34  Jon Atkinson
02/11/2026    17:49:47

absent from the squad tonight as well, he won’t be leading any assists table this season

35  Paul Conway
02/11/2026    18:29:59

john ( 34)
when I first rapidly scanned your post, I thought you said..” Well, He won’t be leaning on any table for assists this Season !”

36  Derek Thomas
06/11/2026    01:54:30

Not in the Squad / unavailable for selection for Coventry.
What does this actually mean?
He's still 'hors de combat'?

Or, is he in the short term, at least 'over'...you're never truly over the internal reasons - thats long term...what ever bender he was on and he's working on getting fully...as far as you can...fit for 90mins.

Yes there's privacy concerns but The Trappist Monk Faction in our so call Communications Dept. seem to have gained the upper hand for now.

A simple "he's receiving treatment for an unspecified Illness" aka, he starting the sobering up process...if indeed he is.

Or,
"We expect him to 'be back on the grass' later this week" aka, he more or less there and he'll be reassessed in 2 or 3 weeks.

Hint; like the Iceland situation, hoping it will all go away if you don't say word one is not the way to go.

37  David Abrahams
13/11/2026    09:56:53

Well Grealish is back at the club— made his apologies to everyone and is ready to resume playing for the club—- all well and good but is he going to any better than he has been since he came to the club—- for me he has done nowhere enough to be a ready selection and it would have been better if we had found a way to get him back to the club who couldn’t wait to get rid of him and the huge wages they were paying him with so little in return and I think Everton are in the boat that City let sail.

38  Robert Tressell
13/11/2026    11:54:26

It’s a strange thread, this - since it still seems like no-one actually knows what happened.

Whatever the case it looks like it has largely been resolved. He’s our player for the season - so good luck to him.

He may yet have a big positive impact although it is nice to see George developing in that LW spot.

39  Peter Fancy
13/11/2026    11:55:17

Seem to be doing alright without him so far…

40  Kevin Molloy
13/11/2026    18:41:25

I don't think you have to be Hercule Poirot to put together what happened Robert. He's got plenty of form for going on benders and disappearing for days. And he looks like he's drying out the whole time.

41  Philip Sheehan
13/11/2026    23:03:53

as I put on the now awful TW - we should be able to send him back immediately but the fuckwits in our recruitment team don;t check the small print and seem to sign anything thats put in front of them - ok we have the smallest squad - his wages/etc could and should have been used to buy a full back or forward. anyway why are we surprised or annoyed its just another in a long, long list of everton cock ups !

42  Steve Brown
14/11/2026    08:06:49

Mike @ 32, don’t fight it.

You might end up being right occasionally.

44  Derek Thomas
18/11/2026    02:22:10

Alway assuming he's back and ready to go from where ever he's been...warm weather training in the middle east has been mentioned.

I myself would prefer that he was out in some far corner of Finch Farm being put through the training wringer on the cold November weather - character building.
You play in it - you train in it!

What I dread though, is Moyes running true to his usually cautious nature...on the bench for Brentford, in the starting 11 over George for The Derby, due to his vast experience of 'big games'

All forgiven of course if he plays a defining part in a famous victory.

He may even get (for a good reason) a Derby named after him?

Nah, Roy of the Rovers fairytale stuff that.


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.