I’ve gone into my bunker of late. I find media coverage of Everton— well football as an overall — just exhaustive. Everything is micro-reported. The slight mishap or slip of the tongue by a player in an interview or a pundit leaves them widely mocked and ridiculed. Anything that’s said or done sends people into a spin on X and is then shared amongst WhatsApp groups the world over for more private ridicule. I’ve gone "cold turkey" and find myself distancing from the football social media world.

Take this Deadline Day as an example. In years gone by I’d have been there in the evening desperately and repeatedly refreshing my X feed in the hope of some positive Everton news. This week I found myself doing that for a few minutes and thought to myself “why is this so important I need to know this right now? Just find out in the morning.” And so I put my phone down, read a book and went to sleep.

Which brings us nicely — or not so nicely — on to Everton. When I awoke, the Everton WhatsApp groups that I’m in were full of messages; the first few words of the most recent ones didn’t look good, and so I went on X and scrolled back from the top. Messages like “Heads must roll for this” and “total incompetence” dominated the timeline for the Everton accounts I do still follow, until I finally got to the news that Folarin Balogun had walked away from Everton, declining to sign his contract.

So a player walked away from us at the final hour leaving us a striker short having let one go. Other things, too, were handled badly in the window which have been done to death by others and don’t need to be regurgitated. But is it life and death? Is it worth getting so upset about?

I’m not a young man; maybe it’s a change in outlook from me, but I find it all so tiresome. I love Everton. I love going to the game, I’ll keep on going home and away, but I just can’t get worked up about these things anymore. If we win, I’m stoked. If we lose, OK, it sucks but it doesn’t ruin my day… well maybe it does against certain opponents but generally it doesn’t, and it shouldn’t.

I’m actually quite positive about how we will do this season now the transfer window has “slammed shut”.

Do you remember when Mikel Arteta was sold to Arsenal on deadline day with no replacement brought in, just a couple of lads on loan in Denis Stracqualursi and Royston Drenthe? Well, David Moyes had to find a way with what he had, and I back him to do it again. He’s been mopey at best, disillusioned at worst, but I feel that David is actually at his best when he has to find a way with what he’s got. He’ll rally his troops and hopefully gather a siege mentality once the dust settles on our transfer window.

What makes me more positive is that we’ll now surely get to see a bit more of some of the talented fringe players we have at our disposal. We’ll get to see more of Tyler Dibling, Merlin Röhl and Charlie Alcaraz. Brennan Johnson will get games and minutes up front. Thierno Barry has a great opportunity to carry on his decent start to the season. Yes, we will miss Iliman Ndiaye, a great player, but we all knew he was leaving.

Really, we knew we were going to get Jack Grealish one way or the other. If he can stay fit we know what we’re getting there. We also have real quality in James Garner, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Tyrique George, Jarred Branthwaite, Jake O’Brien, Hayden Hackney, Harrison Armstrong, Jordan Pickford and, of course, Christan Norgaard is still to come in. We’ve enough adaptability in our attacking players to get by, until January at least.

I’m concerned about full-back, I’ll give you that. Ainsley Maitland-Niles is a good signing for my money, but only if we’d got a bona fide right back also. As that way Ainsley could provide cover and competition on both full back positions and even cover in midfield should we need it. But without said right back we are very short on cover. Expect ongoing square pegs in round holes there, unfortunately.

I’m not saying it’s the transfer window anybody wanted because it clearly isn’t, but it’s not worth losing our minds over either. Demanding people lose their jobs isn’t really nice. They may have got it wrong. They may be out of their depth, I don’t know, but I can’t imagine they aren’t trying their best.

And as for Folarin Balogun: Having sold Beto, obviously having his replacement walking out on us last-minute isn’t ideal and leaving things so late in the day is one of football’s great mysteries I’ll never understand. We weren’t the only ones; far from it in fact. Though if a player doesn’t want to play for us, we’re better not having that player than having him here and unhappy and wanting out in a year’s time anyway. A bad signing is worse than no signing; we haven’t forgotten Neal Maupay already, have we?

If the owners and the board have anything about them they’ll lick their wounds and already be working on supporting David and the team in the next window. And a riled David is an angry one. He’ll be working them players relentlessly and planning diligently for each game. He’ll have that fire back in his eyes and the team scrapping for every ball.

You’ll see.

Read More


Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Lee Courtliff
05/09/2026    03:10:35

I agree, the full back positions and lack of striker cover are obvious causes for concern, but we have versatile players.

And I too am looking forward to seeing more of Dibling, Alcaraz, etc. I just hope David uses his 5 subs regularly and rotates who plays 90 minutes each week.

2  Paul Conway
05/09/2026    08:53:18

Jam Tomorrow!

3  John Collins
05/09/2026    09:10:58

I will be positive Paul.
As long as David follows suit.

4  Robert Tressell
05/09/2026    09:36:08

Paul, it's a good article and I had a similar go at raising the positivity in the article about Roma.

However, all of this requires fans to wait for completion of a rebuild from a truly disastrous state on and off the pitch.

What most fans really want, is winning football now.

That is why big talk from owners goes down well. That is why daft vanity signings like Dele Alli and James Rodriguez tend to go down well. It helps to create the illusion of a "big club".

Contrast that with the continued appointment of Moyes, sale of Ndiaye and a series of low cost signings in the "Coventry City" price bracket and we still have that "small club" look and feel (despite a magnificent new stadium).

But the reality is that the 7 low cost signings made all look astute (although I'll reserve judgement on Maitland-Niles as I haven't seen him play for ages). Had the Balogun deal completed as expected, it would have looked like a good window - giving us a chance to compete for a European place with (probably) Newcastle, Villa, Brentford, Brighton and Forest.

The failed Balogun deal - and the Burnley compensation - have probably set us back a season (although I suppose there remains a chance to resolve both things favourably in January).

So it is not so much that the future looks bleak, it's just that is remains emotionally exhausting to support Everton in the present.

5  Kieran Fitzgerald
05/09/2026    11:14:41

Lee, the general consensus for the collapse last season was that Moyes hadn't rotated the players enough over the course of the seadon. The result was burn out, we ran out of steam. A smaller squad this season, but better rotation might stand to us. Would still like to see money spent in January.

Robert, like it or not, the 40m Burnley money has to be factored into how the summer window went. Kick in the pants alright.

6  Kieran Fitzgerald
05/09/2026    11:27:48

Robert, you mention the vanity signings. It's amazing how the transfer window in it's entirety has changed my view on Grealish. If played in the right position, and to his strengths as a thirty year old, his value to the squad has multiplied in my view. A couple of ifs I know, but necessity and all that.

7  Jerome Shields
05/09/2026    11:41:05

The positive outcome is :

That TFG will be forced to Manage,

Moyes will be forced to play the younger players

Kinnear will have to plan more what he does so that he does not misspeak,which is his tendency.

Augus you will not get away the same as behind the counter at KFC, even though many think you are a Bargain Bucket.

The Friedkins only came to the fore when faced with a crisis at Roma.Well they now have a crisis at Everton,which could be a good thing.

8  Bobby Thomas
05/09/2026    13:19:18

Watching PNE vs Blackburn, and on first watch, am surprised the Blackburn right back Ryan Alebiosu was not mentioned as an option this summer.

Tallish, pacey, comfortable on the ball (looks quite two footed), and likes to get forward. He's 24 and has recently made the Nigeria squad.

Internet research suggests that Brentford, West Ham, and Rangers were linked in the summer for around £8m.

9  Robert Tressell
05/09/2026    13:39:26

Alebiosu was one of the many RBs linked to us too, Bobby. The links to us started in January.

10  Kieran Fitzgerald
05/09/2026    15:53:54

More game time for more players means fewer annoyed and frustrated players. A tighter knit unit.

Lee, a huge chance for Alcaraz. I liked what I saw two seasons ago.

11  Bobby Thomas
05/09/2026    16:26:45

Robert #11

I missed his name being mentioned, but yes, he appears to have been linked in January and May at least. Looks decent.

12  John Fitzgerald
05/09/2026    16:36:43

Hard to see where they’re going to get a decent CF from in January. Happy to be proven wrong, but quality ones only become available in summer windows.

13  David Catton
05/09/2026    18:03:52

A way out?

If Spurs buy out Richie's contract, does that make him a free agent? In which case, could Everton make him an offer that met his financial needs? Presumably there'd be no transfer fee?

14  John Fitzgerald
05/09/2026    19:58:12

I think you can't sign a player as a free agent if they weren't a free agent when the previous window closed. Arsenal made sure to get rid of Aubameyang by terminating his contract on the final day of the window in 2022.

15  John Chambers
05/09/2026    20:34:43

Here is a reason to be positive, a list of the squad 25 or under Branthwaite 24, O’Brien 25, Garner 25, Hackney 24, Armstrong 19, Rohl 24, George 20, Johnson 25, Alcaraz 23, Dibling 20, Barry 23. Whilst I’m still to be convinced by the last 3 this is a nucleus of a good young squad.
It’s a big if but IF we can find the funds to keep this group together and build on it over the next couple of windows we should have a squad competing for Europe.

And talking of being positive I think everyone getting behind the team tomorrow is pretty important as well. The fiasco of the window is nothing to do with those on the pitch, and little to do with Moyes, so lets give the team all our support tomorrow

16  Mike Doyle
05/09/2026    20:57:49

Nice to hear a positive take on recent proceedings Paul - and I hope you’ll be posting some of your match reports during the season (they have been missed).

17  Andy McNabb
05/09/2026    00:05:53

Welcome back, Paul. Wise words for us all. Since leaving Toffeeweb when it went mad, I don’t think I’ve heard from you.

I am also hoping for your measured match reports this season. Only get back for a game every few years and like the much-missed Danny and Ken’s reports, they make me feel like I’m there.

18  Paul Swan
06/09/2026    09:55:46

I find myself avoiding more and more media around football these days as most of it is just senseless noise but it seems to give a platform to the loudmouths to offload about any issue and get it blown up into a crisis to fit their own conspiracy theories or narrative. This guy Balogun sounds like he is trouble and either him or Monaco or more likely both were hiding something. Whilst it is criminal to let our only other ‘recognised’ striker leave before a replacement was tied down, would we ever have been happy with another season of Barry replacing Beto and Beto replacing Barry rinsed and repeated week in week out? The way the cards have fallen Moyes now is forced to try something different and we will see who will stand up and be counted. The Friedkin ownership is a battle for another day but for now we’ve just got to get behind what we have on the pitch and build up some positivity because toxicity and recrimination will kill us.

19  Paul Jones
06/09/2026    09:57:43

I think the highlighting of Arteta's last minute move to Arsenal way back in 2011 (I had to check the date!) is problematic here.

Why? Because here we are 15 years later in a worse position with regards to squad numbers. I think we can accept that the quality of the players we have now is better than it was back then, but the quality of every team in the premier league is much better too. We've got a lovely new stadium now - yes - but as last season showed it's yet to deliver any competitive advantage to us on the pitch.

So as one of many who felt we were badly run during Kenwright's rein, the only conclusion I can draw is we're being run by an even worse regime now.

It's impossible to remain positive when we're stuck with Moyes (again, I would have preferred him to have gone too, but that was before that dreadful transfer window) playing cagey football with a vastly depleted bench, just a single injury away from an existential crisis.

20  Mike Iddon
06/09/2026    10:07:11

I agree wholeheartedly with Paul's sentiments in this article, it's extraordinary the hyperbole around football these days. If this is a crisis I dread to think what it was when we were bottom of the league. just get behind the team.

21  John Collins
06/09/2026    11:14:05

Paul 18,

What gave you the impression Balogun sounds like he is trouble?

22  Paul Swan
06/09/2026    18:08:42

John 21, second hand I know but I heard he was one of the most arrogant members of the US squad at the World Cup and then to walk away from signing leaving both his present and future clubs in a mess screams problem to me.

23  John Collins
06/09/2026    23:16:12

Thanks Paul

24  Neil Cremin
06/09/2026    17:38:24

Well written Paul

Great to read a positive report based on the age old saying “We are where we are”

The weaknesses in the squad are clearly identified but so are the strengths. And what is most important is that the team needs our continued support despite the disappointment of the transfer window. Kneejerk reaction gain nothing, a1111nother old saying ‘“No point in cutting off your nose to spite your face”

The thread is a breath of fresh air and m1akes a difference from TW where the every thread turns into a mostly anti but some defenders of Moyes debate led by the main editor. It has become boring where the same issues are being rehashed over and over again with very little constructive football comments.

25  John Raftery
08/09/2026    16:41:55

Unfortunately there are many fans seemingly content to wallow in their own misery. It’s what keeps them cheerful, I suppose.

Paul is absolutely correct. Nobody within the club would have wanted the transfer window to play out in the way it did. On reflection, rather than go through another shake-up, it will be more productive for them to learn the lessons and aim to do better in the future.

In regard to David Moyes, I am relieved he is in charge at this stage. He is a proven man manager who will extract the most from the players available. Like Sean Dyche in 2023/24 he will galvanise the squad to deliver in a less than ideal situation.

Plainly it will be a relief if we can put plenty of points on the board

before the inevitable injuries and suspensions strike. Otherwise I am looking forward to seeing how a group of young players with skill, energy and pace can grow together. Sometimes out of adversity comes a sharp uptick in fortunes

26  John Collins
08/09/2026    17:09:40

Nobody within the club would have wanted the transfer window to play out in the way it did.

Are you sure on that John?

Looks like TFG were happy to not spend the full amount allowed by the ruling.

I agree on the core of young players growing together mate.

27  John Raftery
08/09/2026    20:52:27

John (26) The late bids for Zirkzee, Abraham and one or two others suggest someone was desperate to spend money, no matter how imprudently.

28  John Collins
09/09/2026    07:57:54

Were they not proposed loan deals John?

29  Benjamin Dyke
09/09/2026    10:47:54

Fully agree Paul with your sentiments and take here. Protests and boycotts because we don't sign an injured striker? Yeah it was gutting that next morning and felt like we'd been incompetent but I'm glad we recouped some money for Beto and as the Italian window shut 4 hours before ours they had to make a call. Who could have known Balogun is actually Baloknife and that our none-RB is actually pretty good and can shoot, unlike Hibbert who we adored for so many years and scored 0 in a million appearances. We're doing OK. George can bang a few in so can a few others. We'll come unstuck between now and January on occasion but we're much, much better now than we were 2 years ago even if the US guys are not liking taking on whole countries financially and need help. They're hardly stripping an asset by putting a mind-boggling £850 million in to Everton are they?

30  Swiss Tony
09/09/2026    12:26:44

Benjamin (47) - I could’ve sworn that Hibbert scored once but, having Googled, you’re right!

Like most, I woke up shocked and a little embarrassed on the morning after the transfer window closed. It looked disastrous and I genuinely feared what might happen next. It’s funny what a battling performance and a well deserved point can do to reset opinions and expectations!

Obviously, if we’d been thumped 0-4 on Sunday we’d probably all still be feeling pretty terrified!

31  Dennis Stevens
09/09/2026    12:45:23

I think Hibbo scored in his testimonial match - leading to the inevitable "riot".

32  Benjamin Dyke
09/09/2026    13:34:12

As Dennis said he scored in his testimonial match but never in a competitive game. First few minutes and AMN has already gone one better - let's hope he can also defend! He seems a great guy though from all his interviews and I'm pleased we finally got him about 4 years after our first attempt but better late than never!


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.