Ask yourself, in a season that promised so little once it became clear that the transfer window was going to end up being more frustrating and damaging than predominantly productive, what — or rather who — have been the genuinely exciting aspects of the campaign so far?

Thierno Barry’s four-goal haul in the first two matches, the continually impressive form of young Harrison Armstrong, and the hope and early signs of an injury-free season for Jarrad Branthwaite might make the list. For this writer, however, it’s been three players: Tyrique George, Hayden Hackney, and Tyler Dibling.

Which is why it is utterly maddening that all three players have found themselves dropped from David Moyes’s starting XI and, in the case of the latter two, left as completely unused substitutes in Saturday’s dismal loss to Chelsea.

Hackney arrived at Everton on the back of a season where he was named Championship Player of the Year and, pressed into action with a starting role in his Premier League game, he immediately looked at home in the top flight as the Blues beat Crystal Palace at Hill Dickinson Stadium on the opening day.

He followed that up with a game-changing introduction off the bench in the next home game, a 2–2 draw with Manchester United, during which he was involved in both of the Blues’ goals.

The first equaliser in that match was, of course, scored by George when he rocketed home Hackney’s pass with his right foot and the young winger was named Man of the Match for what appeared to be his breakthrough display after a difficult loan spell last season during which Moyes frequently overlooked him in favour of retaining faith in the likes of Dwight McNeil, a player with no future in Everton blue. His reward since has been one start, in the goalless draw at Spurs, and a mere 70 minutes worth of action since.

Then there is Dibling, another young signing who had a miserable first year at Everton but who, starting with some impressive outings in pre-season, finally appeared ready to take his chance. Typical of Moyes, he had to wait for the League Cup ties against Preston and Wolves to get one but on both occasions he showed up, no more so than against the Midlanders, when he put in his best display — and first 90-minute game — since arriving from Southampton. Since that Wolves game? 28 paltry minutes as a sub, but both times he did more with those brief cameos than many of his team-mates had managed in full matches.

As Ell Bretland outlined in his post-match piece last Saturday, Moyes is repeating the same mistakes that critically undermined the run-in to 2025/26 and cost Everton a place in Europe. His refusal to make the best use of the playing personnel at his disposal meant a jaded and over-worked team stumbled over the line and finished a disappointing 13th.

And his stubborn, safety-first approach at the very least prevented the Toffees from making a go of the final stages against Chelsea. Instead of throwing on the enterprising, forward-thinking Hackney to chase the game, Moyes introduced a painfully unfit holding midfielder in Christian Nørgaard whose foul set up Pedro Neto’s killer second goal.

Instead of replacing Jack Grealish with the precocious and unpredictable talents of Dibling, he opted for his tried and trusted in Brennan Johnson who is both a totally different profile of player but also one who hasn’t demonstrated the same kind of bums-off-seats excitement that Dibling did in the few minutes he has been given this season.

Given the club’s failure to bolster the ranks at full-back and striker, Moyes has almost no options when it comes to team selection in certain areas of the pitch. As many fans have observed, that is often when he is at his best, and the opposite situation, in midfield and out wide, proves the point. Given the choice, he will almost always err on the most conservative option or the player that provides “legs” and graft over genuine flair.

It’s why he favoured Merlin Röhl, who is neither a right-back nor wide player, over any of his natural wingers against Chelsea; the crushing irony was that the very on-brand decision the Scot made was an effort to counter Pep Chavarría who didn’t even end up playing.

David Moyes is 63. Even at 43 during his first spell in charge at Everton, he was stubbornly and infuriatingly unadventurous. He managed to assemble a team that played some lovely football at times but the hallmark of his management has always been pragmatism and safety. He won’t ever change and calling on him to do so would be like shouting into a hurricane.

It doesn’t stop you desperately hoping the old leopard could change his spots, though. Because the game has changed. You can’t graft your way to success in the modern-day Premier League. You need dynamism in your team, attacking prowess, pace at full-back and out wide, an ability to both press opposition sides and beat their press with quick passing, triangles and movement. Moyes’s preferred starting XI from the most recent Premier League fixtures possesses too few of those vital ingredients but — and with all due deference to their youth and inexperience — there are many of those qualities that George, Dibling and Hackney can offer.

There is almost no chance that any of that trio will be in the line-up to face Arsenal this coming weekend, the type of game where Moyes routinely falls back on his arch conservatism. Perhaps the most we can expect is George to come off the bench late on.

The hope then is that they will be handed their chance in the League Cup tie against Newcastle next week, that the pressure to make every meager second they're given on the pitch won’t prove to be too much, and that they all grab it with both hands.

Barring a devastating injury crisis, it’s unlikely that Everton will be dragged into a relegation scrap; with a self-imposed ceiling on our ambitions and, one would hope, some security in the impression that the three promoted clubs will struggle to stay up, this season should be something of a free hit.

An opportunity to use every member and facet of the squad, to develop the younger players and enhance their value to the club on the pitch or in the market should they needed to be moved on.

More than that, after years of struggle and mediocrity, it’s a chance to give match-going fans something to look forward to watching, young players to support and to enjoy watching them blossom. And who knows, they might even help us win a few games and make the chore of following this confounding institution fun even while it remains in frustrating limbo off the pitch.

Read More

Reader Responses

Selected thoughts from readers
Certain off-topic comments may be removed to keep the discussion on track

1  Jerome Shields
20/10/2026    07:07:00

Having said all that he could beat Arsenal and Newcastle by some fluke.One player could hit form or get a lucky break and galvanise the team organised by Moyes overcoming his innate deliberate caution tactics on the day.But there would still be no younger player development plan or change in match preparation.I have learnt that over the years. Moyes does have the players, I don't believe he doesn't.

2  John Collins
20/10/2026    08:14:28

Law of averages may play a part Jerome.
Don't think he has ever won at Arsenal in around 25-30 attempts

3  John Collins
20/10/2026    08:28:24

Morning Lyndon,

Fantastic,bang on the money article.

I have to disagree with one point though.
Ive watched almost every team in the Prem after last nights game,every team I have seen is more vibrant and forward thinking than us,Coventry included.
I can see a bottom 5 finish being honest.
Id take 16th now.

4  Ian Wilkins
20/10/2026    09:29:12

As you say you can’t graft your way to success. But you can graft your way to PL survival and that is the extent of Moyes and his masters TFG’s ambitions.
Playing youngsters who don’t strictly follow the formula creates risk that has no place in Moyes football world.

5  Jerome Shields
20/10/2026    09:34:08

John#2

The Arsenal game was always a barometer of Everton's promise.But Arteta will know to be careful and that could get Everton into the game.

6  John Collins
20/10/2026    09:38:08

Jerome.
All due respect.It wont.
Why will Arteta know he needs to be careful?

7  Raymond Fox
20/10/2026    10:33:30

I don't think it's necessarily lack of ambition it's more they realise that they are banging their heads against a brick wall.

I also would like to see more of our very promising young players but it's a long season and they will probably be called upon against the lesser teams.

I think Moyes knows we are going to get short handed at some stage of the season and he's more interested in getting points on the board early because we might struggle later, so it's batten down the hatches again.

Lets be honest with the squad we have we have no chance of troubling the top of the table.

8  Kevin Molloy
20/10/2026    10:40:06

It's not just poor squad depth though, it's poor prioritisation of our resources. We spend £20m on Hackney, and don't play him. Forty on Dibling, twenty on George. Meanwhile we have an urgent need for a competent right back, and spend less than £5m on a journeyman. We've known for three years we needed a right back. It's beyond negligent. Also, if he's not going to play O'brien, he could have brought in another twenty, so why keep him just to keep him on the bench.
this is a critical period for Moyes, I don't think he realises what an awful impression he left when he brought Norgaard on. It was brainless.

9  John Fitzgerald
20/10/2026    10:50:07

Kevin - Moyes said in his post-match interview it was his wrong decision to bring on Nøorgard because he was clearly not match fit. To be fair to him, he owned it.

10  Andy Merrick
20/10/2026    11:02:18

Someone should buy Moyes a Tshirt and see if he wears that...
Make up your own slogan...
Safety first...Defense is the last line of attack...Keep it tight...

11  John Fitzgerald
20/10/2026    11:02:46

I’d also say that not playing our dynamic young talent is probably less of a concern than the recent form of more experienced players - especially Maitland-Niles and Pickford. We were able to shut Arsenal out for almost the whole game last time down there in a Moyes defensive masterclass, but the form those two are in - we’ll be lucky to get to half-time with a clean sheet. I’d put Garner in for Maitland Niles - especially against Eze, and Hackney to start, but we know that won’t happen.

12  Kevin Molloy
20/10/2026    11:32:29

thanks John, it wasn't just that he was unfit, why bring on a defensive midfielder when you are chasing the game, when you have a galaxy of attacking talent alongside him?

13  Raymond Fox
20/10/2026    11:40:23

It was a strange decision Kevin as we were only one down then and we had only made one clear cut goal chance up to then.

14  Paul Conway
20/10/2026    11:53:00

John @ 9

With all due respect, I’m not arguing with you for the sake of argument, I’m simply explaining my own opinion.

Moyes said he wasn’t Fit.

without not wanting come over as a Moyes Basher, for the sake of it, although, I’m very critical of him, these comments give me reason to be more Critical.

Norgaard Came on at 85 minutes. With the injury time added, after the unfortunate incident involving Martinez, there were due at least another 15 minutes.

That means that Norgaard had about twenty minutes on the field.

In that space of time he was absolutely calamitous, giving the Ball away and committing a Foul, leading to a free kick for Chelsea.

Now, I find it hard to believe, that that was due to not being fit.

He had three weeks during the international Break to get back ( as he was showing signs of before it), to full fitness and be assessed, by both the physiotherapist and Moyes himself.

I could understand him being a little off the pace, in a foot race, or leaning his hands on his knees, while tired, but these were technical errors he committed.

IMHO, he shouldn’t have been bought in the first place, let alone being bought while injured.

We were already well equipped in midfield, it was Defence and attack, that needed addressing

I suppose we’ll just have to strap ourselves in, for some more absolute gems from The Dour One

15  John Fitzgerald
20/10/2026    12:02:09

To Moyes, bringing on attacking talent at 0-1 down means leaving holes in midfield, it’s just not in his nature to go for it. Especially against Chelsea’s forward line.

To that, I’d remind him of Dibling’s 50 yard sprint against Wolves to make that superb tackle - that had all our bench on their feet applauding. We badly needed that dynamism at that point of the game. I suspect Moyes knows full well he messed it up.

16  Jack Convery
20/10/2026    12:10:21

A bit more proactive thinking, would have resulted in wins against HUll and Manure. We struggled against 10 man Ipswich because he has no clue and never has, ay how to actually go out and win a match. Arsenal are not in good form. Stuffed by Brighton and struggled against a struggling Forest. FFS Myesiah go and have a go. What have you got to lose - apart from a dismal as feck record against Arsenal. Chelsea was a disgrace, surprise us all and win.

PS They play BAyern on Wednesday, we've got a free week. Does that come into his thinking ? One can only hope.

17  Antony Abrahams
20/10/2026    13:07:00

Quite a few posters have been critical of David Moyes, for a long time, and this was echoed on another thread yesterday by John P.

All the Moyes haters, who used to make Toffeeweb, a much worse place, or words to that affect, when it’s nothing but clear to most of us that everything negative they write about David, has got merit.

He has been dealt a bad hand, but Lyndon, is talking about the players who are already here rather than the players who we never signed, and because the biggest criticism I have always had against Moyes, is that he doesn’t know how to rotate the players and implement the full use of his squad, then it’s just unfortunately going over old ground, once again.

18  John Fitzgerald
20/10/2026    13:26:57

Paul @ 14 - 3 weeks back in training after that length of a lay off, for a slow player like Nøorgard doesn’t sound like anywhere near enough time to get match fitness - physically or mentally. He should be playing a few U 21 games as an overage player to get his alertness back.
I was really keen on him when he signed and I know a couple of Brentford fans who rave about him - he’s got old-school number 6 qualities to anticipate and snuff out attacks, but he’s going to need an Armstrong or Garner to compensate for his lack of pace. I just hope he doesn’t end up being Moyes’s new Soucek. 32 and slow is pushing it in the PL.

19  Jerome Shields
20/10/2026    13:43:10

John#6

Moyes managed Arteta and knows what can happen if the ducks line up in a row for Moyes.He was Moyes playmaker . He definitely has the players, most posters complaint are about his reluctance to change and rotate players.

20  John Collins
20/10/2026    13:50:16

On a scale of 1-100 Jerome, how confident are you of us getting a point?

Also,given he has the players to get something at Arsenal, what team would you select?

21  Raymond Fox
20/10/2026    13:55:10

What we really need is new owners, a new manager and half a new team.
Oh, and scrapping of the SCR rules.

22  David Bromwell
20/10/2026    14:50:40

It would be difficult to find any criticism of your article Lyndon, or of the comments which followed it, trouble is it all makes for depressing reading. It also means that as a fan I have little hope that we will do any better against Arsenal this weekend and I wonder how the players feel. It's really frustrating as we have a number of talented players but the Managers refusal to play them is proving costly. George and Hackney should be nailed on starters against Arsenal, even if this means Garner has to play full back, however, what we do about poor Barry this weekend I have no idea, as chances are that he is unlikely to get a kick against the Arsenal centre backs, I think Beto would have been a better option.

23  Jay Harris
20/10/2026    16:06:37

John # 20 team selection and substitution management is my biggest criticism of Moyes who does a few things well but cannot put the icing on the cake due to his own self defeated attitude.

I would tell Jimmy Garner he has to play RB until January when we hope to get a decent RB in.

I would bring Hackney into that MF position.

I would play Dibling and tell Johnson he has to fight for his place and I would bench KDH and put Grealish in as a 10 with George on the flanks.

I would also bring JOB on for the last 15 minutes to give Jarrad a rest depending on how things were looking.

I would also bring Charlie on for Barry on 65 minutes and look to bring Rohl and KDH on when some legs are tiring.

Over to you Davey boy show us you have an open mind.

24  Lyndon Lloyd
20/10/2026    16:35:20

Well said, John (18). Honestly, if Moyes had put Hackney and Dibling on and we'd had a right go, I wouldn't have minded if we'd conceded as a result because a) we gave away a second goal anyway and b) I'd least have felt like we tried.

Ipswich were dead and buried at the Etihad at the weekend but kept going right to the final whistle and tried to make it 3–3. They could just have easily have lost 4–2 (like Sunderland lost 5–3 there) but it's a much better watch than doing nothing of note and losing 3–0.

25  John Raftery
20/10/2026    17:00:36

Like John @ 3, I am not wholly convinced we won’t be dragged near to the foot of the table. In 2001/02 season we collected ten points from the opening seven games. That was as good as it got. We subsequently plummeted down the league. Walter Smith was sacked in March to be replaced by David Moyes. With the help of the new manager bounce we scraped enough wins to survive.

Not so much the result but the performance against Chelsea coupled with the failure to beat Hull left me wondering where and when we will win enough matches to stay clear of the strugglers, none of whom look completely devoid of hope.

A year ago, the trio of Garner, Dewsbury-Hall and Grealish, ably supported by the two Senagalese, Ndiaye and Gana Gueye, looked fresh and exciting. Now, although the two midfielders are still the mainstays of the team and continue to run the hard yards at over 11 kilometres per match, we have less control in matches while the deployment of Jack has become too predictable to trouble opponents other than in occasional moments.

Therefore few would disagree the team’s attacking play needs to be rejuvenated. The best, arguably only, options are Hackney, George and Dibling. I suspect we will learn very soon if they are capable of delivering the improvement required.

One explanation for Moyes’s caution about using them is the inevitable rush to judgment by some fans about individual players; for example Nørgaard written off after a poor fifteen minutes, Maitland-Niles lauded after his late equaliser against Manchester United but now dismissed as a no hoper after two ineffective performances and Johnson struggling to make an impact in his early appearances. Those three are established players, more likely to possess sufficient mental resilience to cope with criticism.

That’s less likely in younger players especially in a team which has yet to establish a consistent, effective pattern of play. Already there are a few murmurings about the worth of Harrison Armstrong’s contribution in relation to his early yellow cards and impact in the final third. As we know reputations are easily boosted for individuals sitting on the bench especially when preferred options fail to deliver. Those reputations are easily lost when they are confronted with the reality of needing to prove themselves in a team not wholly at ease with itself.

All that noted, I think nevertheless we are at the point at which Moyes must introduce more pace and energy into our play by selecting the two young wide players in starting roles. If not now, then when would be a legitimate question. In my view it would be better now while we still have a cushion rather than later when we might well be in the proverbial.

26  Jerome Shields
20/10/2026    18:50:38

My main concern was the attitude of being 1-0 down against Chelsea with 15 minutes to go.I think he brought on a defensive midfielder to consolidate and nick a draw, by getting the right ball drop to the right player or a set piece.He got it badly wrong, even though the defensive midfield was unfit.It was negative tactics that was deservedly punished.If he had have put on Dibling or Hackney he may have got the same result, but there was more likely a chance to score.

John#20

I would not place a bet on the Arsenal result, but have seen this type of situation before with Moyes and had to eat humble pie.

I would drop Glealish and play younger players like Hackney and younger players to get the ball forward quicker.I would play Braithwaite and O Brien to play the defensive line up the field a bit, to reduce gaps and have pace to recover.I would chance AMN at right back,he surely can't make errors in a third match.

But Moyes may just adjust midfield.AMN will play and hopefully Grealish can be less of a carthorse.


27  Peter Mills
20/10/2026    19:07:56

Tongue in cheek, perhaps, but it’s beginning to look like a carefully orchestrated plan to get rid of concessionary season ticket holders!

Never have I heard such disillusionment from my contemporaries (I’m aged 70) about the pain of getting to the stadium, and the dross we have to witness once we get there. Maybe the Club needs to lose these hangers-on?

Those of us who remember the young Colin Harvey, Jimmy Husband and Joe Royle, come to that Kevin Ratcliffe and Graeme Sharp, recall the game time those young players were given to develop their careers. It seems it can’t happen now.

28  John Collins
20/10/2026    19:54:20

"I would not place a bet on the Arsenal result, but have seen this type of situation before with Moyes and had to eat humble pie."

You havent seen it at Highbury or The Emirates Jerome, hasn't happened in 27 attempts.
What game had you eating humble pie?

29  Philip Sheehan
20/10/2026    21:24:05

got to agree with ray @ 21 and add scrapping var to that list.
i'm sure most evertonians are fed up with moyes - its like deja vu all over again.
the negativity and safety first football will make it a nervous end to this season.
i hope I am wrong but with tfg not spending our mini squad will only be depleted further when injuries happen - goals win games and we certainly ain't got a load of goals in this squad

30  Raymond Fox
20/10/2026    21:47:24

We are only 15/2 to win at Arsenal - don't laugh.
We should be 20/1, I'll eat both my hat and my shoes if we win.

31  John Collins
20/10/2026    22:29:24

Arsenal to score in both halfs is my bet Raymond.
6/5

32  Jerome Shields
21/10/2026    01:19:04

John#28

It is more a general comment than related to Arsenal, but I am hopeful.I am glad I started the thread with it,rather than producing Moyes Achilles heal against the traditional Top Six.One was the Man United dust up.

33  John Collins
21/10/2026    08:18:08

Apologies Jerome.

I didn't realise you were playing devils advocate

34  Steve Brown
21/10/2026    10:16:01

In 241 league games against the ‘Big Six’, Moyes has 1 away win against Arsenal (for West Ham) and 1 against Man Utd (last season); he has never won away to Liverpool or Chelsea.

I’d love to think anything is possible, but with Moyes we can probably predict the line-up, gameplan, timing of substitutions and result.

35  John Fitzgerald
21/10/2026    10:48:22

Steve -yes, you’re right, it’s a terrible stat alright, but he did win away at Chelsea once - an FA Cup qualifier - on penalties. Seem to remember Phil “point and shout” Neville got the winner.
I wonder what the odds will be on a win at Anfield this season?

36  Steve Hogan
21/10/2026    12:33:13

I have to say, Moyes bizarre substitutions and initial team selection for the Chelsea game, only adds to the clamour for a change of manager at the end of the season.

Sure he has been dealt a bad hand, when TFG decided to bale out recently, and stop anymore financial support in January, but for a manager with his amount of Premier league experience, to select a player, who my old granny could see was no-where near fit, was quite alarming.

What input did his coaching staff have on his decision, surely they collectively must have been embarrassed at what unfolded before their eyes?

I wonder did we witness a turning point in the majority of fans eyes, in their opinions on Moyes, who has probably enjoyed a 50/50 ratio on his popularity amongst the Everton fanbase.

I'm struggling to think of an Everton manager who has got a player substitution so spectacularly wrong in the last thirty years.

There are younger more progressive managers out there at the moment, playing a much more attractive brand of football, (they may not have Moyes's experience), but this team arn't great to watch, let's be honest, slow and predictable in attack, despite having the likes of Dibling and George available, but Moyes simply doesnt trust them.

Come January, the predators will be circling again, with Branthwaite, Armstrong and a few others, maybe considering their futures, at, let's face it, a club stuck in limbo, and likely to finish in a lower mid-table position.

We need new owners asap, to give us renewed optimism and some hope for the future.

37  John Fitzgerald
21/10/2026    13:56:49

I can’t think of any other fanbase that have had to slightly obsess about the behaviour patterns and decision-making of their manager - for the period of time like we have had with Moyes. At least with Ferguson and Wenger they saw trophies and success, with us it feels like some sort of Groundhog Day loop of the same fare every week - like Steve said @ 34, it is and has been tiresomely predictable for far too long now. Imagine having a coach/ manager who regularly switched things around according to opposition and player form - to good effect? I can’t even remember what that’s like.

38  Philip Sheehan
21/10/2026    14:16:42

steve @ 36, dibling and george are (in moyes's eyes) boys, both 20 years old. hackney 24 yrs. much better they sit on the bench and get a well earned rest. we certainly don't want them getting match fit for when the inevitable injuries happen !
as for input from the coaching staff I wonder if irvine is like phil neal was to graham taylor as england manager -yes boss, mo boss, yes boss !
who are these multitude of people anyway ? bring back harry catterick, wilf dixon and one sub usually sandy brown oh and a white enamel bucket with the magic sponge

39  Robert Tressell
21/10/2026    14:32:35

It’s pretty straightforward with Moyes - he’s a very good manager at certain things.

He is very good at organising a team in a defensive shape, developing and sometimes rehabilitating players (especially turning quite ordinary or stagnating players into very good ones), creating a good team spirit and outperforming the level of investment in the playing squad.

Given that we currently have the 5th cheapest put together squad in the Premier League - and also the smallest squad in the Premier League, Moyes is a good fit.

He is not holding us back in terms of results over a season.

Certainly you can criticise his matchday performance - and he is an annoying manager. But I believe he sets up the squad to play the season, not each match as such. And in approaching things that way he is successful - doing a lot better consistently than rise and fall managers who get found out very quickly.

However, he is a very annoying manager too.

Consistently manages down expectations (which is annoying even when realistic).

Consistently uses passive tactics and we so often fail to get going until the opposition score.

Struggles to create a strong footballing identity (although will do that after sufficient investment in the playing squad).

Typically works better with more limited players than stars.

So he isn’t the guy for the next stage of our development into a Villa / Newcastle standard club on the fringes of the Champions League places but he is, alas, a very good fit for where we are now - given the level of investment in the playing squad.

We could so easily be a basket case club and we are not. We’re looking down on a lot of clubs still after a decent start with only one defeat. He is likely to hand us over in much better shape than he found us with - as things stand - very, very restrained investment to the poor and tiny squad he took over.

It’s boring. It’s really boring. But he isn’t a disaster for us - far from it.

40  Philip Sheehan
21/10/2026    15:40:48

robert I beg to differ WE ARE A BASKET CASE CLUB we lurch from one crisis to another ;
last season with a lot more to spend than dyche ever got we finished 13th with 49 points.
a one point improvement on 24-25 season...i acknowledge moyes has been let down by tfg and the elite recruitment team.
but we need to shake it up a bit ffs lets be realistic - I predict we will finish in the bottom 5 please don't call me a moyes hater, if you do you must be a moyes lover !
so no I very much doubt we will be in a better shape when he leaves - so far the fixtures have been kind to us.i'm going to say the 2 newcastle games will show us where moyes's priority lies.

41  Raymond Fox
21/10/2026    15:43:40

Well said Robert, I think the only thing the owner desires this season is for us to stay in the division now the club is on the market.

We should do that no problem, there are 9 teams in our league playing in Europe this season and that will hinder some or all of them.

Moyes has his faults like all managers do, but when you watch the team he picks do you see much good football from them, no they don't appear capable of making nearly enough goal chances. Backwards and sideways passes they are good at, but good forward ones forget it.

Our biggest problem is most of them are very average Prem. players.

42  Robert Tressell
21/10/2026    15:49:52

Philip # 40 - what is the current crisis that we are in? We are joint 6th, have only one defeat all season, have won our cup games and are 3 points off the champions league?

43  David Bromwell
21/10/2026    15:56:00

Robert at 39, from a fans view point I cannot see the point in boring football and I don't think it's good for the players. Saturday was a good example when we tried to contain Chelsea and it didn't work, and half of our supporters had left before the final whistle. We had of course become used to boring football at G P but things are different now, as we do have some exciting players but it would be nice to see them play. Haven't our neighbours recently sacked a 'successful ' but boring manager ? Good for them I say as I have seen enough boring football to last me a lifetime.

44  John Collins
21/10/2026    15:56:18

Robert 39.

What certain things is Moyes very good at?

I read your 2nd para but have seen no evidence of any of your points this season.

45  John Collins
21/10/2026    16:00:13

"He is not holding us back in terms of results over a season"

13th ok with you?

46  Robert Tressell
21/10/2026    16:05:05

No John it is not good enough for me - which is why I am looking forward to the day when are not lagging behind Ipswich in spending - but are competing financially with clubs like Villa and Newcastle - because then we will start to inevitably see us back in the upper echelons of the Premier League and Champions League runs. That is just how it works.

47  Robert Tressell
21/10/2026    16:17:57

No David, our neighbours did not sack a boring manager for an exciting one. I don’t know where you would get that idea. The RS sacked a manager who oversaw spending of nearly €500m worth of new players on a title winning side. Instead of dominating at home and abroad as they could fairly have expected - they finished 5th and got schooled in the Champions League. Slot was sacked for massively underperforming investment in the playing squad.

They have replaced Slot with a manager who finished 6th and has only ever won a trophy in Cyprus. They did this not becausr they accept mediocrity but because - as above - they recognise that coaching achievements are relative to investment in the playing squad.

48  Steve Brown
21/10/2026    16:19:45

I think the aim in hiring Moyes was to ensure we remained in the Premier League while TFG tidied up the debt, showed a modest growth in commercial revenue and overhauled the leadership team before flipping the club.

He is probably a sensible choice to see us through the sale process with no further investment, but I don’t think he will make it. Moyes has too many glitches in his managerial make-up - we all know them - and this is a weaker squad than last season.

2 wins in 14 league games suggests a long-term downward trend, and if we are not in trouble in the league yet then we will be by Christmas.

49  Robert Tressell
21/10/2026    16:54:53

Steve you might be right but this season only 6 clubs have won more Premier League games than us and only 5 have more points. We also have only 1 defeat and a positive goal difference. I don’t expect us to remain joint 5th by any stretch (since that would be massive overperformance). But it is a real stretch to position that as a bad start or some kind of bellwether for relegation form.

Moyes is an annoying manager and limited in many ways - but our real slump started in 2021 when Moshiri pulled the plug financially on an Ancelotti side that finished (from memory) 12th.

50  John Fitzgerald
21/10/2026    16:57:56

An intelligent, well-rounded analysis, Robert. The most frustrating thing with Moyes for me is the feeling that he’s not hugely far off making us a better, more dynamic watch - starting George and bringing in subs earlier is an easy and obvious starting point, as well as setup to score in first halves, but we’re not experiencing the struggles of United, Spurs, Newcastle, Sunderland, Palace or Fulham, almost all of whom have had much more money thrown at them. They’ve got bigger problems than us, but with bigger squads.

We’ll finish higher than last season, Moyes will go and we’ll have new owners who might even turn up at games. Everything will be a bit meh until then.

51  Steve Brown
21/10/2026    17:06:38

Robert @ 47,

Investment is critical, but it rarely succeeds without top class strategy and leadership, football operations, recruitment and analytics, coaching and a strong academy pipeline. Liverpool were world-class in these areas, and once the standards dropped off the money began to be wasted. That has been the case at Man Utd for 10 years, resulting in £1.25 billion being squandered.

I hope that Everton focus on these areas with a long-term plan if we are to make the best use of new investment.

52  John Collins
21/10/2026    17:31:18

If only the manager had the optimism of posters above.
He might actually try to win a game

53  Les Callan
21/10/2026    17:46:00

Robert, we are hopeless. 2 wins in 14. We have two poor full backs and a centre forward akin to Mr Bean. I’m nodding off after ten minutes. The next four games are crucial. Forget Arsenal. As someone else has reported, Moyes has two wins in 241 away games to the “ big 6 “. So If we fail against Newcastle, the Coventry game becomes immense. And given that we have struggled against the other two promoted teams, a win there is no formality.
NSNO. Yer ‘avin a laugh.

54  John Fitzgerald
21/10/2026    18:19:49

Les “Moyes has two wins in 241 away games to the “ big 6”.
Not true. His record is bad, but it’s 11 wins in 122 matches, including his stints at West Ham and Sunderland.

55  Philip Sheehan
21/10/2026    18:33:09

robert @ 42 so we are joint 6th and still in the league cup. ok stop the season now and we are in europe but like the song says 'it's not where you start it's where you finish'
DM certainly divides opinion does'nt he ? I was ok with him in his 1st spell until his knives to a gunfight churchillian speech WOW ! that must have inspired our boys in the royal blue jerseys !
our current crisis well smallest squad in the epl - one erratic striker - no spends in january - and club up for sale maybe players out in january as desperate dan needs all his dosh for roma and his nhl team - due to tfg policy of no communication uncertainty swirls around everton, all of these factors combined in my humble opinion constitute a crisis. hands up those who agree -some may think everything is great, barry will get 25 goals this season, european competition next season, oh and league & fa cup finals beckon in 2027-i will continue to be realistic !

56  Les Callan
21/10/2026    18:45:25

John @ 54. I’m only quoting what Steve said at 34. However, 11 in 122 is nothing to be proud of either.

57  John Collins
21/10/2026    18:59:48

Steve 51.

Como.
3rd division 5 years ago.
To the CL on a net spend of £60 million per season.
Shows it can be done on a relatively small spend.
Fabregas will be a Premier League manager soon.

58  Antony Abrahams
21/10/2026    21:03:55

I don’t think you will see a more insightful post, than what Steve B, writes in his first long paragraph@51.

It comes from the top, its why Liverpool, will keep going until they’re successful again under these present owners and it’s why Manchester United, won’t achieve the success that they took for granted before The Glaziers, bought the club.

Wenger, took a lot of stick in the end but he kept Arsenal, both relevant and significant, whilst having the lowest net spend in the division, because the money was all being used to build a new ground.

City’s owners have been caught bang to rights, similar with Chelsea, under Abramovich, but only because they had an incredible desire to win, and this to me is the most important thing.

You only achieve real success when you have got real desire, is one of the most crystal clear images, in sport.

59  Robert Tressell
21/10/2026    21:38:42

Steve # 51, absolutely - all correct. And these are all things you’ll have seen me say lots of times on these threads.

However the very clear thrust of so many of these threads is that our biggest problem is our manager - with the solution being to replace him with whoever is flavour of the month (the popularity contest has moved on from Potter to Frank to now Keith Andrews etc etc).

You can check the 5 year net spends on Transfermarkt too John C and it appears that Como are the biggest net spenders in Serie A in that period at €327m. Ahead of Juve (€313m) AC Milan (€267m) and Inter (€172m).

Fabregas is undoubtably a brilliant young manager destined to manage Champions League giants (as per his playing career) but he has not been without financial backing.

60  John Collins
21/10/2026    23:10:16

Your figures are what I posted Robert 59
Average £60 mil per season over 5 seasons.
Chicken feed by today's standards.
Proving it can be done

61  Jeff Armstrong
22/10/2026    05:35:11

Jerome #26, on the real time squad thread at #35 you said you thought Moyes had given up on a draw and brought on Norggard just to give him a run out.
At home, 0-1 down, with 20 minutes to go!
I called you out for talking nonsense, (again)now you say he brought him on to nick a draw.
Which one is it?

62  Jerome Shields
22/10/2026    07:03:05

Jeff.#61

The objective, in the last 15 minutes, always was to nick a draw, but not by being proactive, just playing percentages. That Everton in the last 15 minutes would get into the opposition quarter and that the ball would break and a forward players,any player, would get the right connection.Norggard just compounded that decision.This has worked quite a few times this season already.If he had any idea entering his head of winning, he would have made proactive changes.

63  John Collins
22/10/2026    08:19:42

Morning Jerome.

Struggling to recall the quite a few times it has worked this season?

65  Robert Tressell
22/10/2026    10:06:40

John C, I can’t tell if you’re joking to be honest. The moral of the Como statistics is that if you outspend everyone else in your domestic league then you can confidently expect Champions League football.

Bodo Glimt tend to get a decent set of results in the Champions League too but it doesn’t mean you can compete in the Prem on a Norwegian league budget.

It would be nice if your fairytales really did exist because it would mean all 20 clubs would be right in the mix for titles and trophies each season. But they’re not.

66  John Fitzgerald
22/10/2026    10:09:49

Jerome - you’re right - playing for a draw against a Chelsea side with better players in almost every position and the best front line in the league was the best Moyes could hope for once they’d scored. If you brought on the cavalry and went for a win the probability would’ve been a 0-4 score line. I’d still rather that Hackney, Dibling and especially George all featured in or more in the game, but once Chelsea got in front, there’s no way Moyes hopes for anything more than sneaking an equaliser on percentage play. KITANO fails miserably if you go 0-1 down against a team like Chelsea.

67  John Collins
22/10/2026    11:20:39

Robert.
Its not a joking matter the way this club is deteriorating rapidly.
My point was, and is,CL qualifying can be achieved on a smaller net spend budget of £60 mil per season, a figure that the majority of the Prem clubs exceeded this season.
Not Everton of course, we made a profit.
The point is, money or lack of it, is not the barrier to improvement you and others regularly suggest.

68  John Fitzgerald
22/10/2026    11:27:13

Why is the club deteriorating rapidly, John?

69  John Collins
22/10/2026    12:40:35

Brand new stadium,state of the art but with carpet bagger owners, who's only interest is profit margin.
Smallest playing squad in the Prem.
Defeatist manager who will not progress the club.
Fan base disillusion that is growing rapidly.
Apart from that,everything is great.

70  John Fitzgerald
22/10/2026    12:53:57

Those owners who don’t spend or attend games are selling up. That’s a positive, right? Unless you want them to stay?
Smallest squad in the PL with 12 teams currently below us most of whom have spent way more than us, with a few in full-blown crisis.
This “rapid” fan base disillusionment - what’s that based on?
Moyes can be frustrating, but we’ve known that for years. As it stands - today - we are a club over-performing with the resources we have. Of course it could all go to shit, but I’d rather not going down the Nostradamus-with-a-hangover route just yet.

71  John Collins
22/10/2026    12:55:10

Can you explain how the owners selling is a positive please?

72  Antony Abrahams
22/10/2026    14:33:50

It could go to shit quite easily, and loads of different thoughts often go through my head when I think about Everton football club, right now.

We are badly missing N’Diaye, and one day when a club constantly sells its best players, then bad things will eventually happen, imo.

Bad mismanagement, had us having to sell our better players for years, but this time it was down to the owners (even though a few people criticise N’Diaye) just not seeming that interested and not being that interested, definitely seems to be spreading amongst quite a few of the local match going fans that I speak to.

74  Steve Brown
22/10/2026    14:47:53

Results will decide the manager’s future - 2 wins in 14 league games says he is on a downward trajectory.

We might actually get to see Friedkin on Merseyside if he needs to stabilise the club’s results, as his ability to sell the club for the £250-£300 million profit he wants depends on it.

75  Steve Brown
22/10/2026    14:52:12

Sorry John @ 66, but that post is pure defeatism.

At no point did the manager try to win that game, and he got what he deserved. Absolutely nothing.

76  John Fitzgerald
22/10/2026    14:58:55

Steve - I know Moyes didn’t try to win that game. That’s exactly what I said.
John - you didn’t answer my questions - do you want the Friedkins to stay or do you want new ownership? And where’s this evidence of “rapid fanbase disillusionment”?

77  John Collins
22/10/2026    15:10:26

I want them out.John F.
How much do you think they will spend in January?

Your turn

78  John Fitzgerald
22/10/2026    15:30:38

Struggling with your logic John C - if you want them out why do you consider them doing exactly that as a bad thing?

79  John Collins
22/10/2026    16:24:33

TFG finished the summer transfer window in profit John.A clear strategy from them,blatant attempt to turn a £26 million profit into a £66 million with the Armstrong sale.

They will do the same in winter window.

The thread bare squad will be under pressure,especially given the inevitable injuries.

They don't care that we, the life blood of the club, know waht they are up to.

They will see any protests on the tv and not be at all interested in it.

I want them out but the timing will 100% be detrimental to our prospects.

Bottom line?

We need reinforcement.They wont provide it.

Still your turn to answer my question

81  Darren Hind
22/10/2026    18:27:39

The claim that TFG tried to sell Armstrong but were forced to do a U-Turn due to fan protest doesn't stack up for me. We know there was a bid for him and I think it's safe to say it was considered, but all evidence would suggest that the offer had already been turned down before the protest even happened.

And while I don't think they would have been too disappointed at making a profit in the last window, I don't think they deliberately set out to do so. They gave the go ahead to sign the Yank striker, Balogun. Nobody will convince me that they choreographed the comedy of errors which followed.

89  David Lynch
22/10/2026    22:20:26

We're having the same argument/disagreement we had under Moyes first time around.

Knives to gunfight,players out of position,poor tactics...the list goes on.

Oh the life of an Evertonian eh.

90  Jeff Armstrong
22/10/2026    22:25:15

Darren, why is it safe to say? and where is all the evidence you mention, that the Forest bid was considered, but would be ultimately turned down, before the news broke around 10 am on the morning of the Bournemouth game ?

This is breaking news from you as far as I’m concerned on this story.

91  Brendan Mclaughlin
22/10/2026    22:36:35

Jeff #90

(So good to do that...Toffeweb take notice)

Not sure about evidence but the fact that Armstrong played in that Bournemouth game suggested to me at least he wasn't going anywhere.

92  John Fitzgerald
22/10/2026    23:00:19

John - Bit of a weird move to try and make a profit out of the transfer window but then put up £40 million for Balogun. Your theory doesn’t really stack up, does it?
So, tell us - if you don’t want them as owners, but don’t want them to sell now - when is a good time to sell and why?

93  Darren Hind
22/10/2026    23:04:09

Armstrong had already been named in the team BEFORE the vast majority of fans who protested had even got into the ground.

The fact that Moyes was allowed to select him is evidence enough for me that the decision had been taken long before the protest

Mind you; If you think an international conglomerate was prepared to risk a 40m deal by allowing him to play in a match they clearly didnt care about, for a team they clearly didnt care about, or that they caved in to the demands of a few hundred fans thousands of miles away. You are perfectly at liberty to do so.

TFG dint flinch when the vast majority of 50,000 fans roundly booed the team off the BMD pitch on more than one occassion. Its a lovely romantic thought that 6-7 hundred fans forced their hand and made them keep Armstrong, But I would be surprised if they had even heard about a protest

94  Jeff Armstrong
22/10/2026    23:17:37

It’s obvious the international conglomerate who didn’t care about the club, the team or the fans didn’t even know we had a fixture that day.

Oh and there’s NEVER been 50,000 booing the team off at BMD, they’ve not been booed off yet and there’s only ever 25000 left at the final whistle even after a win!

95  Brendan Mclaughlin
22/10/2026    23:30:27

Jeff #94

International conglomerates know shit like that... that's why they are International

96  Jeff Armstrong
22/10/2026    23:36:06

Oh I thought they where international because they had branches in Paris, London and Peckham, didn’t realise they also knew Everton sometimes played Bournemouth at soccer on Saturday afternoons during a player franchise trade draft.

98  Kevin Molloy
23/10/2026    09:09:06

there is something fishy about the way that Armstrong story broke. Broken by the same journalist who brought the good news that they were getting the hell out (and most thought the Friekdins had given him the exclusive, he writes for a US publication after all). So why would the Friedkins decide to give the exclusive to the same journo whose pervious story had wrecked their £40m transfer...

99  Antony Abrahams
23/10/2026    10:32:49

The fans aren’t always wrong, is what was uttered by David Moyes, and the fact that Harrison Armstrong, has played in every game might indicate that the manager, demanded that the club keep the young player.

Hurry-up and sell. Reports are saying there are no takers at their current valuation, but like always, it depends on the buyers and how much real ambition they have got for Everton Football Club.

I personally hope it’s Usmanov - looking at the bigger picture, it was very cynical how quickly Everton, got dealt with, when it was clear that a good push off the side could have easily destroyed us for years, but we survived, even if it was only in the manner we have been surviving since Boxing Day 1999.

Everton, founder members of the Football league, pioneers, a very rich history, an incredible fan base and a fantastic new stadium, on the finest waterfront in Great Britain.

The fans are desperate for the right owners, because once they get the right owners, they know that Everton Football Club, will push on and become one of the biggest clubs in England again, but there is also a mood of despondency, because it is clear that TSF, were never in it for the long haul and this means that the club never took advantage of a great opportunity when moving into their new home.

100  Steve Brown
23/10/2026    10:35:43

Kevin, someone is leaking but who?

It is not likely to be soneone from the club. The CEO got 2 hours’ notice that TFG before the club statement was published on 9th October.

The Friedkins themselves had nothing to gain from the news of the proposed sale coming out at that time, and only responded when they realised the story was coming out in the Athletic.

101  Steve Brown
23/10/2026    10:49:27

John @ 76, not really.

You said that playing for a draw was the best he could hope for once we went a goal down. That just rationalises the negative game plan he employed for the entire 90 mins of that awful performance.

His approach was defeatist and comments like that just let him off the hook.

102  Kevin Molloy
23/10/2026    10:57:43

I don't see how it can't be the Friedkins Steve. The source knew both their confidential transfer plans, and their plans for sale of the club. Who else would be across two such distinct areas. they keep their dealings discrete and discreet.

103  John Fitzgerald
23/10/2026    11:42:45

Steve @ 101 You seem to keep missing the point where I said I wanted Hackney, Dibling and George to feature, ergo I wanted a team set up to win from the off, but we know that’s not the Moyes way. If you think it’s “defeatist “ to think that a high-scoring Chelsea team who average 3 goals a game would not have relished Everton going for a much bigger win, leaving gaps for that front line of theirs to exploit, that’s your perogative. I wasn’t defending Moyes, I was explaining his thinking.

BTW - what do you think the Arsenal result will be?

104  Steve Brown
23/10/2026    13:59:49

Sorry John F, I seem to have misread your post!

105  David Lynch
23/10/2026    14:29:08

"I personally hope it’s Usmanov - looking at the bigger picture, it was very cynical how quickly Everton, got dealt with, when it was clear that a good push off the side could have easily destroyed us for years.
Everton, founder members of the Football league, pioneers, a very rich history, an incredible fan base and a fantastic new stadium, on the finest waterfront in Great Britain".

Anthony...the FA is now a cash cow, they don't give a flying fuck for our or any other club beyond the "Sly Six".

History to them started with the Prem and the more money the six bring in will only further destroy the soul and integrity of the game.

It won't be until the fans outside of the six rise up and somehow restore some fairness and honesty back into the game, that things will change.

How that will happen? God knows, but something will have to give otherwise the game will eat itself through greed and corruption.

106  Robert Tressell
23/10/2026    15:17:36

You may get your wish Tony. There are a lot of reports suggesting Usmanov is looking to invest. Indeed, it wouldn't surprise me if that is what is behind TFG's sudden willingness to sell.

By all accounts he's just won (of sorts) a protracted legal case in Germany which eases his sanctions although doesn't remove them entirely in the UK. However, it probably does put him in a position to reunite (one way or another) with the stadium he undoubtably funded.

If he does buy us outright, then I suspect it will accelerate our route back to the top table. It may also neatly coincide with Man City's (probably temporary) demise - resulting from some compromise form of punishment that sets them back a few years. That - alongside the continued dysfunctional situation at Spurs and Man Utd - make this an interesting opportunity to really disrupt the Rich 6.

So, all good in some ways.

But I'll be honest I would find it a sad state of affairs if that is the outcome. There's a lot of disdain for private equity on these pages but, although not perfect by any stretch, I prefer that sort of ownership to connections with the Russian Mafia, Heroin trafficking, Putin and the war in Ukraine.

107  Steve Brown
23/10/2026    16:07:01

John @ 103, I always think Everton are going to win despite the overwhelming evidence. 1-0 to us.

108  Steve Brown
23/10/2026    16:09:50

There is zero chance that a Russian will be allowed to invest in or purchase a Premier League club at present.

109  Jerome Shields
23/10/2026    18:12:24

John #63

· vs Bournemouth – James Tarkowski, 91st minute (1–1)

· vs Manchester United – Ainsley Maitland-Niles, 96th minute (2–2)

· vs Hull City – 2–2 draw (11 Oct 2026); Everton led 2–1 but Hull equalised in the 74th minute.

Actually I wasn't trying to play devil's advocate I was hoping and trying to avoid Moyes feeding me humble pie, which I hate.

And John TFG selling is not a good thing on they are trying to get £250m - £350 m out on the Sale and leave _£500 m in debt.

I don't think they will spend in the January Transfer Window. They might if they sell someone, but then they might keep the money, like they did this Summer.

110  Jerome Shields
23/10/2026    18:29:15

Apologies John sneaked the Hull result in.I thought Moyes settled for a draw.

111  Robert Tressell
23/10/2026    18:41:28

Jerome, the proof of the pudding is in the eating. The fact that TFG might make a profit from their endeavours, doesn't automatically make the sale a bad thing. I'd be much more worried if they were making a loss - because that's when sellers entertain offers from real jackals.

I know what you're getting at too, Steve, but it's a funny (peculiar) world. I wouldn't completely rule out our old Uzbek friend returning in some form (whether in the shadows or front and centre).

And I wouldn't completely rule out additional spending in January, Jerome. We don't know how slow or fast the sale process might go (something could be quite advanced already).

112  Antony Abrahams
23/10/2026    20:46:39

Your last paragraph has got me googling “the opium wars” Robert!

That’s why I wrote that I thought it was very cynical Dave, as we await the punishment that bestows - (sarcastically) Manchester City.

113  Don Alexander
23/10/2026    23:07:52

To me it's obvious that Toyota's greatest-ever salesman (according to one of us) in Trump's US will not hesitate to sell cheaply any of our small squad in January or for however long the leech continues to suck the lifeblood out of us. He'll allow signings for next to nowt to preserve Premier League status of course but to me he's the bastard son of Kenwright.

Dave Lynch at #105 sums the current state of football up, with our thoroughly discredited Premier League "bosses" now maybe under threat of having to walk the plank, with Man Corrupt of course, as a result of blindingly obvious cheating for years.

As Dave infers, can fans across the non-Sky-babe teams now exert enough pressure by ceasing to pay ANYTHING more at all IMMEDIATELY to help shatter the odious confidence that people like Friedkin/Usmanov et al have in taking massive monetary advantage of loyal, honest (generally maybe!) committed fans all over our country?

It may well be a once and for all opportunity if we could all get it together, but can we? I hope so.

114  Jerome Shields
23/10/2026    23:40:19

Robert#111

Fair enough on the figures.TFG did pay £331m for Everton. But the point stands. They take cash out at exit and the club still carries the debt. The honest test is simple: what did they put in, and what do they take out? If they take out more, that's extraction; if they just get their money back, it's a normal return. Nobody's published that number.

But the bigger issue is that it's secondary. Everton still isn't sustainable: it needs owner funding to survive, losses are only manageable because of refinancing, and the squad has to be traded to stay compliant.

In January SCR headroom is thin.Any spending has to be funded by a sale or more borrowing. The squad gets traded to fund the club, not the other way round.

And Robert, the IFR's own report says Everton aren't alone in this. 94% of clubs are loss-making, 32 can't survive 30 days without owner funding, and a fifth of the Premier League is technically insolvent. So this isn't an Everton problem.You could say it is the Operating Model.in the Premier League.

.

115  Antony Abrahams
24/10/2026    08:31:29

Has I was standing by the edge - I could see the faces of those who lead - pissing themselves laughing. Their mad eyes bulged - their flushed faces sang - the weak get crushed as the strong grow stronger.

A song written many years ago by The Jam, called Funeral Pyre, is definitely a great metaphor, for The EPL, and football in general.

I have always said that Football reflects life, so to hear a politician, saying just the other day, that the country’s debt, is both astounding and unsustainable, made a lot of sense to me.

Will this affect the judgement, when Manchester City, are eventually punished?

116  Jerome Shields
24/10/2026    12:02:13

Tony#115

I have found when playing a song on the Uku that it is only then that you realise their meaning.

Funeral Pyre by The Jam actually nails it : the leaders laughing while the structure burns. The Premier League and IFR police liquidity and funding, not solvency. The charges catch symptoms — inflated revenue, losses, owner loans, non-cooperation — not whether a club is sound if the owner walks.

Until football licenses solvency: equity, debt caps, stress tests, resolution, the strong keep growing stronger and the weak get crushed by rules aimed at the smoke, not the fire.So the Man City breaches are about liquidity , the structural Solvency problem could be weaponised against them.

Everton is a case in point penalised for liquidity breaches, while the Solvency was getting ripped off out the back door.

117  Robert Tressell
24/10/2026    14:50:44

Jerome # 114, I expect TFG will will want to make some profit for the best part of 2 years' work. That's not extraction / asset stripping - it's the principle behind pretty much any work or investment. Only sovereign states and shady individuals expect no financial return from owning a Premier League football club - because they are in it to launder a reputation, not make money.

And why is the headroom so thin on SCR in January? We obviously had up to £45m to spend up to the final minutes of the summer window closing. Why, with our revenue increasing all the time, has that disappeared? I accept the willingness to spend might now have changed - but you seem to be talking about ability (SCR limits) to spend, not willingness.

As to the point about the IFR report, it's an interesting observation but I'm not sure what the relevance is.

118  Jerome Shields
26/10/2026    16:14:13

Robert#117

Everton sold players and had cash to spend, but the new signings' wages and fees already used up most of their spending allowance under the rules. So even though they have money, the rules say they can't spend much more without breaking the limit.Rising Stadium revenue has no impact on this in the January Transfer window.

I agree that TFG are entitled to get some capital out.Selling there stake for £1 billion will give them little return.It is not they have bit off more than they can chew,it is they are having to chew more than they expected.The better return is selling a stake that takes Multi Club Rules out of the equation.This would give them a premium on the share they sell,greater than selling the whole lot and their remaining shares would Benifit from increased Stadium income.

It is complicated stuff this, but you seem to be able to ask the right question, which I find help in me trying to understand.
.


Add Your Thoughts

Only registered users of Evertonia can participate in discussions.

» Log in now

Or Join as Evertonia Member — it takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your thoughts on artices across the site.